Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Bebek - is cheese allowed?

... · 18 Apr 2006

is cheese allowed if one is doing bebek, as it's obviously been made by machines and plus isn't it the same as butter. VJKK, VJKF

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

... · 18 Apr 2006

Butter is a raw material. It's just cream. Cheese is a product. Bibekis dont' use cheese but do make their own paneer.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

... · 18 Apr 2006

Thank You. Another question, if I wanted to make bread would it be all right to use yeast? Also, how do you make your own paneer?

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

S Singh · 18 Apr 2006

Butter you get in supermarkets is not a raw material. Eat what you want who cares. If you want to eat cheese then eat it.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Gandalf · 18 Apr 2006

"..." So you are not allowed to use items that are products? But can use raw materials (to create your own products)? (I thought butter was a product. So is cheese. So is paneer. Milk is the raw material that creates these products) And one could argue, that since milk goes through many stages, touched by many different people (and machines), that it would be a product as well (not a raw material, in the bibeki sense)....also milk is not pure since many, many chemicals are put into it....as are all other foods we get from the super market... Sorry, I am not bibeki, just trying to understand how people think about this... One final question...how does bibek rehit address the use of machinery in the production of food nowadays...is that in line with bibek or not??

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

... · 18 Apr 2006

Milk is a raw material. Butter is just cream that is either churned or skimmed off the top. It's a physical process like crushing wheat to make flour. Cheese or yogourt are a process by which it is heated up and then add cultures etc. It is not a raw ingredient. Bibeki food is prepared by amritdharis while reciting naam/bani. Machines can't do that. It is also the process of making your own food using raw materials (uncooked, and only physically changed eg. by crushing, etc). It's not all that complicated, unless someone wants to make it so. Butter is turned into ghee before use anyways. Paneer is easy to make: boil milk, when boiling add lime juice and it will split into paneer and whey. Strain it through a cloth and you're done. Yeast seems ok to me, but I'm not 100% certain.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Dhahaabshil · 18 Apr 2006

Just a random Q, can you still reach to high spiritual levels without sarbloh bibek?

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Sherbahadar Singh · 18 Apr 2006

WJKK, WJKF I agree with Gandalf. The milk we purchase in the supermarket is anything but pure. It is full of numerous chemicals which make the cows grow faster and produce greater quantities of milk. Not to forget, the machines that are installed on the cow's nipples make them often bleed and this blood is well mixed with the milk. Many other preservatives are added before the milk finally reaches the supermarket. Not to mention, the milk packaging, loading, etc. is handled by many people of whom it is possible may include drug addicts, smokers, alcoholics, rapists amongst other types. One is only fooling himself or herself if they think the milk they get in the supermarket is pure. Also, I am not Bibeki. I am not slandering anyone who is, as I have the utmost respect for those who do adhere to Bibek. However, I never completely understood the concept of Bibeki. Before we discuss further, can someone please tell me precisely in detail what is the EXACT definition of Bibeki food? Thank you. WJKK, WJKF

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

???? · 18 Apr 2006

A website showing how yeast is produced http://www.algistbruggeman.be/en/intro/production.aspx

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

... · 18 Apr 2006

I'm not going to argue with you that milk in supermarkets is bibeki. Ideally it should be from amritdharis. That having been said, the process is automatised and there are no fingers or hands going in it. I only use organic milk so the "chemicals" and mistreatment isn't an issue. Singhs that use this milk also boil it before using it. I don't know how "EXACT" a definition I can give you of bibeki food beyond what I've already given : food prepared by rehitvan amritdhari gursikhs whiel reciting naam or bani, made from raw ingredients. I suggest you look at the article in the Gurmat section of this site for more information.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 18 Apr 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Bhai Sahib 'Dhahaabshil' Jeeo, it is harder and it takes longer to reach any of the khands, because everytime you eat from a non-amritaree there filth sticks onto you, and because the non-bebekis eat so much from non-amritarees they would have so much filth to cleanse in order to reach Saachkhand. The more you eat from a non-amritari the more filth you put on yourself and due to this it becomes so much harder to reach saachkhand. By eating a non-amritarees food one is greatly affected in a negative way, which means in a lot of ways that person would be affected from missing amritvela, obtaining more lust, anger, worldly attachments, greed and then end up leaving Sikhi. Basically, the sins and the mind of the non-amritaree have a effect on you, as they all stick onto you, thus the demons gain more control over the mind and there's more sins to erase. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Gandalf · 18 Apr 2006

"Ideally it should be from amritdharis." ???? What does that mean??

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Gandalf · 18 Apr 2006

"Basically, the sins and the mind of the non-amritaree have a effect on you, as they all stick onto you, thus the demons gain more control over the mind and there's more sins to erase." This is only true if you let it.... Also, if you believe that, the mind of a non-amritdharee have an effect on non-amritdharees (helping people move towards a better Rehit)...an argument FOR eating w/ non-Amritdharees if you are amritdharee.... Sorry but this works both ways....I know this will start an argument about eating/not eating w/ others....but it could be argued that not eating w/ others because they "bring your sikhi down" is selfish

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

... · 18 Apr 2006

I'm sorry Gandalf, I should've been more clear for you. Let me re-phrase it. The milk should be obtained from people who are amritdharis and have milked the cows themselves thus ensuring ethical treatment of the animals and also hygene. Any clearer?

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Manpreet Kaur · 18 Apr 2006

VJKK VJKF i don't understand, how would you do it in countries like Canada, where everything is bought from the supermarkets? Bhul Chuk maaf VJKK VJKF [%sig%]

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Gandalf · 18 Apr 2006

"... " you said "I only use organic milk so the "chemicals" and mistreatment isn't an issue." Just an FYI the the vast majority of the organic milk farms do not mistreat the cows while they are there producing milk (average is 10 years) however once the cows are no longer able to produce milk they are sold to factory farms. In Ontario there are 13 Organic milk farms and none of these farms allow the cows to live out their full life on their farms... they all sell the cows...

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

... · 18 Apr 2006

Gandalf, that's really quite sad. Have you given up milk though?

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

... · 18 Apr 2006

Also, Gandalf, you mentioned, >>>>>> Also, if you believe that, the mind of a non-amritdharee have an effect on non-amritdharees (helping people move towards a better Rehit)...an argument FOR eating w/ non-Amritdharees if you are amritdharee.... >>>>>> I'm not sure what your'e saying here. If you mean that the situation should work the other way as well and amritdharis should have an effect on non-amritdharis, I agree with you 100%. That's why degh and langars exist. Amritdharis preparing the food while reciting naam and bani do have an effect on the food. Non-Amrithdharis eating it will be affected as well. You can eat with a mona every meal of the day if the food is prepared by an amrithdari. It will have a positive effect on the non-amritdhari. There are many stories to this effect.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

ks · 18 Apr 2006

more hypocrisy from the bibek camp: apparently only raw foods can be considered bibek, and then "..." goes to describe the clearly chemical process to make paneer. so which is it, ..., bibek is chemical or physical or simply raw?

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

lsdjkf · 19 Apr 2006

""The more you eat from a non-amritari the more filth you put on yourself and due to this it becomes so much harder to reach saachkhand."" i think this depends on the individual person and their innocence or love, as some non-amritdharis are more inclined to God or Sikhi or purity than others may be. This is why some people, when they reach a certain avastha, (even like bhai sahib bhai jeevan singh ji) will eat from someone based on their love There were many many chardi kala gursikhs that did not keep sarbloh bibek but were still strict about bibek. Nonetheless there are also some gursikhs who can only do what is in their power, as their families may not be amritdhari. Therefore it depends and Guru Sahib is understanding on these things. We should do as much as we can in my humble opinion sorry if i hurt anyone

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

S Singh · 19 Apr 2006

Organic milk is a joke. You pay more and the cows are treated the same by the farmer. I fail to see why you guys take such pride in drinking milk. It is full of rubbish, it even contains puss (see http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=62903 )

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

. · 19 Apr 2006

__________________ There are many stories to this effect. __________________ please share them. [%sig%]

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Gandalf · 19 Apr 2006

Yes I have....I drink Soy milk...

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

PTE SINGH · 19 Apr 2006

I don’t know enough about 'bebeki food’ or their order to make a sweeping general comment on it. I am sure that certain people have different views on it even within the Bebeki community itself and therefore I do not wish to offend those that do have a genuine belief in its relevance to Sikhi. I have no problem with people eating whatever they want and justifying it in any way they wish, however people should be careful not to over emphasise the importance of this activity in Sikhi. Bebeki food is in no way essential to Sikhi or even seen as part of it by most and from some of the comments I have read about it on this forum I would have to say its contradictory and actually goes against the grain of Sikhi. The chap talking about 'non amritdari filth' etc. obviously belongs to another religion altogether, he sounds like a fundamental Hindu. If he speaks for the code of the Bebeki community then as a follower of Sikhism and as a spiritual human I am disgusted by the principle of that community. [%sig%]

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

a singh · 19 Apr 2006

hmm i am too pondering over the concept of bibeki..i am always inspired by giani thakur singhs advice but he never goes into too much detail on this issue..can maybe someone clarify his views? also i dont eat from restaruants or places like maccy D's or KFC or PIZZA HUT or anywhere like that.....i eat from home but we buy all our stuff from veggies to chips to soup from super market ...also sometimes my sister makes the food and she has not taken amrit..i also eat at the langar but i know that the food is not prepared with bani and naam let alone amritdharis.....someone help? :(

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

... · 19 Apr 2006

ks, you said, "apparently only raw foods can be considered bibek, and then "..." goes to describe the clearly chemical process to make paneer. so which is it, ..., bibek is chemical or physical or simply raw?" I'm afraid if people lack common sense and basic information processing systems, there isn't much I can do. If an amritdhari makes the paneer, it's fine. If it's bought from a store, it's not. Amritdharis can use raw ingredients to make what they need. What they do with these raw ingredients is their own choice: make paneer or yogourt, or bread or anything else. Even cooking daal or sabjee is a "chemical process." S Singh, You mentioned milk being "rubbish"; Guru Sahibs all drank milk, pus and all. Degh ie. Karah Parshad is made with milk products. Ramkali Ki Vaar mentions "kheer ghiaalee" ie. buttery kheer. Were Guru Sahib and the Sikhs wrong? You clearly must have information they didn't have? As for stories, please do a search on "Dr Surinder Singh" and how he gave milk to a non-amritdhari that he had prepared with naam and see what happened. Also you have the examples of Baba Ram Singh who used to prepare langar and it would have an effect on all those who ate it (Ranglay Sajjan).

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Makhan · 19 Apr 2006

If people are so particular about what they eat they should not even drink milk or use any milk product. Milk is produced by mammals for theirbabies and not for other animals. Humen are the only animals who steal other mammals milk and no other animal does this. I am unable to give the exact wording of GURUBANI but according to this shabad you must not eat anything which corrupt your thoughts every thing else is OK. It says something like this Baba hor khada khussi khuyar jit khadhye taan peerryhei naam maiin chalei vikkar. Why ask sone body what to eat or not your inner being should tell you. If you observe some thing which is imposed on you, younare not true to yourself. Listen to your soul.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Gandalf · 19 Apr 2006

"..." There is a difference between the milk the Gurus drank back then and the milk we drink today. 1.) Milk back then was not produced at the health of the animals. Animals were treated as they should be (i.e. a life that should be respected) Milk production today requires the torture of animals and does not treat animals properly. 2.) Milk back then could be considered pure (because the animals were not tortured, or becauase it was not pasteurized. Pasteurization puts so many chemicals in milk to keep it "fresh longer".) Milk today is full of pollutants, blood pus, hormones, chemicals. 3.) Milk back then was produced in small amounts, as needed. Cows were milked by hand back then. Milk production today yields 5 to 10 times more milk per cow per day, than is naturally allowed (i.e. the cows are drugged up so they produce more). Basically, the cows are in a factory, and do piece work (without their consent). Cows are milked by machine (which can be very inhumane - how would you like a machine milking you??) 4.) You knew who produced your milk back then (i.e. the farmer down the street etc.). You knew what happened to the milk (i.e. it was clean and pure). You definitely don't know who produces your milk today. You definitely don't know what is in your milk. You definitely don't know what happens to your milk to get it from udder to glass. I don't see how all of this fits in with the bibeki model (i.e. torture of animals, polluted milk) (Also, what proof is there that Gurus placed importance in milk. I thought the only drink they placed importance in was Amrit). [%sig%]

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

... · 19 Apr 2006

Gandalf, You are right that the milk industry in the West does not treat the cows properly. But even in India, the "jhota" (male) is sold to butchers. As I mentioned already, the organic industry has very strict guidelines about drugs/antibiotics to increase yield and rules against inhumane treatment. Agriculture Canada has very strict guidelines about how the milk is handled and processed. I would argue that the chances of there being pollutants or uncleanliness are far less today than before. It's also not true that the milking machines are uncomfortable for the cow. You are right though, that bibeki milk is that which is obtained from amritdhari farmers who have milked the cows themselves and vouch for it. As for "proof" that Guru Sahib placed "importance" in milk: I never claimed they did. I said they drank it and the use of milk in the langar is even mentioned in Bani in Ramkali Ki Vaar (Satta & Balvand). The issues of pus in the milk were the same back then as they are now. Sikh tradition does however place importance on Karah Parshad which is made from ghee.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 19 Apr 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Bhai/Bibi Sahib PTE SINGH, Makhan and Sangat Jeeo (this isn’t referring to entirely everyone; only those who are against the REHIT BEBEK) Seems like most of you don’t have a clue about bebek or Gurbani, as gurbani states so many times that if the filth of anyone, which is the sins, hasn’t been erased then the cloths, life and whatever that person touches is affected in a negative way, HENCE their FILTH is stuck like glue onto those places and so they are CURSED. a(n)thar mail n outharai dhhrig jeevan dhhrig vaes || If inner filth is not removed, one's life is cursed, and one's clothes are cursed. This Gurbani line clearly states that whatever is touched by the manmukh is cursed, which obviously means the way they are will most certainly affect the other person if that person touches the same thing. Only the ones that become Gurmukh and go above Saram Khand will not be affected but will remain pure. saachae mail n laagee man niramal har dhhiaae || The truthful ones are not stained by filth. Meditating on the Lord, their minds remain pure. Just as filth doesn’t stick to water the same way a Gurmukh who leads a pure life will become this and sustain this. Even when one does reach Saram khand that person should still proceed with doing bebek, just to be on the safe side and to reach Vaheguru Jee quicker. If it’s been written for that person, then they will reach Vaheguru Jee quick as it shall be done with Vaheguru Jee’s help. kilabikh kaattai hoe niramalaa janam janam mal jaae || Their sinful mistakes are erased, and they become pure; the filth of countless incarnations is washed away. Also, do you know where this filth comes from? It comes from countless sins that have been committed in your past lives, but if that person doesn’t lead a religious life in this one then whatever he touches becomes cursed, but this doesn’t mean you don’t shake hands or communicate with them, as this is thinking high of yourself and low of them. On the other hand, food is effected much more, so that is why Gursikhs follow this REHIT of GURU JEE, who himself followed it too. Yes Guru Gobind Singh Jee followed this rehit that has been forgotten now, just as the kakaar Keski had been forgotten. Even Guru Nanak Dev Jee didn’t eat from those who practiced falsehood, and to top it all up, he gave a clear example of how cursed the food becomes when he squeezed both food from Lallo and Bhago but from the bread milk gushed forth as it being Lallos whereas blood from Bhagos. This was due to the way they lived their life now. This clearly determines that the way a person lives his/her life and the way that person is would effect another immensely from the food eaten from that particular person, as that person would begin to think the same. Basically you wouldn’t just have your own mind but another’s as well. So this is why Guru Gobind Singh Jee created this hardcore REHIT, as it can save a Sikh from falling. Again, Guru Gobind Singh Jee created not just bebek on its own, but in fact SARBLOH BEBEK, as IRON is special in a spiritual way that no one understands. Also, remember that IRON was established in Kalyug, it holds unknown power, which only some find out about such as Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee. ‘This is why some people, when they reach a certain avastha, (even like bhai sahib bhai jeevan singh ji) will eat from someone based on their love’ Bhai Sahib Jeevan Singh Jee only eat from Amritaree, as he was very strict in Bebek, and Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee was enormously strict in Sarbloh Bebek and so many others have kept this very important FORGOTTEN REHIT as well, BUT! If Guru Gobind Singh Jee kept this rehit why aren’t we? WAIT! If Guru Gobind Singh Jee’s sons, which symbolize what we should be like, kept it as well, AND! Weren’t they all very chardi kala, on high levels, strong faith, mighty warriors etc? So, why did the Khalsa nation drop so much to a few faithless sikhs, as weren’t most sikhs giving up their faith when British Raj was occurring in India? This is due to the reason that the KAKAAR Keski, was erased by goraa and the REHIT sarbloh bebek was forgotten by the sikhs. You may think these things are worldly, but if one doesn’t jap an immense amount of Naam that person can easily lose faith in these and in their religion, again Naam is the SUPPORT of the religion, earth, the Khands and most importantly the Gurdwara SAACHKHAND, as it floats in the air without pillars – Naam is supporting it. Furthermore, Saachkhand is made from the religion SIKHI, and so we need NAAM to support our Sikhi. Though, Bhai Sahib Rama Singh Jee didn’t keep this REHIT, but those who do not keep it find it hard to reach Saachkhand and it takes longer to reach it, but most have failed and fallen due to not keeping bebek. This REHIT is very strong and it would keep the Sikh stable, but only if he does a lot of Naam Bhagti then can this REHIT be accepted, as Naam is the support of all. Sarbloh Bebek helps one on his/her journey, and by keeping this REHIT one won’t fall. In KHALSA RAJ this REHIT will be kept by the Khalsa in Punjab, as all food will be made in Sarbloh as well as Keski shall be worn by all. Finally, Bebeki isn’t a separate community from Sikhs, as it is apart of Sikhi and apart of being a Khalsa. Without completely giving your life to Guru Jee when taking AMRIT how can that person reach Saachkhand, as he/she is stuck in the filth of DUALITY, isn’t this true? Why ask sone body what to eat or not your inner being should tell you. If you observe some thing which is imposed on you, younare not true to yourself. Listen to your soul. How can you listen to the soul if most of the time the mind is doing the talking, and you aren’t making it easier for yourself if your eating from a MANMUKHS HAND. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

. · 19 Apr 2006

has anyone got quotes from bhai sahibs books which confirm gur ka langhar should be done by gursikhs? all quotes/translations will be much appreciated far too many are trying to justify non-amritdharees doing langhar seva.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

<> · 19 Apr 2006

"." , I'm not sure any quotes from Bhai Sahib's books will convince those who don't think Guru Ka Langar should only be made by Amritdharis but pg. 163 of Gurmat Bibek has a section called "Amritdhari Nam Rasiaa(n) da Sajaaiaa Langar hee Guru ka Langar hai" Bhai Sahib says that only tyar-bar-tyar Amritdharis should do seva in langars who keep the rehits given at the amrit sinchar. That langar which is not prepared by Amritdharis is not Guru ka Langar.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Makhan · 19 Apr 2006

I am not against bibek or rehiyat but you have to draw a line. Gandalf said how milk was produced then and now, the question is not how milk is produced drinking an other mammal's milk is against the low of nature. Can you give a single example from natural world where one species of animal suck or drink other mammal's milk? Akal Purkh has not given this right to any form of life on this planet and no body is above Akal Purkh including our GURUS I am a practising sikh and have full faith and dedication in Sikh and respect for our Gurus. I kept my sikhi saroop when I was the only one sikh in the university and at my work place and all 360+ people around my know that I carry my siri sahab all the times.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

... · 19 Apr 2006

No one is above Guru Sahib. If it was unethical to use milk, then you can bet Guru Sahib would have told us. When no one knew about the health risks of tobbaco, Guru Sahib told us. When no one knew how horrible drugs were or meat was, Guru Sahib told us. But you think they didn't know about milk? That Satguru Nanak who is one with Vahiguru would himself make what you would see as a "mistake" and use milk and ghee? And not only that, Guru Arjan Sahib would enshrine the fact that milk and ghee were used in the langar in Bani?? You can have all the logic you want and arguments you want but I for one cannot and will not question anything Guru Sahib said or did. Guru Sahib has mentioned using milk in Bani and Sikhs have been making karah parshad since the time of Guru Nanak and were taught this by Guru Sahib himself. Unless all the Brahm Gyanis and Satguru jee themselvs were wrong (which is impossible), I think milk is fine to use. You said "no body is above Akal Purkh including our GURUS". I suggest you think about what you're saying. Our Gurus were one with Akal Purakh. If you think that you or your vegan buddies know better than Satguru Nanak, you've got serious problems. ਬਲਵੰਡ ਖੀਵੀ ਨੇਕ ਜਨ ਜਿਸੁ ਬਹੁਤੀ ਛਾਉ ਪਤ੍ਰਾਲੀ ॥ ਲੰਗਰਿ ਦਉਲਤਿ ਵੰਡੀਐ ਰਸੁ ਅੰਮ੍ਰਿਤੁ ਖੀਰਿ ਘਿਆਲੀ ॥ ਗੁਰਸਿਖਾ ਕੇ ਮੁਖ ਉਜਲੇ ਮਨਮੁਖ ਥੀਏ ਪਰਾਲੀ ॥ ਪਏ ਕਬੂਲੁ ਖਸੰਮ ਨਾਲਿ ਜਾਂ ਘਾਲ ਮਰਦੀ ਘਾਲੀ ॥ ਮਾਤਾ ਖੀਵੀ ਸਹੁ ਸੋਇ ਜਿਨਿ ਗੋਇ ਉਠਾਲੀ ॥੩॥

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

confused on bibek · 19 Apr 2006

I'm lost on the bibek issue, so I ask for forgiveness of my ignorance on this topic. I understand that keeping the bibek rehit is very essential for a sikh, and I think its a good thing if one can do it. HOwever, I have to wonder how far one can be bibeki when they are living in a country where practically all the food is bought from the grocery store and it was grown by people who are non-amritdhari. In our own garden, we only have enough space to grow tomatoes, eggplants, mircha, zuchinni, long beans, and garlic. Then what about the wheat for flour to make roti? IT comes from some indian shop who get their shipment from Punjab, where it was likely grown etc by a non-amritdhari. my point is, of all the people who say they are bibeki, are they really? Who has their own cow in their backyard today to milk every morning? Who makes their own butter and cheese from that milk? WHo grows all their vegetables? No doubt some do, especially in PUnjab, but in a foreign country? and then some people say the food has to be cooked by an amritdhari to count as bibek food. But what about the farmer where the food started from? Didn't the farming or whatever process add "filth" to that food? I think majority of amritdhari people are not bibeki. What about the family where one person is amritdharhi but their parents and rest of members in the house are not? And the cook in the house is the mother who is not amritdhari? Can the amritdhari child not eat his mother's own cooking anymore? ANd sarabloh utensils aren't even available even in indian shops here. To go to india to find some sarbloh utensils I'd have to take off my kirpan. And what about Guru ka langar? If a non-amritdhari wants to have an akhandpaath and they make the langar then its not Guru ka Langar? Forgive me, but that doesn't make sense to me. I thought langar was that which has had bhog done it. THis would mean that a bibeki person wouldn't eat the langar at the gurdwara in this situation. But even Guru Amar Das ji made it mandatory for everyone to eat the langar before they could have his darshan. I once heard that if an amritdhari is strong in his sikhi with naam, bani, etc...then nothing can affect him. What people say can't hurt him. Then in this case, how would the food he eats from a non-amritdhari affect him? Doesn't stuff only affect you if you think it will? IF you're always worried about who cooked your food and about jooTH for instance, then it definetly will have some affect on your mind. Whereas, if you dont' worry that your mother is nonamritdhari and your eating her cooked food, then it will never affect your mind. I dunno...sorry for a long post, hope it makes sense though and if someone could further explain this I'd appreciate it. juz remember I'm new to this, so don't bash me and kill it.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Gandalf · 19 Apr 2006

... I don't think anyone is saying Milk itself is bad...I agree Gurus did drink milk...but...the way it was made was fine back then I don't understand how anyone can justify drinking any milk that is produced by these methods...everything about how milk is made today is not in line with Sikhi principles (torture of animals, milk is impure etc etc...) You can't just say "Guru did it so that is fine"...You have to accept that the way milk is made has changed since then, and that makes drinking milk different today than it did back then... I find a lot of vegan-bashing going on this site...there is nothing wrong with being vegan...so what if someone doesn't drink milk...does that make them any less of a person??

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Sherbahadar Singh · 19 Apr 2006

WJKK, WJKF Bhupinder Singh Jee, Your arguments are full of so much doggerel that I'll have to tackle them bit-by-bit. "The more you eat from a non-amritari the more filth you put on yourself and due to this it becomes so much harder to reach saachkhand." Why stop here? Unless you've sealed yourself from the outside world in a vacuum chamber with oxygen filtration pumps and only amritari's, what about all the filty non-amritari air you breathe into your lungs all your life? In fact, you breathe more pounds of filthy air in a day than the amount of food in pounds you eat a day. What is your reasoning here? It's your kind of amritari vs. non-amritari dichotomy that hurting the panth more than ever. "By eating a non-amritarees food one is greatly affected in a negative way, which means in a lot of ways that person would be affected from missing amritvela, obtaining more lust, anger, worldly attachments, greed and then end up leaving Sikhi." How does eating food from a non-amritari lead to more lust and anger? This logic is as stupid as saying drinking loads of coffee helps lower your kaam because with such stinking breath, no sane women will ever come near you and hence your induced kaam will be lower. The comments you made about non-amritari's are dehumanizing and I think you should retract them. "Seems like most of you don’t have a clue about bebek or Gurbani, as gurbani states so many times that if the filth of anyone, which is the sins, hasn’t been erased then the cloths, life and whatever that person touches is affected in a negative way, HENCE their FILTH is stuck like glue onto those places and so they are CURSED." I guess we don't, because obviously, you seem to have all the answers. "a(n)thar mail n outharai dhhrig jeevan dhhrig vaes || If inner filth is not removed, one's life is cursed, and one's clothes are cursed." "This Gurbani line clearly states that whatever is touched by the manmukh is cursed, which obviously means the way they are will most certainly affect the other person if that person touches the same thing. Only the ones that become Gurmukh and go above Saram Khand will not be affected but will remain pure." Actually, I think this Gurbani line, when referring to inner filth, is talking about the 5 vices: Greed, lust, ego, anger and attachment. Someone correct me if I'm wrong. "Even Guru Nanak Dev Jee didn’t eat from those who practiced falsehood" And what about non-Sikhs who don't practice falsehood? And what is falsehood? "Basically, the sins and the mind of the non-amritaree have a effect on you, as they all stick onto you, thus the demons gain more control over the mind and there's more sins to erase." Be aware that almost all of the technology you're using right now (and a lot that was used by the Guru's) was either created or modified by non-amritari people. They keyboard you're typing on, the internet you use (which is, for the most part, probably the single largest collection of filth ever conceived by mankind), your fridge, oven and just about everything else, by your definition, are all filthy technology. The bus, subway, library and everything else are also very (VERY!) filthy by your own definition. And what does that make you? Exactly. "This Gurbani line clearly states that whatever is touched by the manmukh is cursed" and then "but this doesn’t mean you don’t shake hands or communicate with them, as this is thinking high of yourself and low of them" You just contradicted yourself. Also, your constant use of "us" and "them" is a very primitive, herd mentality way of thinking. WJKK, WJKF

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

... · 19 Apr 2006

Before adding your thoughts, please be sure to read the article below and address the points there. confused, there are many many Gursikhs in the west that keep sarbloh bibek. Sarbloh utensils are availabe EVERYWHERE. You can order them online. Go to any cookware store and ask for "carbon steel" or "cast iron" and they'll show you lots of utensils. Go to Sacha Sauda in Brampton (if in Toronto) and they have lots of utensils. Vegetables can be bought from markets. Raw materials all can be bought, but the stamp is put on it by amritdharis when it is cooked in sarbloh while reciting naam/bani. This practice of bibek has been followed by Baba Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwale, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh, Akali Kaur Singh, Baba Mitt Singh, Baba Jwala Singh Harkhowal and countless other Gursikhs. It is a mandatory rehit. You said, >>>>>>> If a non-amritdhari wants to have an akhandpaath and they make the langar then its not Guru ka Langar? Forgive me, but that doesn't make sense to me. I thought langar was that which has had bhog done it. THis would mean that a bibeki person wouldn't eat the langar at the gurdwara in this situation. But even Guru Amar Das ji made it mandatory for >>>>>>> Non-amritdharis can have akhand paaths but just like the seva of the paath is done by other amritdharis, same with the langar seva. Do you really think putting a kirpan through something makes it holy? Nihangs put their kirpan through meat and bhang, will you consume that as "parshad" ? Poolah Nang's gang used to put kirpans through alcohol. Is that parshad too? Langar is only that which is prepared by Gursikhs. Otherwise it's not langar. Gursikhs should not eat it. Gandalf, I have no problems with vegans. I don't see ANY vegan bashing on this site at all. My very own sister is a vegan. What I don't agree with is when people say, as Makhan did, that the very concept of using milk is unethical and against nature. Who makes him or others smarter than Guru Sahib? Please stop with "torture, mistreatment" angle. I've already said, organic milk should be used. You know as well as I do that these cows have access to pastures year round and are not injected with any drugs. You are right that it is sad the old cows are sold to butchers. But this is not new or just in the West. Even in India this happens and has happened in the past. Don't get me wrong though. I agree with you that the milk being used is not ideal and ideally the milk should be from amritdhari farmers who are ethical with their animals. I don't think we have much of a disagreement on this point at all. Sherbahadar Singh: It is a fact that the thoughts and words of someone who prepares food as an effect on that food. The Japanese scientist who has studied this has done many talks and written articles on this. Water responds differently to negative emotions and positive emotions. How do you think amrit is created? It is though Gursikhs reciting bani while stirring water and sugar in sarbloh. It is the power of those words transforming simple water and sugar into something much more. In the same way a Gursikh tries to prepare his food in the same manner using bani and sarbloh. There are many lines in bani that say the food of a Manmukh is cursed. Even the shabad "maas maas kar moorakh jhagray" clearly says that saag can be as bad as meat. How? If the money which bought the food was through dishonest means. If food is food and it makes no difference, why didn't Guru Nanak Sahib eat Malik Bhago's food and while having his meal convince him he was doing wrong? Why did he choose to eat nutritionally inferior food at Bhai Lalo's house? Because food matters. >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Guru Ka Langar & Bibek by Bh. Manmohan Singh LA (with minor editing and note by Toronto Sangat) It is an established truth that the food one eats does not only affect the body's health but also influences one 5 mind and thinking. That is why Sahib Sri Guru Nanak Dcv Ji has forbidden eating food which makes the body writhe in pain and fill the mind with evil. That is why he refused to accept the most nourishing and dainty dishes prepared in the house of Malik Bhago but preferred the simple dry food prepared by the so called low-caste carpenter, Bhai Lalo. Similarly, Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji refused to drink water brought by a young man who had never done any service to anyone in his life. Thus, in the Gursikh way of life it is not only the nutrient value of the food that matters but, more importantly, who has prepared it and who serves it. Guru-Ka-Langar, whether prepared in the Gurdwara or in the household of a Sikh can be called Guru-Ka-Langar only if it is prepared by Guru-Ke-Sikhs. This may be the one reason why Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji asked the recipients of the holy Amrit to share food among themselves in the same plate, but forbade them to do so with non-Amritdharis. One of the edicts given at the Baptismal ceremony is: Gursikh di roti beti di saanjh Gursikh naal. The Gursikhs have to share food and establish marital relationships with Gursikhs only This edict is enjoined upon all the baptized Sikhs at the Baptismal ceremony at every Amrit Sanchar in the Panth irrespective of organizations or Jathas arranging it. It is further supported by the following quotation from Rahitnamaa: Jay Kurahtieye Jag Darsaawat. Pahul Peeay Kukaram Kamaavat. Tin So Vartan Nahe Milaawey. Rahey Nirlep Param Sukh Paavey. (Rahitnamaa Bhai Desa Singh Ji) Gursikhs are not to socialize or associate with those who have become apostates. Only then will they lead unaffected and happy lives. Incidently, the above quotation brings out another important point; that even one who has taken Amrit once can become a non-Amritdhari if he commits any of the four Cardinal Sins or big Don'ts. It is, therefore, clear from the above that if a Sikh is to strictly follow the commandments or Code of Conduct enunciated at the time of partaking of Amrit, he has to share food and keep relationships with Gursikhs (i.e., Amritdharis) only. There is no 'elitism' or 'communalism' in it. In fact, it is a practice ordained by Guru Sahib himself. It does not reek of Hinduism or Brahminism, as some people say. In the case of Brahminism, the low-caste people remain untouchable throughout their lives simply because of the accident of their birth, and there is no means by which they can be upgraded and made acceptable, with respect to sharing food with them. In Sikhism, all people, irrespective of their caste, religion, race, country, etc., are welcome to the Khalsa fold. Once they become Khalsa after taking Amrit, they are then an integral part of the Khalsa Panth, and it is always a privilege to share food and contract marital relationship with them, whatever may have been their original faith, race, etc. In fact, this is the holy way employed by the Satguru for the uplift of humanity. Much fuss is made on this point because at the congregations of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha, the Guru-Ka-Langar is generally prepared by Guru-Ke-Sikhs (Amritdharis) only. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh followed this rule strictly and, in addition, had his food prepared in All-carbon Steel vessels. This practice is referred to as Bibek in Sikhism. This tradition of being an All-carbon Steel Bibeki is not an innovation of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh or any other person. It has been in vogue right from the time of Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh ii, who himself set this precept by using all-carbon steel vessels and Khanda for the preparation of the Holy Amrit given to the original Panj Pyaras at the time of the Birth of the Khalsa on Baisakhi of 1699 AD. Since then, certain sections of devout Singhs have been following this principle until even today, not simply for preparing Amrit, but also for preparing food. ***[NOTE: proof for the tradition of Bibekee Singhs can be found in the historical records of M.A. Macauliffe who writes "..so amid the general corruption of the religion of Gobind there are to be found about one hundred Sikhs at Naderh in the Dakhan, who are said to have up to the present time preserved intact the faith and ceremonies of Guru Gobind. They have kept aloof from the contact of Brahmins. Brahmin ministrations are not permitted either at their births, their marriages, or their obsequies. Whether they be Brahmin or Sudras who receive the sacramental pahul, all are by this fact admitted within a pale of social and religious equality. Brahmin weds Sudra and Sudra weds Brahmin. No need, therefore, to put their infant daughters to death through fear of not obtaining for them husbands of their own social status, as is the custom among such a large section of the Sikhs of Punjab. And widow marriages, reprobated by Hindus and now consequently by the Sikhs of the Punjab are habitually solemnised with the clearest conscience among the Sikhs of Naderh...At Patna, as at Naderh, the Sikhs pay the strictest attention to the Injunctions of Guru Gobind. Sleeping or waking, they are never without the habiliments known as the "five Ks." So strong is the aversion of the more orthodox among them to Hindus, that they will not even partake of food cooked by their hands. This is carrying orthodoxy a long way, but still further is it carried when they will not partake of food cooked even by a Sikh who has not on his person all the ‘five Ks’" (Macauliffe in "The Sikh Religion under Banda and its Present Condition") Various Puraatan rehitnamas also make clear the importance of Bibek for a Sikh. Bhai Daya Singh rehitnaama contains the following bachans: "Bhojanaad Moundit naal chhakey, Tankhaiyaa" or One who eats food with a Mona/non-Sikh, is guilty of a breach of conduct (Piara Singh Padam’s Rehitnamay pg. 72); also "Patr sarb loh kay, bhougtay asan souaad....loh patr mai chhakai," meaning: using utensils of sarbloh, one eats tasty food...one should eat in sarb loh utensils" (Padam, 75) The Rehitnama Hazooree by Chaupa Singh says "Guru kaa Sikh...apaNy langar rasoee vich Sikh rakhey. Hukaie, Topeeaa, BhaadNee, chor, yaar, jooaybaaz, kurehiteeyaa na rakhai" meaining "A Guru ka Sikh...should keep only a Sikh in his langar and kitchen. Smokers, hat-wearers, shaven people, theieves, gamblers, kurehitees should not be kept" (Padam, 85). In Sau Sakhee, sakhee #8’s rehitnama it says clearly "So Sikh gur ka janeeay, Monay ann na khai" meaning: such is a Sikh of The Guru who does not eat the food of Monay/Non-Sikhs. [End-Note]*** Who is a Bibeki Singh? Bhai Sahib Kahan Singh of Nabha, in his Encyclopedia of Sikh Literature on page 863 defines Bibeki as "...a Sikh who is strict and steadfast in following the principles of Sikh Dharma." The terms Bibek and Vivek are synonymous and have the same meaning i.e. 'sense of discrimination.' In Gurmat, it implies the unquestionable adherence to the command of the Satguru. Satgur Bachan Kamaaveney, Sachaa Eho Vichaar (ang 52) Practice of the True Guru's commands is the only true philosophy. Thus, in Sikhism, a Bibeki is a person who adheres strictly to and regulates his life in accordance with the Guru's commandments. Generally, people do not grasp the true meaning of the terms Amritdhari and nonAmritdhari Sikhs. The phrase non-Amritdhari Sikhs is meaningless. One cannot make a comparison between them. There is only one class of Sikhs and that class is the SIKH (Khalsa). Thus, one is either a Sikh or not a Sikh. Who is a Sikh? The literal meaning of the word Sikh is a 'disciple.' A Sikh is one who is a disciple of the Satguru. To be a disciple of the Satguru, one must completely surrender one's will and wisdom to the Will and Wisdom of the Satguru. Only then, the Satguru admits one is in his fold as a 'Sikh' and blesses him with the holy Naam. This initiation ceremony was previously referred to as the deekhya or charan pahul and has been prevalent right from the time of Sahib Sri Guru Nanak Dcv Ji, as supported by Bhai Gurdas Ji: Gur Deekhya Lai Sikh, Sikh Sadaayaa. (Var3,Pauri 11) One is called a Sikh only after he has been blessed with 'deekhya.' Charan Dhoe Rehraas Kar Charnamrit Gursikhaan Pilaaayaa (Var 1, Pauri 23) (Guru Nanak) followed the system of washing the Guru's Feet and blessing the Gursikhs with the Charanamrit (Charan-Pahul). Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji prescribed specific rules and regulations which must be unconditionally accepted by the candidates before they can be admitted as disciples (Sikhs). The ceremony by which the Panj Pyaras are authorized by the Satguru to admit such persons in the fold of Sikhism is partaking Khande-ki-Pahul or Amrit. Therefore, according to the Commandment of the Satguru, one can become a Sikh of the Guru only by taking Amrit. Such a person is also called an Amritdhari because he has been blessed with the holy Amrit and has, thus, become a Sikh. It is further explicit from the following couplet from Rahitnamaa of Bhai Desa Singh Ji: Pratham Rahit Yeh Jaan, Khande-ki-Pahul Chhakey. Soee Sikh Sujaan, Avar Naa Pahul Jo Lai. The primary Rahit for a Sikh is to take Khande-ki-Pahul. Only he is sagacious Sikh. Now consider this point from another angle. If someone belonging to other faiths like Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Hinduism, etc., wishes conversion into Sikhism, what is he required to do? Does he become a Sikh by merely refraining from cutting his hair and wearing a turban as Sikhs do? Obviously not. (There are a number of such people with long hair, and even wearing turbans, belonging to faiths other than Sikhism). He has necessarily to partake the holy Amrit to become a Sikh. How can, then, one become a Sikh simply because of accident of birth, without being baptized? This point has also been explicitly made clear by the Satguru himself as: So Sikh Sakhaa Bandhap Hai Bhai, Jay Gur Ke Bhaaney Vich Avey Aapney Bhaaney Jo Chaley Bhai, Vichharr Chotaan Khaavey. (pg 601) Only that person is a Sikh and he is my near and dear one, who comes under the total allegiance of the Guru. As against this, one who owes allegiance only to is personal will, always remains in separation and will suffer. Even in the booklet entitled Sikh Rahit Maryada published by the S.G.P.C., a Sikh has been defined as under: "...Dashmesh ji dey Amrit utay nischa rakhadu hai atey kisey hor dharam nu nahin manadaa, oh Sikh hai." "...and has full faith in the Amrit of the Tenth Guru and does not believe in any other faith, is a Sikh." Clearly, therefore, being a non-Amritdhari means that one, has not yet declared his total allegiance and obedience to Sahib Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji I Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji I Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji as his Guru. Nor has he been blessed with the Gurmantra or Naam which is given ONLY at the time of baptism by Guru Sahib himself through the Panj Pyaras. Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji himself put a seal on this point by bowing before the Panj Pyaras for his own baptism. Are these so-called non-Amritdhari "Sikhs" greater than even Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji, that they call themselves full-fledged Sikhs without being baptized? It is thus, abundantly clear that the non-Amritdharls, even though they may claim to be Sikhs, and are also considered Sikhs politically and socially, are not Sikhs in the true sense and in the eyes of the Satguru. In Gurbani, they are referred to as (a) Nigurey; (b) Gumantar heenus; (c) Sakat; (d) Manmukhs or Vemukh, and (e) Vedeen (Faithless), etc. howsoever prominent or outstanding they may be in the social and public life of the community. Gurbani defines such terms as under: a. Nigurey: one who has not become disciple of the Guru. Nigurey Ko Gat Kaaee Naahee. Avgann Muthhey, Chotaan Khahee. (pg 361) For him who is without the Guru, there is no liberation. Deluded by evil propensities, he suffers. Satgur Bajhon Gur Nahi Koee Nigurey Kaa Hal Naao Bura. (ang 435) Without the True Guru (i.e. Guru Nanak), there is not another Guru. And one without the Guru has a cursed name. b. Gurmantar-heenus: One who has not been blessed with the Gurmantra (Naani). Gumantar-Heenus Jo Praani Dhrigant Janam Bharashtneh. Kookreh Sookreh Gardbeh Kaakeh Sarpaneh Tul Khaleh (ang 1356-1357) One who is without the Gurmantra, is the most accursed, and contaminated is his life. He is like a dog, a swine, an ass, a crow a snake, and a fool. c. Saakat: Infidel Saakat Suaan Kaheeyey Baho lobhee, Baho Durmat Mael Bhareejey. (ang1326) The dog like infidel is said to be very avaricious and is full to the brim of evil thoughts. Saakat Besuva Poot Ninaam (ang1239) The infidel is nameless like a prostitute's son. Santan kaa daanaa rookha so sarab nidhaan. Saakat nar chhatee parkaar, tay bikhoo smaaan (ang, 811) The food of the saints/gursikhs is dry but it is equal to all treasures. The 36 types of tasty food of the infidel/saakat are equal to poision. d. Manmukh: One who follows his own will; the egocentric. Manmukh Oodha Kowl Hai, Na Tis Bhagat Na Naao. (ang 511) The egocentric person (i.e. Manmukh) is like a reversed lotus and possesses neither devotion nor God's name. Manmukh Seti Sang Karey, Muh Kalakh Daag Lagaaey (ang 1417) Whosoever associates with a manmukh, blackens and stains his own face. Manmukh Naam Na Jannani, Vinn Naavey Pat Jaaey... Vishta Kay Keerray Pavey Wich Vishta Se Vishta Mahe Samaaye. (ang 28) The manmukhs know not the Naam, and without Naam lose their honor... They are worms of excrement, fall in excrement, and get absorbed in excrement e. Vedeen: The faithless; the irreligious. Choraan, Jaaran, Randiaan, Kuttaneeya Di Baan. Vedinaa Ki Dosti Vedinaa Ka Khaann Sifti Saar Naa Jannani, Sada Vasey Shaitaan. (ang 790) It is the habit of thieves, adulterers, prostitutes, and pimps that they contract friendship with the irreligious or faithless and eat their food; they know not the worth of God's praise and Satan ever abides within them. The above are only a few of the numerous quotations from Gurbani and are self-explanatory and need no further comment. Evidently then, the Sikhs of the Satguru have to avoid the food prepared and served by them whether in the Gurdwaras or in their social gatherings, in the interest of the upliftment of their souls and the enjoyment of the Bliss of Naam Simran. This practice is not confined to the Akhand Kirtani Jatha alone. Even in the Langar premises of Sri Harimandir Sahib (Golden Temple) at Amritsar, a notice painted in bold letters in Punjabi, hangs prominently near the kitchen stating that the "SEWA OF THE PREPARATION OF LANGAR BE DONE BY THE AMRITDHARI SIKHS - MEN AND WOMEN. NON-AMRITDHARIS MAY DO THE SEWA OF CLEANING OF UTENSILS, KITCHEN, HALL, ETC." Thus in trying to follow this practice, the AKJ is simply trying to follow the edict of Gurmat in respect of food and not out of any superiority complex or hatred for others.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Admin · 20 Apr 2006

Only those messages which are on topic and bring up new points will be allowed hereafter. If you wish to take part in the debate, read what has been written and certainly read the article on Bibek above. If you have an argument after reading the article or preceding exchange, then please do contribute.

Re: Bebek - is cheese allowed?

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 20 Apr 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Well said Bhai Sahib '...' Jeeo. As for Bhai Sahib 'Sherbahadar Singh' Jeeo, you haven't tackled or gained anything from my posts but instead been talking rubbish and wasting your time. 'I guess we don't, because obviously, you seem to have all the answers.' Don't praise me, praise Vaheguru Jee; only he has all the answers. he he. You've ignored so many important aspects of the article written by me. This clearly determines that you hate this rehit and don't wish others to follow it because you don't. Don’t ever put a Rehit of Guru Jee's down. Why the hell are you trying to go to Saachkhand where only Gurmukhs abide, don't go there as you'll be stuck in a 'vacuum chamber with oxygen filtration pumps and only amritari's'. If you wish you can go to hell if you prefer - there are defiantly non-amritaree over there. You probably didn't even read the whole of the article, as I've stated that the FOOD has a larger effect from the manmukh than other things he/she has touched. You’re meant to be a Sikh but you couldn't even understand the fact that your father Guru Gobind Singh Jee also practiced this rehit. We're meant to be following in our father's footsteps, just as Guru Jee took amrit so do we, he obeyed the rehits given in the Amrit Sanskaar, so should we. Well isn't this true? His image is a Khalsa, so we ourselves have to become this image as well, and so the only way to do this is by following our father's teachings. How else will our father be happy with us if we don't follow his teachings? One more thing, you missed the other important point, which was that Sarbloh Bebek will be a mandatory belief held in Khalsa Raj. Basically Khalsa shall only have it's raj by following everything our father has followed. Khalsa mera roop hai khaas Khalse mein main karoon nivaas. ‘Actually, I think this Gurbani line, when referring to inner filth, is talking about the 5 vices: Greed, lust, ego, anger and attachment. Someone correct me if I'm wrong.’ Of course the filth is from the interior, where the hell would the filth be on the exterior of the body? The demons are what cause the human to lead a false life, so when the being does lead this life he/she brings filth upon his life and therefore curses everything he touches spiritually. You even missed the other important part where the blood came out from bhagos food whereas milk from lallos food. Why do you suppose this happened then? Even I talk to blacks, whites and asians, the rough ones that you wouldn’t ever want to hang out with, but I just wouldn’t ever eat from a non-amritaree, because in order to get Guru Jee’s approval to get married to Vaheguru Jee you have to please Guru Jee first. This can be achieved by becoming his student in everyway. Then you would be on that high standard where you will one day be allowed to marry your future husband Vaheguru Jee. hor kithai bhagath n hovee bin sathigur kae oupadhaes ||1|| There is no other way to perform devotional worship, except through the Teachings of the True Guru. ||1|| This gurbani line explains that there is no other way of performing devotional worship towards Vaheguru Jees but through guru Jee’s teachings. Guru Jee has taught that both the external and internal of the body have to be purified, if not, then one is surely punishable. So, that person can never reach Saachkhand. If one listens to Guru Jee’s teachings, then one is fully practicing and understanding the essence of life and the truth. There is no other way but to follow everything Guru Jee has taught us, not just one thing should be followed but they all should be followed. We’re meant to be meeting Guru Jee’s standards not ours, we don’t follow the rehits we like to follow but all of them. By only following the ones that satisfy yourself then one is listening to the mind, which is having an enormous amount of ego. Hence we are thinking of ourselves to be higher then guru Jee. Guru Jee didn’t explain why we have to follow every rehit, but just gave it to us to follow, as he wants to see how much we love him and have faith in him. Although today’s society has proven the opposite. We have forgotten Guru Jee’s teachings of love and faith, in him and the rehits. It’s not a question of why we follow these but the fact that we love Guru Jee so we will follow them. Thus, we have to have faith in all the rehits. We should all ask ourselves: do we love our father enough to be his children. What has happened to Khalsa Raj some ask, well this has happened: no one has faith and love in Guru Jee so they keep on attacking his teachings. [gurbani] ijnI iek min nwmu iDAwieAw gurmqI vIcwir ][/gurbani] Those who meditate single-mindedly on the Naam, and contemplate the Teachings of the Guru [gurbani]iqn ky muK sd aujly iqqu scY drbwir ][/gurbani] -their faces are forever radiant in the Court of the True Lord. NEVER EVER PUT DOWN A TEACHING OF YOUR OWN FATHER!!!!! Sat Sri Akaal VAheguruJeeKaakhalsa VahegurujeekeeFateh [%sig%]