Re: How do keertanis make a living?
Kawaljeet Singh · 25 Apr 2006
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh,
With all clear facts i am mentioning that Manpreet singh is such holy spirit that i have seen never before.
at this time he is just worshiping GOD.
Please take care to write anything about these type of holy and denine spirits.
thaks
with regards
Kawaljeet Singh Khalsa
Re: How do keertanis make a living?
Harmeet Singh · 25 Apr 2006
vjkk, vjkf
Bhai Tejinderpal Singh Jee is a Homopathic Doctor and I believe that Bhai Harpreet Singh Jee is a engineer. Bhai Manpreet Singh Jee is a Proffessional Ragi.
vjkk, vjkf
Re: How do keertanis make a living?
Harmeet Singh · 26 Apr 2006
vjkk, vjkf
I know 'vv' jee,
but I was just answering the question :)
what better duty (notice how I didn't say job) is there than serve the guru and do keertan seva and parchar :D
bhul chuk maph karnee jee :)
vjkk, vjkf
Re: How do keertanis make a living?
Rajinder Pal Singh · 27 Apr 2006
In my opinion akj singhs all over the world should pass a Gurmata for not paying even a single penny to any kirtani singh and discourage this practice tooth and nail.There are many varities of kirtani singhs in our jatha.Most of the kirtanis who do not like to take Indian currency in India,but accept Pounds & Dollars when they visit other countries.The other catogary accepts money everywhere.
Re: How do keertanis make a living?
Bradford youth · 28 Apr 2006
hahahha you guys make me laugh, on one hand everyone pumps up the kirtanees with threads like this and then you want to make a "don't invite list" hehehehe, seriously though we all sit in the west with our nice house, flash cars, computers, tv etc etc etc. So if someone who has a gift of keertan requests money we decide "no way hose, that ain't right" yet we willingly waste money at car dealerships, on the net, in the home etc.
How can we value what gurbani keertan can do, you may critcise this keertani or that keertani, but i have come to the view that some keertanis have through keertan attracted the most wayward youth, was it not worth the £500's ??? can we really put the value on that.
I agree there should be a limit and greed should be discouraged but if you look at the whole picture you might think a bit differently, we are all full of greed, other wise we wouldn't work and build these houses, cars, etc etc..
Re: How do keertanis make a living?
Rajinder Pal Singh · 28 Apr 2006
I know some of famous kirtanees who belong to AKJ but do kirtan only for money.One of the kirtanis told me personally that the enjoyment of doing kirtan in AKJ has no comparison with the kirtan they do at other places against money.This is fact that the professional kirtanis do kirtan in AKJ just to show their loyality with AKJ.Otherwise they prefer to do kirtan out of the jatha as they make lots of money there. AKJ has no past record of giving or taking money for doing kirtan.If we all do not make sincere efforts to curb this practice, it may harm the interests of AKJ in bigway and all of us will be responsible for the loss the AKJ may suffer.
Re: How do keertanis make a living?
manmukh man · 29 Apr 2006
well sed vv