Skip to content
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Forum
Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
m8 · 07 Apr 2006
I was wonderin,g, the ganga sagar is nt sarbloh and guru gobind singh ji used it.....also, please no1 say its a fake.
but
does this prove that guru gobind singh ji was not sarblohi?
im nt sayin this in a bad way because i just wanna learn myself so plz shed some lite on this
plz can any of the tapoban sangat reply 2 this?
[%sig%]
Re: Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
Bootha · 07 Apr 2006
1 You CANNOT question Guru Gobind Singh Ji, period. What they did, what they said, how they acted, what they preached was the TRUTH and 100% correct.
How can we mere fools even think of questioning Guru sahib Ji.
2 Guru showed us the way, we should follow it. We are ghand, Guru is sucha and poora, how can you equate the two?
3 There is a sakhi of Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji eating fruit picked by a mata Ji who had taken a bite out of each one to make sure each was ripe and sweet. Because her love of Guru Sahib Ji was pure and total, Guru Sahib Ji ate the parshad. Now, we fools again will question how Guru sahib Ji could eat jootha fruit when they have told us not to. BUT we cannot even contemplate one iota of the thoughts of our Guru, and we shouldn't because this leads down a dangerous path, the path of duality and bharam and bhem.
[%sig%]
Re: Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
... · 07 Apr 2006
Bootha,
You believe everything you hear or read? Guru Sahib is poora and no one can question Guru Sahib. But you can and should question stories. Only Guru Sahib's bani is not questionable. There are stories about Guru Sahib that just can't be believed like worshipping Hindu gods, or having Hindu ceremonies, etc. Will you believe those as well?
Your third story is pretty unbelievable. It's based on the Hindu "Bhilni" story. Why would you call the fruit bitten by the woman "parshad" and why would Guru Sahib eat this? Who's parshad? The woman's?
If a story doesn't fit with Gurmat, it shouldn't be accpeted.
There are two Ganga Sagars. One has been in teh Gurdwara there and one is the one claimed by the Rai Kallah family. Which one is authentic, I don't know. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh and the Jatha examined one and that story is in the stories section of this site (in article by Baba Surjan Singh).
Although I'm not sure the story is true or false, I personally don't understand what the purpose of the Ganga Sagar would be and why anyone would carry this with them. It's a jug with holes in the bottom. I'm genuinely curious what this utensil is designed to do.
Re: Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
Bootha · 07 Apr 2006
...,
<<< You believe everything you hear or read? >>> No.
<<< Why would you call the fruit bitten by the woman "parshad" >>>
When you take fruit or milk or sugar to gurnwara what do you call it ?
<<< and why would Guru Sahib eat this? >>>
If you took some fruit to Guru Sahib Ji, would Guru Ji not eat it? so why wouldn't guru Ji eat the fruit of the mata?
<<< Who's parshad? The woman's? >>>
If she brought it, then yes.
Re: Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
... · 07 Apr 2006
Booth,
I think you're confused about the concept of "parshad".
Parshad is only given by someone higher to someone lower. It becomes parshad when it is "blessed" or "sanctified" in some way. Human Gurus usually eat some of the offering and only then does it become parshad.
So if you take some sugar or something to Gurdwara, it doesn't automatically become "parshad".
Re: Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
Bootha · 07 Apr 2006
<<< and why would Guru Sahib eat this? >>>
If you have true piyar for your Guru, then he will do anything for you.
When Bhidi Chand took Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji's name and jumped into the bhatti, it was Guru Ji who felt the heat, not his sewak.................sorry just another story !
When Mukhan Shah took Guru Tegh Bhahadur sahib Ji's name it was Guru Ji who used his shoulder to save his ship .............. sorry, another story.
[%sig%]
Re: Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
... · 07 Apr 2006
Stories are fine. As long as they're not against Gurmat.
Guru Sahib will do anything for his Sikh as long as it's not against Gurmat.
Re: Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
Bootha · 07 Apr 2006
I assum you will say that Miracles are against gurmat, right?
So according to you the above sakhis of Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji and Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib Ji cannot be correct, right ????
[%sig%]
Re: Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
... · 07 Apr 2006
Bootha,
You know what they say when people "assume" to much right?
At any rate, I do believe in stories that involve "miracles" such as the Makhan Shah Lubana story. That's really irrelevant to this discussion though.
Re: Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
sikhbacha · 09 Apr 2006
Veerji
It is well known part of Sikh history that Siri Guru Gobind Singh ji Maharaj stayed with Rai Kallah (a muslim) for a few days. It is where news of Shahidi of Sahebzadas came. During his stay Guru ji accepted milk from Rai Kallah and this is where Guru Saheb ji gave Ganga Sagar to Rai Kallah.
Some people make all kinds of comments about Ganga Sagar or the motives of Rai family. I have high respect for Rai Kallah and his descendents, for having the honor of done Guru Saheb's Darshan and sewa and at a time when even some Sikhs were affraid to give Guru Sahab shelter.
Personally to me, the fact that this utensil has holes all over yet liquid does not spill, which is miraculous, is not as important to me as the fact the Guru Saheb's Pavitar Hands touched this item.
Another thing, my respected father tells me that he remembers as a child and youngman that before partition on every Baisakhi day, Rai Kallah's family used to bring out Ganga Sagar for Darshan to Sikh Sangat. They have kept it with utmost respect.
[%sig%]
Re: Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
Singhstah · 09 Apr 2006
Just in my own moorakh opinion, guroo ji gave us rehat to follow, and we just follow that, we dont look at wat guroo sahib does. Remember that sakhi of bhai mardana ji and Guroo Nanak Dev Ji Mahraj, Guroo ji told bhai mardana ji to recite a naam of God, so that they could walk across the water, by reciting the naam, bhai mardana ji was able to walk on the water, while walking Guroo Ji was reciting a different name, so bhai mardana ji started doing the same as guroo sahib, at that moment, bhai mardana ji fell into the water. Guroo ji told him to concentrate on the naam he was told to say, not wat guroo ji was saying.
What im tryng to say is, this whole play is guroo sahibs, its up to him wat he does, everything belongs to him. Saying that, that doesnt mean we can do anything we want, it means that we listen to what guroo sahib TELLS us to do.
Re: Ganga sagar + Sarbloh?
** · 09 Apr 2006
Boota
u need to sort out your bootha. taking a bit from each fruit is "bhalnee's " hindu story and this is the first time i have heard that some one with twisted bootha connected this fake story with any sikh guru. get u r facts right nefdore u put them on the phorum