Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

"Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

"Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

Panthic Weekly News · 10 Apr 2006

[URL=http://www.panthic.org/news/124/ARTICLE/2388/2006-04-09.html]http://www.panthic.org/news/124/ARTICLE/2388/2006-04-09.html[/URL] Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ? Sunday 9th of April 2006 Panthic Weekly News Bureau London, UK (KP) - On Sunday, 9th April, 2006 took place the annual Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Kirtan. The Nagar Kirtan began at Sri Guru Singh Sabha Gurdwara, Havelock Road. The route of the Nagar Kirtan was as follows: Havelock Road, King Street, The Green, South Road, High Street, Green Drive, and ending at Sri Guru Singh Sabha Gurdwara, Park Avenue. In previous years, the Sangat had raised the issue of manmat [unacceptable conduct] being allowed in the Nagar Kirtan by sending letters to the Sri Guru Singh Sabha Southall Committee. In particular, Gursikhs were concerned with Bhangra dancers dancing in the Nagar Kirtan and singing Boliyan (song lyrics). Last year, Bhangra dancers and members from the Desi Radio station danced in the Nagar Kirtan to songs about the Shaheedi of the Sahibzaadey. It raised among many the questions, "Is Dharmik Geet to be listened and contemplated upon for its message, or to dance and jump and down to? How can this sacrilege by condoned by the Sri Guru Singh Sabha Gurdwara Committee who organised the Nagar Kirtan?" The Sangat’s message to the Nagar Kirtan organisers admonishing their lack of responsibility of ensuring the Nagar Kirtan is done in accordance to Gurmat done last year fell on deaf ears. Little or nothing had changed this year. View Video of [URL=http://www.panthic.org/data/images/news/categories/cat_124/2388_nagar_bhangra.3gp]Nagar Kirtan Sewadar participating in Bhangra[/URL] Bhangra dancers dressed in their costumes can be seen in the pictures dancing to the dhol (drum) and someone singing Boliyan. The boliyan were about caste, women and drunkeness, which nowadays comprise the themes of modern Punjabi song lyrics. The Bhangra dancers disrupted the the purpose of the Nagar Kirtan, and secondly they promoted Manmat at such a joyous occasion by singing lyrics about things which are condemned in Sikhi, and thirdly it gave encouragement and acceptance to the youth that it is okay to keep your head uncovered, dance to vile lyrics promoting alcohol and caste and show little or lack of respect to the singing of Shabads and Simran being done in the Nagar Kirtan. When the Nagar Kirtan approached Green Drive going towards Park Avenue, Gursikhs noticed a group of clean-shaven men, some who didn’t even have the courtesy of covering their heads, dancing and jumping up and down to the beat of the Dhol. In between jumping up and down and dancing, they were shouting slogans of “Raj Karega Khalsa,” and “Khalistan Zindabad.” Gursikhs noted that one need to “become Khalsa” before shouting such slogans and that secondly, by dancing and jumping down and shouting Jaikaare at the same time, ridicules the seriousness of such Sikh slogans and violates the sanctity of the Nagar Kirtan and belitles the purpose and message behind such an event. Some wondered:" What does this demonstrate to the youth?" More shameful was the behavior of a Nagar Kirtan sewadar from Sri Guru Singh Sabha Gurdwara, wearing a Sewadar jacket, who was dancing with the group of men rather than asking them to stop this disrespectful dancing and instead encouraging them to sing along Gurbani or at least show respect and solemnity to the rest of the Sangat who are singing Shabad Gurbani. Eventually the group of men stopped doing Bhangra after Gursikhs tried to explain to them that this was not the time nor place to do Bhangra. Furthermore, members of the Sangat who were standing right behind the men dancing were annoyed that there Shabad Kirtan was being drowned out by the shouting, dhol playing and dancing of these men. Members of the Sangat also approached the men to stop. It seemed the group of young dhol players was fuelling these men to dance. So Gursikhs asked the dhol players to not play for a while, let the atmosphere calm down and restore to the intended peaceful atmosphere of singing Gurbani and doing Simran in Sangat roop. Editors can be reached at [URL=mailto:[address removed]][address removed][/URL]

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

Stop the Manmat!! · 10 Apr 2006

Year on year, it's the same stuff. I don't understand why we can't do anything about this! There was a larger than normal group of Singhs this year trying to stop the dancing. It's ironinc, I approached 2 groups of guys dancing this year and both groups were straight from Punjab. You would think the UK born Punjabis would be doing this. The guys straight from Punjab should know better. I got a video of some monay waving the Nishan Sahib in the air and bopping up and down to dhol beats. I will put in yourtube.com. They were all from India and did apologise once a jatha of Singh's approached them. There was a punjabi laday giving out free facials and makeovers at the Nagar Kirtan. It's all commercial, it makes me sick.

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

ns · 10 Apr 2006

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh This is what I mean Sikhs killing of sikhe when people ask what are you talking about. We have the cream of Educated Sikhs living around the Southall,Hayes,Middlesex area who cannot get this sorted. We need one town in the UK to do it and the example could be set forth for other towns. Nagar Kirtan stems from Prabhat fari which in todays' form shown above is disgusting. The question is will Guru Sahib punish the ones who claim to be authentic sikhs and make such complaints and don't walk the talk, apologies I don't mean to offend panthic weekly but this is includes me too on that list. Where is the Respect 4GURU Ji campaign Guru Ji is being taken along with bhangra and boliaan...this stinks of a black kala cultural festival not a religous one and is disgusting indeed. What does it take to educate the mega rich committee types of our towns?

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

singhni - UK · 10 Apr 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh I have stopped going to Nagar Kirtans years and years ago, because the above article is spot on in conveying what exatcly goes on at these. It has turned into a social mela where guys and girls can get together, dance, eat (food stalls in ur face every 2-3 paces) and talk loudly , laugh and joke around. My friend who is a moni went yesterday to the southall nagar kirtan and she wasnt impressed by what she felt or saw. The girls were (and im sorry to say this so bluntly) but most of them were tarts, showing off their tight clothes etc. Every year I ask people why they go to nagar kirtan or what the purpose of going is and they say that they go because their friends are going and they dont know the purpose of a nagar kirtan, the concept is completly lost and it may as well be called southall mela. Every Vaisakhi its like this and its so upsetting. :(

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

sanjo · 10 Apr 2006

totally disgusting, now that i think of it i ahve experienced this before. ther eis always young dholis usually towards the rear of the nagar kirtan, playing their dhol while the nagar kirtan proceeds. i never used to think much of it because i wasnt in to sikhi at all. but surely the whole point of nagar kirtan is to enjoy n partake in the kirtan n to show upmost respect for guru granth sahib ji who is present. to be honest i never used to know that the guru granth sahib was taken on a nagar kirtan! noone ever told me that guru ji was present n that we should show respect, everyone just wants to listen to the dholis n watch the gatka demos which occur. i dont blame people who do these things alot of them just get caught up in the moment and arent really educated on sikhi n relaly dont realise they are doing beadbi of guru ji, because i used to be one of these types. but really we need the gurdwareh who organise these nagar kirtans to educate people n point out what is right and wrong. as for sewadars acting inappropriatly, where i come from the sewadars for the mela atleast are any old fellow, my friend was once a sewadar at a mela n he said they dont care what happens, they just like walking around in their sewadar jackets looking like "gangstas" n many are very quick to assist girls n ignore actual required seva. other than that nagar kirtans are good to raise awareness of sikhi but we have to make sure that we give out the correct message and not let other communities think sikhi is about bhangra dancing n the dhol.

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

Singh · 10 Apr 2006

We have to ask ourselves do we really need to hold Nagar Kirtans. In the past, to my knowledge, the purpose was so that people who could not make it to the gurdwara (due to old age, disability etc) could have darshan of Guru Ji with out having to travel excessive distances. But nowadays with advances in modes of transport there are very few reasons why someone with the intention cannot to get to the Gurdwara I personally would favour a ban on Nagar Kirtans and thereby avoiding all of the above

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

makhan · 10 Apr 2006

What is the purpose of nagar kirtan. to who do they sing shabads. There should be no nagar kirtan in any city town or country.this is the biggest disrespect we show to our guru ji.

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 10 Apr 2006

Origin Nagar Kirtans originate from ‘PARBHAAT PHERIS’ ([i]Parbhaat[/i] literally means ‘early morning,’ and [i]Pheri[/i] means ‘going around’). The Parbhaat Pheri would consist of a Gursikh carrying a vaaja (harmonium) tied to themselves, some people would carry chhainey (bells), and one person would carry a dholki. One of the earliest Parbhaat Pheris is from Guru Hargobind Ji's time when Guru Sahib was in Gwalior Fort. Baba Buddha Ji led a Parbhaat Pheri around the Gwalior as a form of protest and raising the spirits of the Sikhs. Early in the morning the group of Gursikhs would walk around the village or city SINGING SHABADS and people would join them as they walked past their homes. Leading the jatha (group) would be the people leading the shabad singing and a Gursikh carrying a Nishan Sahib. The processions gave opportunity for people to enjoy the bliss of singing the Lord’s Praises, an opportunity to distribute relevant and useful GURMAT LITERATURE to the public and also SHARE A POSITIVE IMAGE of the Guru's Khalsa. In recent history we have started doing processions which include Guru Maharaaj's Sawaari (without Prakaash) and also Panj Pyaare leading the procession. Benefit of Traditional Nagar Kirtan The traditional Nagar Kirtans or Parbhaat Pheris inspired people to SING GURBAANI and gave them opportunity to DISTRIBUTE EDUCATIONAL MATERIAL in regards to Gurmat. Seeing Chardikala Gursikhs in public singing Kirtan provided the public and youngsters with POSITIVE ROLE MODELS and GOOD IMPRESSIONS of what and who Sikhs are. The whole event would have a COMMUNITY SPIRIT, gathering the community together and INSPIRING OTHERS to sing and understand Gurbaani. [gurbani]ਜਨੁ ਨਾਨਕੁ ਧੂੜਿ ਮੰਗੈ ਤਿਸੁ ਗੁਰਸਿਖ ਕੀ ਜੋ ਆਪਿ ਜਪੈ ਅਵਰਹ ਨਾਮੁ ਜਪਾਵੈ ॥੨॥[/gurbani] jan naanak DhooR mangai tis gursikh kee jo aap japai avrai naam japaavai.2. Translation: "Servant Nanak begs for the dust of the feet of that GurSikh, who himself chants the Naam, and inspires others to chant it." (Ang 306, SGGS) [gurbani]ਆਵਹੁ ਸਿਖ ਸਤਿਗੁਰੂ ਕੇ ਪਿਆਰਿਹੋ ਗਾਵਹੁ ਸਚੀ ਬਾਣੀ ॥[/gurbani] aavhu sikh satguroo ke piaarihu gaavhu sachee baaNee. Translation: "Come, O beloved Sikhs of the True Guru, and sing the True Word of His Baani." (Ang 920, SGGS) Today’s Nagar Kirtans * EAT AS MUCH AS YOU CAN squeeze into your stomach. You can see the development of gluttony. * Wearing as many BIG KHANDEY possible and WAVING A NISHAAN SAHIB like people wave a football team flag in a football game. * PUSHING one another and SQUASHING OTHERS (young, old and children) attempting to do Matha Tekh. * If you are bored of the Kirtan, there's an OPTION OF DOING BHANGRA and jumping and down, with a few Jaikaaray being shouted out in between the dancing. RAB BHALLA KARE! (Don't know what else to comment!) * [i]Some positive points:[/i] You see some children sitting on floats and SINGING SHABADS or parents with their children who have especially dressed up in Bana and sing along with the Kirtan. However, these people are sadly a minority! How productive are today’s Nagar Kirtans in educating, promoting and highlighting Gurmat Generally the whole atmosphere of Nagar Kirtans nowadays is of a STREET CARNIVAL, with an unfortunate motto of "KHAA-O PEE-O AISH KARO" being practiced. Thought to take away We are celebrating 307 years of the Khalsa Panth. We should ask ourselves WHAT DO WE LEARN from Vaisakhi of 1699 and the establishment of the Khalsa Panth? How do we IMPROVE OURSELVES, and what steps do we take to change and adjust our lives to become CLOSER TO GURU JI and receiving the TRUE KUSHEE (happiness) of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. Bhul chuk maaf karnee jee. Daas, Manvir Singh Khalsa

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

sanjo · 10 Apr 2006

is it not ok to do kirtan now? i read somewhere that bhai randhir singh walked through the streets doing kirtan with plenty of followers and many people joined in a done beautifull kirtan and they then ended up doing a rehansbhai on a gurpurab i think. i dont understand what disrespect a nagar kirtan shows? if all the bhangra etc wasnt present i think it is a good way of representing sikhi to others. the nagar kirtan itself isnt a problem, its the panjabi influence thats manmat. in my opinion. i think nagar kirtans can be used to promote sikhi u jus need to get rid of the panjabi influence. n by not going to nagar kirtans all together, we r just leaving them to the panjabis n they wil be free to do whatever they want. i think we should all make a big effort to purify nagar kirtans n use them to prmote real sikhi rather then having a knee jirk response n ban everything instead. same with meleh aswel, alot of people say we should ban them, but its a great oppurtunity to get people in to sikhi, but again its the panjabis that make them a disgrace. these things are tools we can use to our advantage in my humble opinion and i think totally banning stuff isnt the way forward. bhull chik maaf waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

TKD · 10 Apr 2006

WJKK WJKF I WAS AT THIS NAAGAR KIRTAN AND WAS DISGUSTED AT THE DANCING THAT WAS DONE, ALSO THERE WAS A FIGHT THAT ERUPTED TOWARDS THE END AMONGST SOME SINGHS!!!!!! DISGRACEFUL....... THERE IS KIRTAN GOIN ON AND STOOPID PEOPLE DES RESPECTING OUR GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI..... WHERES THE RESPECT IN THAT!!!!!!! IT WAS MY IST AND LAST TIME GOING TO SOUTHALL NAAGR KIRTAN, NEVER AGAIN..... WE HAVE OUR EAST LONDON COMMENCING SOON, LETS HOPE THE SAME IS NOT REPEATED AGAIN! WJKK WJKF

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 10 Apr 2006

TKD Bhai Sahib, where was the fight? Sadly the same issues from last year are repeating. Gursikhs wrote letters to the Singh Sabha Managment Committee but NO response. NO SURPRISE! Rab Rakha!

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

yeahhh · 10 Apr 2006

this is where we needa get together some singhs like nihang singhs wit danda and chittar fayroo. this is nonsense.

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

punny · 10 Apr 2006

this is disgraceful, i dont think our nagar keertans in canada are at that level yet tho, well i dont know about the one that goes to city hall but the one in malton is always the best, even no bhangra, no bibyan flirting, EVERYONE COME OUT TO THE MALTON GURUGHAR TO REXDALE GURUGHAR NAGAR KEERTAN!

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

singh who walked the walk · 10 Apr 2006

Gursikhs who attend need to take action themselves. a small minority did take action. no point to say im not going to attend so you will let the gandh continue. people need your positve image there you as guroo sikh need to take action. :)

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

G Singh · 11 Apr 2006

I suppose we seem to be focusing on only one of the negatives of the Nagar Kirtan. There is the problem of corporate advertising and the naamdhari's promoting their "satguru". This year there was some literature handed out in Southall in response to the naamdhari parchar handed out last year. The naamdharis didn't do a float this year, but they did have their banners in the Nagar Kirtan promoting "his holiness satguru jagjit singh ji maharaj". There were 2 incidents I witnessed where some Singhs and naamdharis had heated debates within the Nagar Kirtan. Maybe this is the fight TKD is going on about. And then there were confrontations with the Western Union Guys, just like last year. How long can these confrontations carry on for? People walk past and accuse us of being fanatics. I was called a Khalistani by a group of ladies giving out their flyers for a free facial at their salon. Anyone with a Sikh view is branded a Khalistani, Extremist, Fanatic etc. Sohi's (Singh Sabha Southall) committee and other Gurdwara committees should have the balls to release strict guidlines about what can be and cannot be part of the official Nagar Kirtan. No Bhangra, No Advertising, No Naamdharis or any other anti panthic groups. They are employees of Guru Maharaj, hence they are only answerable to Guru Maharaj, no one else.

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

Leicester Sikh · 11 Apr 2006

Waheguru Jee ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Ki Fateh Having read the above articles I am sorry to hear that one of the biggest events of the Sikh religious calendar is being turned into one big manmat funfair. I would like to point out that I was priveliged to have attended the Leicester Nagar Kirtan on the same day and I can report that this was a very good event for everyone involved. It was kept well under control by the management and the religious aspect was at the forefront. There was not a word ushered that was manmat - no bhangra dancers, no cars with young youth blasting out bhangra music, no drunks, etc, etc, etc. The Leicester Nagar Kirtan is conducted this way twice a year and has followed these principles ever since it was started. I would like to pass on my compliments to the Sangat that attended the Leicester Nagar Kirtan and the management for keeping this as a religious event only to celebrate the Birth of Khalsa, Vaisakhi. Waheguru Jee ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Ki Fateh [%sig%]

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

singhnee · 11 Apr 2006

i attended the nagar kirtan, i was only meant to go for abit but it was so spiritually uplifting that i ended up walking the whole way.....this is why I WAS RIGHT AT THE FRONT behind Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji I know there is alot of crap that goes on, which is why i made sure i stayed right at the front, it was so amazing, everyone was singing the shabads so loudly and i was one of few youngsters at the front i was surrounded by mata ji's and uncles. whenever we stopped and i closed my eyes i felt i was at a rainsbai. i felt a lot of community spirit the whole way....but i think after the first section of the nagar kirtan...the kaljug starts.... i thank the other gursikhs who made steps to stop the beadbhi by approaching people, i myself didnt mean to turn a blind eye, it just happened that the front was amazing and i wanted to stay there

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

S Singh · 11 Apr 2006

>>There was a larger than normal group of Singhs this year trying to stop the dancing. It's ironinc, I approached 2 groups of guys dancing this year and both groups were straight from Punjab. You would think the UK born Punjabis would be doing this. The guys straight from Punjab should know better. So true. Might be an idea to telephone the local enforcement unit of the Immigration and Nationality Department before the next Nagar Kirtan and send all these guys back to Punjab. They are very bad and have no respect for Guru Ji.

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

A Singh · 11 Apr 2006

<> I quite agree, it is insulting to have monae-konae flagging nishan sahibs and with unecessary political slogans when they themselves are about as far flung as one can get from being Khalsa! This is supposed to be a Nagar-KIRTAN or Jaloos of Guru Maharaj and Guru Khalsa not some commercial festival - there are melas for that to occur. The analogy of Black Cultural Festival is well made given the amount of litter created during the procession (rather like the Notting Hill Festival) and recent trends amongst "chardi kala" types to introduce Beat Box, Rap and other blatantly ripped off forms of music for the purpose of somehow creating 'awareness' for the 'youth' - there was a one great example of this with the likes of Harjit Singh Grewal from Watford and his Jatha of Chardi Kala looking Singhs, blasting out beat box tunes with distorted dhadi jatha vocals screaming over the top... ...whatever the rationale behind this, the sad reality is that more people were congregating around this tent in bana than there were around Guru Maharaj and other floats in which Kirtan was being sung - not only this, but this Tiger Style Black Panther style gangsta dhadi jatha mish mash was actually drowning out the Kirtan!!!

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

uk singh · 11 Apr 2006

singhni - UK writes 'I have stopped going to Nagar Kirtans years and years ago, because the above article is spot on in conveying what exatcly goes on at these. It has turned into a social mela where guys and girls can get together, dance, eat (food stalls in ur face every 2-3 paces) and talk loudly , laugh and joke around. ' It is true that manmat has crept into Nagar Kirtans and situation is worsening year on year. In any situtaion like this, alot depends on what you want to take away from the experience. For me this was one of the best Nagar Kirtans in years due to the quality of the Kirtan. The first jatha was excellent. We should stop the manmat through education. This responsibility should lie with the Gurdwara committee. Announcements can be made in the Nagar Kirtan itself or even better during the weeks prior to the event.

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

singh · 11 Apr 2006

why dont you judgemental "gursikhs" do your own nagar kirtan, and let the "manmukhs and tarts" do their own. Do you get jealous that they have fun?

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

Joka · 11 Apr 2006

.whatever the rationale behind this, the sad reality is that more people were congregating around this tent in bana than there were around Guru Maharaj and other floats in which Kirtan was being sung - not only this, but this Tiger Style Black Panther style gangsta dhadi jatha mish mash was actually drowning out the Kirtan!!! Lol i think some people need to get their glasses adjusted!! Lets think you have A tent/stall with what max 15 or 20 people around it ... then you have guru ji's truck and other trucks etc ... with thousands of people mutha tekhing etc ... i think my friend you have caught the punjabi bug which is known as doing a GAPH! and actually singhs told me that the music was actually switched off and always is when guru ji went past.... so i think you got the bumari big time! maybe you should take a pill (chill pill lol) as far as music is concerned, we all know its personal choice, i might like that kind of music when i listen to dharmic geet, i might like slow raag kinda music when i listen to keertan, or i might like the tabla bashing hyper speed type of music when i listen to keertan! but yeh bhangra dancing at a mela is mashed up!! i didnt like the human guru worshippin namdharis there either!

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

A Singh · 11 Apr 2006

Dear "Singh" You asked "why dont you judgemental "gursikhs" do your own nagar kirtan, and let the "manmukhs and tarts" do their own. Do you get jealous that they have fun?" Whilst I may not speak for everyone, I feel you need to reconsider your question. No one is stopping guys and girls having "fun" if by that you refer to the dancing, chatting, etc - this is all fine at a Mela, however a Mela is a NOT a Nagar Kirtan - that I believe is simple enough to understand for most people.

Re: "Southall Vaisakhi Nagar Bhangra & Kirtan ?"

Sanjo · 11 Apr 2006

"singh" wrote: "why dont you judgemental "gursikhs" do your own nagar kirtan, and let the "manmukhs and tarts" do their own. Do you get jealous that they have fun?" first of all "gursikhs" arent being judgemental when it comes to beadbi of guru ji. if someone is dancing on top of guru granth sahib disrespecting guru ji, are we judgemental to point out this is wrong and try n stop it?were the shaheeds n sikhs of 1978 judgemental for trying to stop beadbi that narakdharis were doing? if "manmukhs" n that wona do their manmat things they can do em where guru granth sahib is not present. but by doing these things they are representing sikhi, n giving out the wrong message is dangerous. they can dance n listen to their music n have fun in their own homes or in clubs, but where guru granth sahib ji is present it is not acceptable. oh n i would think "gursikhs" wouldnt be jealous of these "manmukhs and tarts" having fun, cos gursikhs would be getting more ras from the kirtan n gurbani if ofcourse it wasnt being disruspted and disrespected by bhangra dancers n dholis etc. there is no arguement for the presence of such manmat things at nagar kirtans so i cant see how someone can put such things before the respect of guru granth sahib n try n justify such things like bhangra. total ego n ignorance if someone does try to justify these. though it has to be pointed out that alot of people do stop doing these things when told that they are doing manmat activities, so maybe we just need more education and we need for the commities to come out n clarify what is right n what is wrong. bhull chukk maaf