Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh Women, do they have full rights? Do they want full rights?

Sikh Women, do they have full rights? Do they want full rights?

Topic of Seva · 18 Apr 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh, 1. Is it sack religious to have women serve on Panj Piara de Seva (when did this practice start)? 2. Is Palki Seva exclusive to only men? 3. In allowing women to serve in theses types of seva are we redefining Sikh as we know it? Are we changing the religion? 4. Is Sikhi a religion that focuses on gender in certain areas and ignores it in others? 5. Is this male female division a result of culture or is it truly a reflection of the Sikh experience that we attempt to erase in a quest to highlight false equality? Please those who are well versed in Sikhi please respond I would like to understand these issues clearly. Also if moderators of Tapoban Gurdwara can respond it will be appreciated. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh! ----- article attached --------------------------------------------------------------------- ____________________________________________________________ [themaninbluediscussiongroup] A response to Mejindarpal Kaur Mejindarpal Kaur Ji, Your passion for equal opportunity in sewa speaks loudly in“Myths About Sikh Women And Seva”. Your efforts to distinguish between “myths” and “Gurmat” is commendable. However, what is most interesting is that the issue of sewa and women in Darbar Sahib did not stem from the women living in Punjab but citizens or residents of a western nation. I believe this deserves some closer introspection. The concept of equal rights between men and women or women’s rights differ greatly in Punjab compared to the west. Further, the women of Punjab also differ greatly than the women of the West. Although, one may live the complete Sikh lifestyle while being born and bred in the west, it is impossible to ignore that western influence and ideologies undoubtedly factor into ones approach to life, religion, politics, and gender. Unlike women of the west, Sikh women of Punjab never needed to fight for equal rights. The Guru blessed Sikhs with such an enlightenment that no complexes could survive in the mind of any Sikh, be it a man or woman if he or she had true love for Him. Thus, when western Sikh women bring their western complexes or ideologies of equal rights or women’s rights into Punjab, they are not only questionable but plain unnecessary. On the same note, the average Sikh woman in Punjab does not distinguish between sewas. Her aim is to do as much sewa as possible before she is to either walk or take the bus home to feed her family, take care of daily chores and deal with daily struggles in a society that does not care if her son, daughter, or any Sikh is murdered, raped, or soon to become the victim of drugs. In fact, she will only do sewas that are dominated with women because her modesty, intelligence, self confidence does not allow her to be placed in circumstances that can not provide her personal comfort. Furthermore, sewa at Darbar Sahib is never limited. One can find countless possibilities for doing sewa around the clock and women do participate in almost all of them. Thus, I find your tireless efforts to bring equality in sewa at Darbar Sahib suspicious. With your western knowledge, one would imagine you to not take such great lengths to respond to myths that probably only a very few have ever pondered over in Punjab. What I mean to say is, few people think as you do in Punjab. Their understanding of their culture explains without question why women do not participate in all of the sewas. You may be a Sikh. but you are nevertheless a western Sikh. Moreover, if the concern is sewa, one must first question herself of what is the purpose of sewa? Does it mean that we must do exactly what men do? Does it mean doing anything to serve Guru’s sangat? Does the type of sewa have any weight on its importance? Do intentions matter in sewa? I believe western Sikh women must answer these questions first before demanding the right to sewas that have traditionally been performed by men. It is just as important to understand that division of sewa does not equate to discrimination, sexism, or violation of any rights. There is equality in distinctiveness. Just as men and women sit separately in the Gurdwara, they nevertheless are completely equal. The myths you have listed, I agree, are just myths. But I am still concerned why you were not able to recognize that socio-cultural reasons specific only to west may be influencing your perception of the division that exist in some of the sewas? Since I find the myths to be meaningless and the “Gurmat” responses to consequently bear the same meaningless weight, I am only concerned with why women should or should not be allowed to do the two sewas you mentioned: Palki Sahib and Panj Pyare. During amritvela, when Palki sewa is performed, it is dominated by men. However, you are aware of one of the reasons why women are not part of the sewa, as you provided us with the following “Gurmat” explanation: “It is ignorant to suggest that no Sikh woman would have the statureto shoulder the weight of the Palki Sahib, assisted by other bearers. It isnaive to suggest that a Sikh woman would attempt to do this seva unless she has the strength to do so.” Of course there are some exceptionally masculine women out there who could support the weight of the Palki Sahib, but most women are not so strong. Consequently, the sewa will always be dominated by men. Further, and more importantly, when the sewa of Palki Sahib is performed, there is such crowding that it is impossible to avoid close contact with others around you. For this reason, Sikh Punjabi women will choose never to be part of it and that is why you will always find women standing very near the Palki Sahib as it are carried. Lastly, it crucial to point out that dislike of close contact between men and women is actually a desired norm in Sikh society. Now to the Panj Pyare issue. This is particularly a sensitive issue and deserves more discussion than I can provide in this response. However I will attempt to shed some light. First, as Sikhs we all must agree that anything the Guru did was unquestionably perfect. Secondly, during the creation of the Panj Pyare, women actually practiced more of their religious rights than they do today. This is the reason why we have countless women figures like Mata Sahib Kaur and Mai Bhago. Taking these facts into account we can conclude that women could have been part of the initiation but were not, and this is how Guru Ji desired it. To doubt this is to doubt Guru. Now, one may argue as you have Mejindarpal Ji, that there were no white Sikhs around that time, so does that mean Whites can not be part of the ceremony? This, I think is an unnecessary question if one thoroughly examines Sikh history and culture. Sikhi is color blind, not gender blind. As I have stated earlier, there is equality is distinctiveness. Further, to suggest that a tradition that was initiated by Guru should be altered to fit the times is clear blasphemy. I think you would agree with this? Again, Guru could have made one, even all of the Panj Pyare females but He did not. Thus, as humble servants of Guru, we should accept and practice the tradition as it is. Furthermore, the Panj Pyare issue in Punjabi Sikh society is not only non-existent but to generate such an issue would be, again, plain unnecessary. The Sikh women of Punjab have such great shardah, commitment, and practice of true love for Guru, that to demanda part in Panj Pyare sewa would be considered, by them, sacrilegious. Moreover, such an issue has never concerned Sikh women of Punjab, as they have never found their roles as women to be inferior, unlike western women who constantly measure their freedom or equality in relation to men’s. Women in Punjab do not feel “free” by being in very close proximity with men in the Public eye, whether it maybe a religious setting or not. This is true even if a woman stands at a bus stop in Punjab. She expects any man waiting along with her to be at least five to ten feet away. This is the kind of freedom and control she possess in Punjabi and Sikh society. Thus, bringing in western generated ideas of freedom, equal rights, or women’s rights does not sit well in a society in which women do not demand to be treated like men but instead as respectable women. Sincerely, Karandeep Kaur www.Sikhe.com Myths About Sikh Women And Seva By Mejindarpal Kaur Wednesday, May 14, 2003 - 05:38 AM IDLW It has been suggested that Sikh women should not be allowed to participate in certain seva. Answers from Gurmat to excuses for disallowing seva are given below. During seva a Sikh woman would have to endure Eve-teasing, jostling, or she may indeed be involved in sexual misdemeanors. GURMAT: A Sikh woman is less likely to be a victim of eve teasing at a Gurdwara, let alone Darbar Sahib, Amritsar, than she is at any other public place. Jostling should be brought under control by the management by hiring properly trained and polite Sevadaars who can ensure orderly conduct at Gurdwaras. To suggest that Sikh women will indulge in sexual misconduct during seva is an insult to the devotion and integrity of all Sikh women. However, should any untoward incident take place, it will involve both a man and a woman and both parties should be appropriately dealt with. Misconduct by Sikh men should not punish Sikh women. All efforts should be taken to punish the miscreants. A menstruating Sikh women should not be allowed to do seva and it would be difficult to establish if she is menstruating when she requests to do seva. GURMAT: There is no prohibition in Sikhism on a woman undertaking any Seva or prayer when she is menstruating. Guru Nanak Dev Ji declared in Asa Ki Vaar: Sebho Sootak Bharam Hae….All belief in the Brahminical concept of sootak is mere superstition. Guru Nanak Dev Ji goes on to say….that the superstition of sootak can only be erased by spiritual knowledge…Nanak Sootak Aave Na Utarae Gian Utarair Dhoae. As a woman has her periods, month after month, so does falsehood dwell in the mouth of the false; they suffer forever, again and again. They are not called pure, who sit down after merely washing their bodies. Only they are pure, O Nanak, within whose minds Vaheguru abides. || 2 || (page-472: Mehla-1) Sikh men wear their kecchera as an outer garment during the cleaning seva in Darbar Sahib, however, it would be improper for a Sikh woman to do the same as it may be distracting for Sikh men. GURMAT: There is no need for Sikh men and women to dress alike during seva. A Sikh woman could be asked to dress in a manner, which is respectful of her presence in the Darbar Sahib. Any tradition, which prevents a Sikh woman from exercising her right to do seva, has to be modified accordingly. Sikh women have never done seva at Darbar Sahib, be it for cleaning the Darbar Sahib or for doing Kirtan. Why start a new tradition? Further, they may distract the Surt (spiritual link) of the male sangat. GURMAT: There is no historical evidence to suggest that Sikh women did not ever do seva at Darbar Sahib. To the contrary, Sikh history is replete with examples of seva done by Sikh women. Further, since equality of women was recognised by Guru Nanak Dev Ji, there is no theological basis to suggest that Sikh women were prohibited from doing seva at Darbar Sahib. Sikh women have done Kirtan at all other gurdwaras, including Takht Sahibs where the distraction to the male surt has not been an issue. Why should it be any different at Darbar Sahib Ji? Due to the weight of the Palki Sahib, a woman would not be able to carry it on her shoulders. GURMAT: It is ignorant to suggest that no Sikh woman would have the stature to shoulder the weight of the Palki Sahib, assisted by other bearers. It is naïve to suggest that a Sikh woman would attempt to do this seva unless she has the strength to do so. There is always a heavy rush following the Palki Sahib seva during the Sukhasan and Parkash ceremonies. If Sikh women are allowed to undertake the Palki Sahib seva, they could be 'roughed' up in the rush and could give rise to more problems. GURMAT: There should be no disorderly conduct during any of these ceremonies as it is unbecoming conduct at a holy place. The SGPC management should engage suitably trained Sevadaars to ensure orderly ceremonies. Therefore, if the ceremonies stewards do their job well, the question should not arise about any risk to Sikh women during these ceremonies. Types of Seva: 1. Palki No Sikh woman has ever done such seva previously. Why start a new tradition? GURMAT: Equal opportunity is not a tradition but a right. We are aware of instances where a Sikh woman has done the palki sahib seva. The Palki Sahib ceremony is a ritual and no Sikh, man or woman should do it anyway. GURMAT: Rituals or Karam Kaand are prohibited in Sikhism. But if a Sikh, man or woman performs a religious act as an act of love for the Guru, it is not a Karam Kand. A Sikh should be made aware of this and the SGPC should not allow any act of the ceremony to take the shape or form of a Karam Kaand. If any aspect of the palki seva is ritualistic, SGPC should end it. 2. Panj Piaré Panj Piaré seva: In 1699 when Guru Gobind Singh Ji called for volunteers to be one of the panj piaré, no woman rose to the challenge and so she should be excluded from the panj piaré seva today. GURMAT: The social realities of 1699 were very different from today. However, it must be remembered that Mata Sahib Kaur was bestowed the custodianship of the Khalsa. An Amritdhari Sikh woman partakes amrit from the same crucible and ceases to be seen as a woman or man in her spiritual role as one of the panj piaré. Since women were not one of the panj piaré in 1699, are Sikh women, therefore, not to take amrit today? Further, since there were no European Sikhs in 1699, should European Sikhs be disallowed from being one of the Panj Piaré too? Using historical events to distort Sikh principles is a sign of ignorance. mÚ 1 ijau jorU isrnwvxI AwvY vwro vwr ] jUTy jUTw muiK vsY inq inq hoie KuAwru ] sUcy eyih n AwKIAih bhin ij ipMfw Doie ] sUcy syeI nwnkw ijn min visAw soie ]2] {pMnw 472} pd ArQ: jorU-iesq®I [ isrnwvxI-nHwauxI, mwhvwrI ^Un [ vwro vwr-hr mhIny, sdw [ jUTy-JUTy mnu`K dy [ jUTw-JUTw [ eyih-Ajyhy mnu`K [ sUcy-su`cy, piv`qr [ AwKIAih-AwKy jWdy hn [ ij-jo mnu`K [ soeI-auhI mnu`K [ ijn min-ijnHW dy mn ivc [ soie-auh pRBuU [2[ ArQ: ijvyN iesq®I Æ’ sdw hr mhIny nHwauxI AwauNdI hY (qy ieh Apiv`q®qw sdw aus dy AMdroN hI pYdw ho jWdI hY), iqvyN JUTy mnu`K dy mUMh ivc sdw JUT hI rihMdw hY qy ies krky auh sdw du`KI hI rihMdw hY [ Ajyhy mnu`K su`cy nhIN AwKy jWdy jo inrw srIr Æ’ hI Do ky (Awpxy vloN piv`qr bx ky) bYT jWdy hn [ hy nwnk! kyvl auhI mnu`K su`cy hn ijnHW dy mn iv`c pRBU v`sdw hY [2[ If one accepts the concept of impurity, then there is impurity everywhere. In cow-dung and wood there are worms. As many as are the grains of corn, none is without life. First, there is life in the water, by which everything else is made green. How can it be protected from impurity? It touches our own kitchen. O Nanak, impurity cannot be removed in this way; it is washed away only by spiritual wisdom. || 1 || FIRST MEHL: The impurity of the mind is greed, and the impurity of the tongue is falsehood. The impurity of the eyes is to gaze upon the beauty of another man's wife, and his wealth. The impurity of the ears is to listen to the slander of others. O Nanak, the mortal's soul goes, bound and gagged to the city of Death. || 2 || FIRST MEHL: All impurity comes from doubt and attachment to duality. Birth and death are subject to the Command of the Lord's Will; through His Will we come and go. Eating and drinking are pure, since the Lord gives nourishment to all. O Nanak, the Gurmukhs, who understand the Lord, are not stained by impurity. || 3 || - Interpretation of a passage from page 472 of Sri Guru Granth Sahib -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Blab-away for as little as 1¢/min. Make PC-to-Phone Calls using Yahoo! Messenger with Voice. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Yahoo! Groups Links To visit your group on the web, go to: http://uk.groups.yahoo.com/group/themaninbluediscussiongroup/ [%sig%]

Re: Sikh Women, do they have full rights? Do they want full rights?

anon · 18 Apr 2006

Kulbir Singh..... Any thoughts?

Re: Sikh Women, do they have full rights? Do they want full rights?

E · 19 Apr 2006

"Since women were not one of the panj piaré in 1699, are Sikh women, therefore, not to take amrit today?" ---------------------------------------------------------------- just because women wernt in panj doesnt mean they cant take amrit, truth is always the truth truth = 5 singhs in panj, this truth was started in 1699, when dasm patsah founded the khalsa truth still is the truth , ie panj = panj singh if there were 5 singhnees in original panj, then it would have always been 5 singhnees if there were 3 singhnees and 2 singhs, it would always be 3 singhnees and 2 singhs it was preordained that panj pyare were to be 5 singhs, god os not practicing inequality, just as it wasnt inequality to make all 10 guru's male females have not been disadvantaged by this, its just one of the roles singhnees are not supposed to play i have contacted several bibia and singhs from bhai sahibs time, some new him very well all have said singhs make up panj there were many bibia in bhai sahibs time who were ranggle sajjan, the bibi i asked told me even though there were such gurmukh singhnia they did not do panj seva. ---------------------------------------------------------- "Further, since there were no European Sikhs in 1699, should European Sikhs be disallowed from being one of the Panj Piaré too? Using historical events to distort Sikh principles is a sign of ignorance." ----------------------------------------------------------- what a silly argument, theres no difference between a singh living in india and one living in europe, except they live in different places there is a difference between a singh and a singhnee, and dont say there isnt, if there isnt can a singh get pregnant? can a singh marry a singh? can a singh breast feed? bhai mokham singh, bhai tharam singh, bhai sahib singh, bhai himmat singh bhai daya singh - panj singh were preordained. another bibi questioned on the area spoke to babu mal singh now if you think you know better than a bram gyiani theres no point continuing this discusion when the bibi asked if singhia should be put in panj, babu ji said NO, panj pyare are 5 panj singh, in exceptional circumstances if there arent 5 singhs who can be found, then and only then may a singhnee take a singhs role in the panj (note the word exceptional) this is gurmat from a true gurmukh, not manmat which has evolved from modern day womens magazines

Re: Sikh Women, do they have full rights? Do they want full rights?

aks · 20 Apr 2006

All men and women are equal as guru ji said