Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Caffiene

Caffiene

Caffeine · 17 Dec 2003

fateh folkzz, i'm on da net.. munching on me coffee crisps... (not a bibeki yet: i usually don't drenk pop..but todayz i was eating coffee crisp it has caffiene in it.. so is it wrong??

Re: Caffiene

Mkhalsa · 17 Dec 2003

yes. any drugs that give u nasha are wrong.

Re: Caffiene

G · 17 Dec 2003

I dont think caffine is a big deal... but thats up to you personally I guess if your panj tells you not to eat it then you shouldnt...

Re: Caffiene

? · 17 Dec 2003

is chocolate wrong for a sikh?

Re: Caffiene

jinder · 17 Dec 2003

I never drink coffee, but man I love Coffee Crisp. You can't get it in america. I would start chewing gum if I were you, especially the whitening kind. Just by chewing on them, my teeth have less discolouring and are more white. :)

Re: Caffiene

. · 17 Dec 2003

man caffiene is in those products in such minor quantities it dont matter, and it doint do much anywyas munch on brother!!!

Re: Caffiene

Dasan Daas · 17 Dec 2003

vaheguroojikakhalsa vaheguroojikifathe Iv always pondered over this, people say that caffeine is a stimulant therefore a nasha, which is kind of true. What caffeine actually does as far as I know, is it slows down the pace at which the body naturally tires as the day progresses. So in theory this should mean chocolate is also off the menu for Amritdharis because this also contains a similar stimulant called theobromine (present in the cocoa bean) which is a close relative of caffeine (hence acts in a similar way to caffeine, albeit on a smaller scale) but the fact remains it is still present. To this, I guess Sangat would say as long as its in moderation its acceptable, but can you not also say the same about caffeine then? My question (yes, all that was actually leading somewhere...) is would it be ok to consume green tea, fruit/herbal tea and coffee which are 'caffeine free' (i say 'cafeine free') because although its says this, most of the time they will still contain small ammounts of 'nasha'? My thinking is that in moderation it would be ok, as are coca-cola, chocolate and eating in moderation (...ie not having 4 parshadey at home when you know you can make do with that 3rd one!) because this is also seen as a form of 'nasha') Your thoughts Jio...? vaheguroojikakhalsa vaheguroojikifathe

Re: Caffiene

Singh 0 · 17 Dec 2003

Mkhalsa not wanting to argue with you but onions contain alchole as well as some viniger. Guess everyone who's ever eaten in the Langer now has to go pesh (providing the 5 pyarari didn't have onions in thier dhaal)

Re: Caffiene

Kulbir Singh · 17 Dec 2003

Quite simply talking, we should not recommend anti-Gurmat thing to anyone. Bibek (not eating from hands of non-devotees) is an important rehit of Khalsa. If someone was to ask me if it is okay to buy candy if there are no eggs in it, I would say no. The reason is that it is not only eggs that we are stopped from eating but also food cooked by non-devotees. If nothing else, I would stay quite and make no comments. Let us not suggest anything against Gurmat to anyone. Instead of buying whatever "crisps" you want, I would say make them at home. Why eat something cooked by non-devotees and lose considerable amount of your paath simran? It's not worth it. If we don't keep rehit, we cannot get full spiritual benefit of naam and gurbani. So says baani.

Re: Caffiene

Singh 0 · 17 Dec 2003

Kulbir I see what you are saying. But the fact is that we all eat food prepared by non Amritdhari’s who probably drink, smoke and all the rest of it. The atta (flour) used in our rottis are farmed, harvested, ground down, packaged delivered and sold by such people. All we do is the final part of the preparation of adding water and putting it on the teva. We all eat butter, eat sugar salt from packets and drink milk from the shops. These products to name a few have been 100% made by non Amritdhari’s yet we ignore this fact. So the idea of eating things not prepared by Amritdhari’s simply doesn’t hold for most of us, unless we grow our own ‘organic’ food and herd cows for ourselves. Please can you comment on your solution to this dilema.

Re: Caffiene

Singhstah · 17 Dec 2003

I have seen tea being made at the gurdwara is that wrong aswell? It's not like you drink tea to get high most people just have it with their breakfast

Re: Caffiene

Kulbir Singh · 17 Dec 2003

Singh 0, ---------- The atta (flour) used in our rottis are farmed, harvested, ground down, packaged delivered and sold by such people. All we do is the final part of the preparation of adding water and putting it on the teva. We all eat butter, eat sugar salt from packets and drink milk from the shops. These products to name a few have been 100% made by non Amritdhari’s yet we ignore this fact. So the idea of eating things not prepared by Amritdhari’s simply doesn’t hold for most of us, unless we grow our own ‘organic’ food and herd cows for ourselves. ------------ According to the rehit of Khalsa, buying raw materials for cooking is allowed. What is not allowed is cooked food. Please read Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee’s Gurmat Bibek for more details. Bhai Sahib clearly mentions that Khalsa is allowed to buy raw materials like daal, flour, vegetables, fruits etc. from shops but is not allowed to eat cooked food by non-devotees. He writes that so long as the cooked food has the stamp of Khalsa, it is okay to eat such food. In the light of above, you don’t have to be an organic food eater to be a Bibeki Khalsa of Guru Dashmesh jee. All bibeki Singhs whether Nihungs, Taksalis, Jatha Singhs or whatever, follow this rule of buying raw materials from outside but cooking themselves. Singhs of olden times, when they used to live in the jungles, used to accept raw materials but not cooked food. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Caffiene

Singh · 17 Dec 2003

I understand only eating from Amrit Dharees, But could someone explain why some people only eat from other Sarblohis?

Re: Caffiene

G · 17 Dec 2003

they got Coffe-crisp in Cali

Re: Caffiene

Amardeep Singh · 18 Dec 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Is this for real? are people really advocating eating food prepared and served by other people within the same rehit. If it's true how is this different from the Brahmins who refuse to even touch anything that has been associated by someone of a lower caste ? I thought Sikhi was supposed to take us away from all of these things. If some "Gurmukh Pyara" wants to do langar seva in a gurdwara should we turn them away just because they have not partaken in Amrit? If anyone thinks that's the case then you'll have a shortage of sevadaars in a majority of the gurdwaras all over the world ? I know let's go one step further and not even talk to or associate with non Amritdharee's. And then not content with that we can rewrite almost half of the Baani, because there's no way we can have the Baani's of Baba Farid, Bhagat's NaamDayv, Trilochan, Ravidaas and all the other non Sikhs recited in there. (Just in case anyone doesn't get I'm being Sarcastic !!!) In my humble opinion no matter how good the intentions of a Rehat Marayada are and regardless of whose it is, whether its AKJ or SGPC or DamDami Taksaal, it's still a man made Marayada and through no fault of its own is limited in foresight to some extent. e.g. SGPC's rehat forbids any Non-Sikh from performing Kirtan, so based on that logic Bhai Mardana would be forbidden from playing the Rabaab in any gurdwara today, does that make sense ? Also this same Rehat Marayada allows meat to be eaten when another one doesn't. Why the differences ? Also based on this logic by not accepting food from certain people it implies that people following a Rehat are of a higher status than people who are not, surely this is not the message of the Baani that we should attain to be this status. The message of the Baani is to attain one's self with the almighty and that regardless of caste, creed, color this will be achieved by Naam Jaapna, Kirt Karhnaa and Wand Kay Shaknaa Sure we should partake in Amrit and formally wear the "Uniform" and have the outer appearance but by doing this, it shouldn't propogate people to a higher status where others are looked at differently. If we start to do this, then in my humble opinion we haven't achieved what we set out for. Once this stage is reached you start to see Waheguru's creation in everything. This is just my humble opinion, and if my brothers or sisters out there wish to point out where I have erred then I would truly welcome the opportunity.

Re: Caffiene

Caffeine · 18 Dec 2003

WJKK WJKF i dint want this to turn into A DEBATE PYARIO. simply, i dont really eat caffeine products. then i had a quench for chocolate. i think caffiene is harmless, and if can be avoided, should be. wjkk wjkf

Re: Caffiene

Mkhalsa · 18 Dec 2003

Dearest Caffeine.. do you know a lot of people that just cant pass a day without chaa in the morning and/or evening? i do, most of my family is like this, most punjabis are like this. isnt that an addiction? well, i ask my family members that and they say, "no way, its just something nice and hot to drink every day" really? try and go a day without it, "nah then i will be grumpy" so ur addicted then? "no, i just dont like not having it" caffeine is highly addictive, gurmukhs should not be addicted to anything but naam, all other addictions are distracting and will take one away from simran.. as for amardeep singh jee... where to start!! >>>If some "Gurmukh Pyara" wants to do langar seva in a gurdwara should we turn them away just because they have not partaken in Amrit?<<< gurmukh pyara? what makes one a gurmukh (one who follows gurus command) when they have not followed gurus command and taken amrit? big time gurmukh eh? what if some gurmukh pyara wants to make degh, should we just turn them away? what if that gurmukh pyara says, "HEY!! I want to be in panj pyaras (its happening at a certain gurudwara here)" should we allow them, who cares if they havent taken amrit? they are still gurmukh pyara.. what makes them gurmukh pyara? the fact that they come to gurudwara every sunday, make some rotis, eat some parshad and then go home and shave, eat meat, and drink? are these actions of a gurmukh pyara? and bibek is VERY different from actions of a brahmin.. brahmins beleive in a birth concept, no matter what a lower caste person does to prove themselves, they can never be a brahmin and a brahmin will never eat from them!! but amritdharis eat from amritdharis, as it has been from guru sahibs time, anyone can take amrit, no matter what their birth, status, gender, occupation, race, creed, religion (well after amrit they will be sikh)... so this comparison is actually insulting! and then you will say well what about the mona who doesnt eat meat or drink or smoke, arent they a sehajdhari? they still cut hteir hair dont they? last time i checked there are 4 bujjar kuraits, drinking/nasha/smoking, cutting hair, eating meat, premarital sex.. so being a drunk, a pervert or a meat eater is just as bad as cutting ones hair. anyway, ive replied to posts like this again and again for 2 years, i am done :)

Re: Caffiene

Amardeep Singh · 18 Dec 2003

Dearest MKhalsa Ji, Just to respond your comments, what makes a Gurmukh Pyara, in my humble opinion is someone who serves the almighty in some capacity whether it be through Naam Simran, Seva or any other service. Sure people stray from the path, and don't do this at all times like we're supposed to all the time, but one shouldn't think of them as being in a lower catergory. Moreover, you should do Ardaas for them and ask for God's Blessings to show them the right way all the time. I'm simply pointing out that based on your concept of AmritDhari's eating from only AmritDhari's seems to be not in line with what little knowledge I have learned from our beloved Baani. I may be wrong, and if I am, I hope that Waheguru will one day show me the right way. There is no doubt in my mind that all Sikhs should aspire to partake in Amrit, but from my experience and dealings with people who have taken Amrit once this happens it's really a small issue in the big scheme of things. It was mentioned that Amritdhari's eat from AmritDhari's as of Guru Sahib's time, could you please educate me to some material that shows this ? either some literature or info on the web, as I am interested in learning more about this. I just find it to hard to fathom that even Guru Gobind Singh Ji could turn down food from Bhai Nand Lal or other non sikh people that he was associated with and say you haven't taken Amrit so I cannot eat anything you give me. Or that Guru Nanak would not eat from Bhai Mardana. Any information you can provide will be greatly appreciated... Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Caffiene

Singh 0 · 18 Dec 2003

Kulbir Singh Thank you for your reply, it does shed some light on the issue. But it still doesn’t make sense to me that Guru Ji would ban us from eating food cooked by non Amrishari’s but allow us to add products made by non Amrishari’s to our food, which is essentislly the same. I have never heard Guru Ji ever state the above. Food stuffs such as butter which we all use in the Karah Prashad are also not raw materials but already made which we add to our shabzi, parotai etc. So it’s a food product we always eat yet was certainly not made by Amridhari’s therefor we are saying one thing but actually doing another.

Re: Caffiene

Singh 0 · 18 Dec 2003

Mkhalsa Please would you clarify if a Sikh is allowed to eat onions and other such products in your opinion of Sikhi. I think that to make your earlier statement and not comment on my question posted below is wrong as if that is what you think Sikhi is about you should be able to justify it and not ignore it and instead debate about other things. Kulbir Singh I just re-read your response to my comment about organic food (after I just posted a second ago), and you say we don’t need to only eat organic food to be Bibeki Khalsa of Guru Ji. But this means that you are happy for us to use chemical gasses and poisons on living insects and small animals. Surely to refuse killing chickens or what ever for food and on the other hand saying you can eat food which was produced using poisonous gasses to kill other animals makes no sense, and is a blatant contradiction. Perhaps I’ve got the wrong end of the stick, please can you clarify your justification on eating such food produced by such methods.

Re: Caffiene

Balpreet Singh · 18 Dec 2003

I request everyone who has a question about bibek and the importance of it in gurmat to please read the article in the Gurmat Section. Some people are arguing that butter/flour are not raw materials. I believe they are and it is generally the understanding among Singhs that ghee is a pure substance. However, if someon finds that this is not bibekee according to their own understanding, no one is stopping them from finding their own alternatives. If you don't think flour is bibekee, then some Singhs do grind their own. Do what you think is right and as much as you can. That's what I think most Singhs do. But don't challenge the concept of bibek. If you read the above mentioned article and have doubts or wish to contest something, then please do so.

Re: Caffiene

Mkhalsa · 19 Dec 2003

Amardeep veer jee, sorry for being so harsh. >>>>one shouldn't think of them as being in a lower catergory. Moreover, you should do Ardaas for them and ask for God's Blessings to show them the right way all the time.<<<< i entirely agree with you. who in this thread has said non amritdharis are lower than them? i have never said that, and i truly dont beleive anyone else beleives that. the truth is, us bibekee singhs are nothing but keerae, well i cant speak for others, but i myself am just an insect, i have no good qualities. because of this, the little good will i have inside me i would like to keep. have you ever heard the phrase, you are what you eat? if i continually eat food made by a person with an undisciplined/manmukhi mind, what will happen to my own mind? i will continue to do simran, only to continuously wipe off the karam i keep creating and will not move ahead! because of my incredible weakness and sensitivity in what i eat and who it comes from, i have a discriminating intellect, or bibek, in what i eat. if i were to eat something from someone who thinks unpure thoughts a lot and does unpure/manmukh things.. i can feel it.. deeply and it doesnt feel good. such bibek only comes when guru sahib deems it appropriate for u to have. the more simran you do the more u realize what is right and wrong, whether it be with food or other things.. think about it, you already have some bibek.. thats why you dont drink or smoke. maybe you dont eat meat.. also, who said bhai nand lal jee and bhai mardana jee were not sikhs of the guru? do you actually beleive that somebody could spend their entire life with guru nanak sahib jee maharaj and NOT become a sikh? no! bhai mardana jee was definitely a sikh of the guru. Bhai nand lal jee was also amritdhari. how could a non amrithdari write so much bani and write rehat of the khalsa without being a khalsa themselves? wouldnt that make them a hypcrite? are khalsa so shameful that they follow hypocrites? NO!!! bhai nand lal jee was a great GURSIKH!

Re: Caffiene

Hold up · 19 Dec 2003

are u serious onions dont have alcohol?:S

Re: Caffiene

Mkhalsa · 19 Dec 2003

most fruits and vegetables also contain arsenic, are we to stop eating all togehter? haha.. we shouldnt take it to such an extreme. any alcohol that could be present in onions burns off when cooked anyway. coffee is a full on caffeine drink, which is a drug. you might as well take caffeine pills. decaffinated tea has small amounts of caffeine so that might be somewhere where you could have caffeine in moderation, but even that isnt caffeine free. anyway we should just do what we think is right and not criticize others who follow stricter rehat.

Re: Caffiene

Hold up · 19 Dec 2003

caffiene has a alcohol??? i am very shocked... but it burns away.. what if you eat raw onions?????????????

Re: Caffiene

p · 19 Dec 2003

Coming to the cooking part I pose a question to all the knoledgeable ones out there.... Who was the cook of Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee Maharaj?

Re: Caffiene

Singh 0 · 19 Dec 2003

M Khalsa "most fruits and vegetables also contain arsenic, are we to stop eating all togehter? haha.. " Your above comments appears to contradict what you said in your first post. Any way onions do contain alcohol this is a fact, as do so many other fruits etc. I am referring to Mkhalsa’s statement that one should not take caffeine in any form as it’s a nasha, but surely alcohol is also a nasha but Mkhalsa you appear to have no problems with it when contained in for instance onions. So what if we eat raw onions, even cooking them will release residues into our food in the form of evaporation and steam so in you opinion Mkhalsa are we doing something against Gurmat considering your earlier statement about a much lesser nasha caffeine in crisps. I thank Balpreet Singh for attempting to answer my earlier question and would appreciate a response from Kulbir Singh about my above two posts. I have read the article in the Gurmat section but it doesn't shed any light on whats being discussed here. I think if one is to do Bibek its being hypocritical to say don’t eat crisps from packets but at the same time eat other products made by non Amridhari’s and justify it as raw materials. Surely butter from the shops has already been made and all we do is eat it, so we are really not doing Bibek if that’s what you believe in. Can we really have it both ways by saying we will not eat food made by non Amridhari’s from the shops but at the same time eat food made 100% from non Amridhari’s. At the end of the day a meal is made from ingredients so if the ingredients are meat it’s a meat meal, if the ingredients are organic its an organic meal and if the ingredients have been made by non Amridhari’s its not a meal made 100% by Amridhari’s just the final bit.

Re: Caffiene

Kulbir Singh · 19 Dec 2003

------- Thank you for your reply, it does shed some light on the issue. But it still doesn’t make sense to me that Guru Ji would ban us from eating food cooked by non Amrishari’s but allow us to add products made by non Amrishari’s to our food, which is essentislly the same ---------- Singh 0 jeeo, if it does not make sense to you, then you are free to not adopt this rehit. Khalsa faith is not about zabardastee (forcing). This is what we know from Gurbani and gursikhs books that eating from non-devotees is wrong. You are talking about food, Guru Sahib prohibits us to even avoid their sangat. If bad waves can travel just by doing their sangat, I am pretty sure the food made by them cannot be “Food from Sachkhand”. The concept of bibek is limited to cooked food and source of money used to buy raw materials for food. This is what we know from the Singhs. You can call Sarblohee Singhs in India to find out. They follow this rehit. Same is written in the books of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. In the inspirational stories section of this site, there is a wonderful story of Baba Mitt Singh jee. Baba jee was not from Jatha but was a very strict sarblohi Singh and followed bibek. Read that story to find out how singhs about 100 years ago used to keep rehit. Gurbani makes it clear that food prepared by a Sikh and one who does not do Naam is different: SANTAN KA DANA ROOKHA, SO SARAB NIDHAAN|| GREH SAAKAT CHHATEEH PARKAR, TAY BIKHOO SAMAAN|| (The 36 kinds of delicious foods prepared by saakat (one who doesn’t do bhagtee) are like poison. On the other hand dry and simple food of Gursikhs is like nector). Singh 0, do you need more proof after this pankiti? Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Caffiene

its hard · 19 Dec 2003

u know what dont make snese onions having alchol HA GIVE ME SOME PROOF!

Re: Caffiene

Mkhalsa · 20 Dec 2003

Well, fruits and vegetables that are going bad have high amounts of alcohol due to fermentation, this is why we dont eat them. These are natural quantities and its common sense not to eat something thats gone bad. Singh 0, you think WAYYYYYYYY too much! parr parr bhoolehi chottaa khaahi || Reading and studying, one becomes confused, and suffers punishment. bahuth siaanap aavehi jaahi || By great cleverness, one is consigned to coming and going in reincarnation. naam japai bho bhojan khaae || One who chants the Naam, the Name of the Lord, and eats the food of the Fear of God guramukh saevak rehae samaae ||5|| becomes Gurmukh, the Lord's servant, and remains absorbed in the Lord. ||5|| like you said, we arent brahmins.. so look at bibek from a reasonable point of view. you are just going off on all these crazy tangents.. its like what if my lettuce was grown with cow dung, its dirty now isnt it? oh man now i cant eat it, might as well starve to death.. its ridiculous, just be reasonable about it, you act as if rehatdhari gursikhs are some kind of fanatics.

Re: Caffiene

p · 21 Dec 2003

I pose a question to all the knowledgeable ones out there.... Who was the cook of Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee Maharaj? Can some one tell me who was the cook or nobody knows it? or is it a secret.........

Re: Caffiene

Amit · 21 Dec 2003

I found a similar topic on another site, and I'll write the same points here. My view of Sikhi is that everything is not to be taken very literally. Sitting on the floor to eat langar is not about sitting on the floor to eat, it's about equality of all human beings being able to serve, eat, and be together. On the topic of amritdharies eating from only amritdharies, I believe the purpose to be that we eat with the right company. If I eat a pizza with people who drink and smoke and talk about things which I won't mention here, I will be affected by those people, not by the food. The same goes if I eat a pizza with Sikhs, I will be affected by them (albeit in a good way). When this rehit was made, carry out and delivery food wasn't available. If you wanted a meal and didn't cook it yourself, you went to someone else's place to eat, and would eat with them, therefore be affected by them. This is the reason why Sangat is so important; it surrounds us with people on the same path who will support us and nuture us. Take some langar home and share a meal of it with some people who aren't on the path. You'll see that you are affected by their company. I don't mean to affend anyone, but I wanted to say my piece, and if I'm wrong, then hopefully Waheguru will show me the way.

Re: Caffiene

Kulbir Singh · 22 Dec 2003

------- I pose a question to all the knowledgeable ones out there.... Who was the cook of Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee Maharaj? Can some one tell me who was the cook or nobody knows it? or is it a secret......... --------- Guru Sahib did not have a separate cook for himself. There used to be Guru ka Langar that everyone including Guru Sahib ate. No historical text gives account of Guru Sahib having a separate cook for himself. Some people now a days say that Gangu Brahmin was Guru Sahib's cook. This argument does not hold any ground when we look at historical evidence. Gangu surely used to live in Siri Anandpur Sahib and was known to Guru jee's family but this does not mean that he was a cook. Gangu most probably was a Sikh but it looks like he lived at Anandpur Sahib before 1699 Vasaakhi and thus missed out on taking amrit. He did not deserve amrit either. Before 1699 Sikhs were not required to use "Singh" in their name. In any case Gangu was not a cook of Guru Sahib. No old historical evidence proves that he was a cook of Guru Sahib. Daas, Kulbir Singh