Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Can Someone Give Parshada Back?

Can Someone Give Parshada Back?

wondering · 05 Apr 2006

If I am doing Seva of serving Parshaday in Langar, and i give someone a Parshada, and they are like "I want the other kind of Parshada" (Misa Parshada)...are we supposed to take it back from them, or is it too late? I encountered this situation the other day, and the Auntie Ji was telling to make this one back, and get the other kind of Parshada for me, and i thought to myself, "What if she didn't wash her hands before sitting down" (she hadn't started eating yet)...so i said, "Once it gets served we should just accept it"...was this the right thing to do, or should i have taken it back? My biggest concern was whether her hands were clean or not.

Re: Can Someone Give Parshada Back?

charan dhoor · 05 Apr 2006

might be easier if the person keeps the parshaada and instead give them a bag to take it home. sometimes people don't wash their hands. so it might be an issue. easiest thing is ask them to take it home if they really can't eat it.

Re: Can Someone Give Parshada Back?

... · 05 Apr 2006

You cannot and should not take a parshada back from someone once you have given it. You are right that you can't know if the person's hands are clean or not.

Re: Can Someone Give Parshada Back?

satnaam · 05 Apr 2006

one time someone was giving parshada in langar and the plate (thaal) flip over and all the parsharda fell to the ground. would you need pesh in such a situation?

Re: Can Someone Give Parshada Back?

Kookar · 06 Apr 2006

You go pesh if you have done one of the BAJJAR KUREHATS, i.e. 1. Dishonour the hair (cut, pluck, bleach, dye, shave etc) 2. Eat kuthaa 3. Consume tobacco or any intoxicants 4. Physical relationship with anyone other than your wife/husban If you make a MISTAKE or you do DHILL in REHAT (minor lapse in rehat), then go to GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI and do ARDAAS. We are NOT perfect. This is the advise I was given at Amrit Sanchaar.

Re: Can Someone Give Parshada Back?

Rashpal Singh · 06 Apr 2006

No, you cant take the parshada back.

Re: Can Someone Give Parshada Back?

MANKIND · 07 Apr 2006

thats saying......i am clean and you are not...who makes sure the sewadaars all have clean hands..i have seen nails of deg sewadaars as black as claws.... anyway this is a one in a million chance... how many times do people get the wrong parshadas..and want to give them back...i would just eat what i get..and so would everyone else..in my 50 years i have never seen a single one trying to give back anything....if they dont like it..they just leave it all behind in their thaalis...for the washers to get rid of.... in our local gurdawra..the balance parshadas are fed to the pigeons..and the extra degh, kheer,daals,whatever is donated to the nearby drain-cum-stream....has been this way for long..and will be this way for long... I DONT THINK Guru Nanak Ji behaved in this holier than thou attitude when He distributed the 20 rupees Langgar...anybody got any evidence of where He cooked the daals/parshadas....was it all tyaar bar tyaar kitchen ?? who pakaa all the rotiaan...or did Guur Ji just buy everything readymade from the nearest village... it is so common in the Villages of PUNJAB..for the Gurdawra Granthi to collect rottian/daals/whatever from the HOUSES in the Pind... who makes sure all the LADIES have clean hands....Most of them do GOHA KOORRA while making rottian...??? all this suchma thing is bipparism..in this way most of the langgar at village gurdawaras..would be UNCLEAN??? because a hundred different ladies performing a hundred different household works gave out the rottian daal etc to the collector sewadaar