Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Gursikhs plz reply

Gursikhs plz reply

?? · 06 Apr 2006

After, doing chaupai sahib ji in mornign nitnem, must svaya and dohraa be recited or do u go straight on to tavprasaad svayae? Also, after finishing each bani, do u say gurfateh, or do u only say gurfateh once all 5 are done? thank you very much - an ever learning singh

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

... · 06 Apr 2006

You recite Japji Sahib, Jaap Sahib, Savaiyay, Chaupai Sahib, and Anand Sahib. You recite Chaupai Sahib to "dusht dokh tay layho bachaiee" and then go straight to Anand Sahib without dohra or svaiya. You also don't say "Fateh" between the banis, only at the end. This is just like at the Amrit Sinchaar where there is not Fateh between banis.

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

l · 07 Apr 2006

u may as well add in shabad hazare after jap ji sahib as well

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 07 Apr 2006

if you are doing sampuran chaupai sahib you may recite all of chaupai sahib from hamri karo hath dai racha to gobind daas tuhaar with arill, swaiya, dohra. no comment about "fatheh" between banis - some feel one way others feel another way and i don't know if one is wrong or right.

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

Bootha · 07 Apr 2006

You guys don't recite Chaupai Sahib to 'kirpa carry ham par jag matta ..........' 'Arril - sunnay ghoong jo yahee so rusnaa .........' 'Chapai - Sumbnadh suttr sehas panijay........' 'Pai gahay jab tay ko......' 'Dohera, sagal dhoar koe shaad kay .........' ????? I certainly do and see no reason why I shouldn't.

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

Guroo · 07 Apr 2006

I don't think there is anything wrong in saying "Fateh" after each Bani, if someone wishes to it. Alternatively they can say "Fateh" at the end of the full Nitnem.

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

a singh · 07 Apr 2006

i think thats the akj marayda..as taksal nitnem chaupai is recited to dohra..and fateh is said but is not a must.

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

Bootha · 07 Apr 2006

Bahi'o, sometimes we get so into something that we lose the bigger picture. If you say fateh between Japji Sahib and Jaap Sahib do you think that your nitname will be invalidated ? If your say "Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru" inbetween the panj banis that Guru Ji will be displeased ? I don't think so. Do your nitname and don't get into so much bhem or params, yaar !

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

Panthic · 07 Apr 2006

"a singh" is NOT akj maryada, its SRI AKAL TAKHT SAHIB MARYADA approved MARYADA. Suggest you pick a copy of Sikh Rehat Maryada from your local Gurdwara. Or you can visit www.sgpc.net.

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

Panthic · 07 Apr 2006

agree with "bootha" ji

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

raj_karega_khalsa · 07 Apr 2006

Panthic veerjee, im not sure if u beleve kes as kakkar or keskee...but is its keskee, then u are also goin against akal takht sahibs maryada...if u Do beleve its kes, my apologies im jus an idiot :) but to those ppl who beleve in keskee as kakkar n then for other issues say look at akaal takhat sahibs maryada...thas pritty hypocritical sry if i sed netin wrong, i dont kno netin Bhull CHuk Maph Vaahiguroo Jee Kaa Khaalsaa Vaahiguroo JEe Kee Fathe!!

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

... · 07 Apr 2006

The dohra and svaiya after Chaupai Sahib is not part of Chaupai Sahib. It is read during Rehras Sahib but I don't see why it would be in the morning as well seeing as how it's not actually linked. As for saying fateh and whether this "invalidates": no one is saying it would invalidate. But there is a right way of doing things. Nitnem is like churning the amrit within us everyday. So just like in amrit sinchaar, I don't think a fateh should be said between banis.

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

Panthic · 07 Apr 2006

Dear "raj_karega_khalsa" There is a difference between "PERSONAL vichaar" and "PANTHIC vichaar". To keep PANTHIC EKTA we have to RESPECT and SUPPORT the Sikh Rehat Maryada and Sri Akaal Takht Sahib's Hukamnamas. Therefore, I support and respect the Guru Panth's maryada and decisions, however believe "HISTORICALLY" Keski has been the 5th Kakkaar. End of day, everyone, irrespective of whether you believe Kes is Kakaar and follow SRM, wearing the Keski is a MUST and a part of REHAT. Belieivng Keski to be mandatory Rehat is NOT being "ANTI-PANTHIC". Quite the opposite. If you research the Amrit-Sanchaars which took place at Sri Akaal Takht Sahib PRIOR 1948 (when Giani Gurmukh Singh Musafar became Jathedar of Sri Akal Takht Sahib) no lady was admitted to recieve Amrit who did not wear a Keski. Jathedar Musafar did NOT issue a Hukamnama saying wearing a Keski is "not mandatory". However, HE PERSONALLY sanctioned changes in the Amrit Sanchaars taking place in order that MORE bibian take Amrit. This was a DHILL (lapse) in Rehat in order to make numbers (reminds me of giving Amrit drive by Sant and Babe). You hopefully know that Amrit Sanchaar takes place every Sunday and Wednesday at the Takht Sahib. So what happened is that one day of the week was for mandotory Keski Rehat and other day in the week was more "RELAXED" rehat for ladies who could NOT commit to full Khalsa Bana. This led to a slippery-slope to eventually Keski Rehat and unique Khalsa Bana was not enforced at Amrit Sanchaars at any of the Takht Sahibaans. You can read about "Keski Rehat and SRM" here: http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=56430&t=56430#reply_56430

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

Truth · 07 Apr 2006

Please read the full chaupai sahib, not the SGPC version which cuts out the last 8 lines. Followed by arill and dohra (takes about 1 min more than SGPC version). And lets cut down on the hypocracy while we're at it. If you follow SGPC maryada, don't keep thumping keski as kakaar. Be brave enough to admit you don't follow some of the maryada from the SRM.

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

Confused Khalsa · 07 Apr 2006

"The dohra and svaiya after Chaupai Sahib is not part of Chaupai Sahib." the answer is simple, read bani... aslong as its bani/praises of guru ji then there is no problem in saying fateh.... no problems with doing extra with doing dohra etc i think one thing we as a society always forget when looking at these situations is that we forget about how things were in the olden times. why was their ekta? because everyone respected everyone elses views. if someone reads dohra at the end, and you dont but you are both doing simran 24/7 does it matter who reads what? the problem is that for many people including myself is that ALL we do all day is our nitnem... if we did simran/meditation every second of every minute these things wouldnt even matter. aslong as we're doing minimum paath we're going to have minimum understanding as a panth, and that means minimum respect for each others beliefs.

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

other ... · 07 Apr 2006

Confused Khalsa, The problem is that people read extra things in between their nitnem and later that starts to be considered the "real" nitnem and if someone isn't reading it or doing it, it's not complete. An example would be in Rehras Sahib, "Har jug jug" and "dukh daroo" were not part of Rehras but because they are read immediately before at Darbar Sahib, we have somethign called "Sampooran Rehras" while others are doing, by that logic, "Adhoora Rehraas". So it's fine to do as much bani as you want, but nitnem is a set amount of bani.

Re: Gursikhs plz reply

raj_karega_khalsa · 07 Apr 2006

Panthic veerjee i completely agree wit u on tha fact that keskee is tha 5th kakaar, i jus didnt think we shud push SRM wen we dont fully beleve in it...but yea i agree wit ur other point bout personal and panthic vichar...i take back wut i sed b4...thx for teachin me sumtin useful :) lol Bhull chuk Maph Vaahiguroo Jee Kaa Khaalsaa Vaahiguroo Jee Keee Fathe!!