Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Mr. Sad Singh · 18 Dec 2003

Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ka fateh First off I am not here to disrespect Bhai Sahib Randir Singh. I have a lot of respect for him I have been doing some readings on him and I want to learn more about him. My question is why do people look at him as if he was our Guru? I mean I've read some of his books and he talks about how we should eat from amritdari's only and my friend and i were discussing this and I said "I think that is wrong" and he flipped out and pushed me and said that I was disrespecting Bhai Sahib....my question is how was i disrespecting him? To me Bhai Sahib was a person with a lot of knowledge but he's not my guruji and i said that to my friend and now he has not talked to me for three weeks. But no disrespect..I mean he isn't guruji... These are just his opinions, beliefs and perspective. If I said anything wrong please forgive me. From the bottom of my heart.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Balpreet Singh · 18 Dec 2003

I don't think anyone is calling Bhai Sahib a Guru. As for bibek, Bhai Sahib along with MANY other gursikhs encouraged it. I don't need to list them as they've been listed before. I think in the spiritual path, we need sangat to help us. Bhai Sahib's books are perfect sangat for the person on the spiritual path and give a lot of inspiration and guidance. No one calls Bhai Sahib a Guru, but he can be a very good friend through his books. And they actually aren't his opinions. I've never seen a book written like Bhai Sahibs with so much reference to BaaNee. Everything he says is backed up.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Gupt Singh · 18 Dec 2003

Bhai Sahib was a Singh who experienced the spiritual world. He experienced the highest spiritual experiences. But of course he wasn't Guru Jee. I've never ever ever ever met a person in the whole world who has accorded Bhai Sahib guru-like status. Respecting Gursikhs and having enough nimratha to believe their beliefs over your beliefs isn't gurudom - Its what Gurmat is about. Who would know better..... a Singh whos experienced Naam Simran and Gurbaanee and kept very strict Rehit? Or someone like myself who keeps very weak rehit and who hasn't experienced Naam and baanee? This doesn't mean we should follow everything blindly, But having the actions and beliefs of Gursikhs as a blueprint to our own beliefs is not wrong at all.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Another Sad Singh · 18 Dec 2003

I too have met lots of Singhs who very often quote Bhai Sahib Ranthir Singh Ji in discussions. These same guys make a mockery of anything said by a Sant or other person. All due respect to Bhai Sahib Ranthir Singh Ji but he was not the only Gursikh around

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Sarbloh Soulja · 18 Dec 2003

WJKKWJKFATEH ALL his books are backed up by bani.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

jagjit singh · 18 Dec 2003

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru jike fateh Pyare jio, many people respect Bhai sahib, but like all Gursikhs he was just a Gursikh, and should not be elevated to anything more. Being a Gursikh is high enough in Kalyug. Bhai sahib created a jatha, who`s sole purpose is living and breathing Shabad Guru. Prathan Gursikhs were akhand kirtanees and akhand paathis. They worked, and used all there free time in sangat and abyass. This was reflected in their high jeevans. Essentially we only pray,and puuj, and honour one entity. That is the Shabad, and that is our only Guru. "Guru Moorat Gur shabad hai". If any Gursikh, no matter how high, or whatever background, has gained anything, it is only through Shabad Guru. People are respected because of their kamai. So doing kamai of shabad is the most important thing. I hope veer ji, you are not too upset, by that Gursikhs reaction. There is nothing wrong with being inquisitive. Many Gursikhs keep Gurmat bibek and sarbloh bibek, some do not. I personally do not, but I have utmost regard for those that do. The most important thing is Naam and kamai. Anything that joins me to Naam is my friend, anything that takes me away from it is my enemy. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singh 0 · 18 Dec 2003

I think this is an essential discussion as the fact is that some people appear to quote more from Bhai Sahibs life and books then Gurbani and factual Sikh history. Bhai Sahib was without a doubt a great Sikh but he was not our Guru so simply speaking we should use facts from Gurbani and Sikhi first. He has offered varies opinions which are in most cases a great benifit to the Panth, but no individual no matter how great or spiritual is greater or has a superior opinion then the collective Khalsa Panth. I have seen some Jatha people who although claim they are against the modern Sant culture are sadly not far off from doing the same thing.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Baljit Singh · 18 Dec 2003

Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee ke Fateh!! I was always in a Chaa of Amrit Chak. I went to Bidar Eng college in Karnataka, India. I never knew anything about Amrit. I always thought that taking Amrit is the only thing one has to do on the path of Sikhi. Hence, i went to Hazoor Sahib and took amrit. We were told to do 5 + 2 banis during the day and that is it. I started reading Gurbani according to Hukam of Panj payaras, but still my inside was not satisfied and i was searching for something else. I met Gursikhs from Bidar college, they used to do kirtan together and in utmost Pyaar. Never heard of such a kirtan in my life (because i used to listen to Rangeela, Harbans singh Jogadri wala, Maskeen, Darshan Singh and many more). One of the Gurusikh gave me Jail-Chittiya to read. I started reading it and could not stop, hence finished it in the morning. I went back to that Gurusikh and asked who are these Singhs - who live according to Gurubani. I was told that these Gurusikhs are from AKJ. I was then taken to a Samagam and that is it. I was told about Nam-Simran (Abyaas) and reading Gurbani in Pyaar. My life changed due to Sangat of Gurusikhs - AKJ. These people don't have a DERA or A SANT. They have utmost respect for Guru jee and live their live accordingly. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee spend his whole life according to Gurubani and is a role model for others. We can learn so many things from his life history and books. He followed Gurubani and we need to follow Gurubani too, but his life is an example for us and we can learn many great things by reading his books. In 1990, Canada was very restricted in terms of Sangat, hence Bhai Sahib jee books gave (still giving) a great sangat to me. We should respect Gurusikhs like Bhai Sahib and try to learn things from their jeevan instead of cross-question. A different way of doing kirtan with utmost love was started by Bhai Sahib. Bhai Sahib style of kirtan is a great "dayeen" (contribution) to the Khalsa panth. Many young people are able to do kirtan now. We were again put into a caste system of Granthi and Ragis, without them our Karaj was difficut to handle. We used to wait for Ragis to have our Karag done, but now everyone can learn kirtan and can do their Karaj. The depth of Gurubani was exposed by Bhai Sahib jee books. He does not say anything in his books according to his Matt. He states a line from Gurbani and then goes and explains what guru jee says. I have never ever seen that he ever had said anything according to his Maat - His Matt is just Guru Sahib jee Matt. I will request to please read Bhai Sahib jee books and find out yourself. AKJ members respect him as a Gurusikh and read his books to get a great sangat. As a note: I also read Bhai Veer Singh jee books. That does not mean that he is my Guru now. These Gurusikhs have written so much "KHAZANA" for us and we can learn from their experiences.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Kulbir Singh · 18 Dec 2003

Very well said Bhai Baljit Singh jeeo! You have beautifully expressed what I wanted to but was not finding words or phrases to do so. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee was a great gursikh. No one in jatha thinks of him as Guru. It is totally absurd to even imagine such a thing. One who has read books of Bhai Sahib knows very well, how much he opposed worshipping a living person as Guru. We should not get misled by such false propaganda. Bhai Sahib was a truly great Gursikh. He realized Vaheguru and got Vaheguru jee’s clear darshan (vision). For this reason we cannot take anything he write lightly. He was a fully enlightened gursikh and for that reason, I personally don’t see anything wrong in quoting him, while making a point. Don’t we quote Bhai Gurdas jee, Bhai Nandlal jee, rehitnamas of singhs like Bhai Daiya Singh jee, Bhai Chaupa Singh jee etc. ? Then what is wrong in quoting Bhai Sahib’s writings? The clarity of Gurmat that Bhai Sahib jee had is next to no one. All you have to do is read his books. His books are full of Gurmat. He was a humble Sikh of Guru Sahib and we should consider him nothing but that. We ourselves too are Sikhs of Guru Sahib but are not as elevated spiritually as he or other great gursikhs were. For this reason, such gursikhs as Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, deserve utmost respect from us. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Still Sad · 18 Dec 2003

The issue here is not whether Bhai Sahib Ji should be quoted or not - by all means go ahead and quote him. He was a great Gursikh. But most of the AKJ Singhs I meet scoff at quotations made by other Gursikhs (like Sant Attar Singh Ji etc) Is that applying double standards?

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Kulbir Singh · 18 Dec 2003

Dear Mr. or Mrs Sad, ------ But most of the AKJ Singhs I meet scoff at quotations made by other Gursikhs (like Sant Attar Singh Ji etc) ------ This is totally false. Singhs in AKJ have utmost respect for Sant Attar Singh jee. Very shortly, we will be posting life story of Sant jee on this site and that too would prove that the jatha singhs love Sant Attar Singh jee and other gursikhs like him. Bhai Sahib and Sant jee were very close friends. Bhai Sahib jee's cousin was an active member of Sant jee's jatha. Please don't fabricate facts here. Jatha Singhs have no problems with gursikhs like Sant jee. Please prove me wrong, if you can. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Baljit Singh · 18 Dec 2003

Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee ke Fateh!! "Still Sad", I have posted many stories from books of Bhai Veer Singh jee @ www.akj.org. I read books from Gursikhs like Bhai Veer Singh, Bhai Ragbir Singh Beer, Short inspiring stories from Sikh missionary college, Dr. Gurbax Singh and on top of that Bhai Randhir Singh jee and many more. I have also read books on life history of Akali Kaur Singh jee. Bhai Randhir Singh was complete on Kathani/karni aspect of Gursikhi, and his books are so full of intoxication of Gurusikhi that if you read it once, you start loving Guru jee more. What Bhai Sahib jee has written has changed many many lives? Let me tell you an incident which i faced 15 yrs back in Gurdwara Bangla Sahib jee and this incident will show you that how much Gursikhi doses are present in Bhai Sahib jee books. We (my dear Gurusikh friend in India) were going towards Bidar Eng. College (Karnataka) and were spending our night at Bangla Sahib jee parkarma. Whole night Dhun of Waheguru kept on pouring in our ears. During Amritvella we saw a red face Gurusikh deep into Simran. When he was finished we just sat beside him and asked him about the kirpa (Bakshish) he was going through. He told us that someone has given him Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jail Chitiyaa book to read and he told us that he has read it in just one sitting and after reading he can't eat or sleep. His simran does not stop and he is in search of those Gursikhs. He wanted to meet those Gursikhs, because he was desperate to meet those Guru Pyaras, hence we told him to attend one of the Samagams and hence we gave him the pointers to follow. That is what Bhai Sahib jee has written? All his books are full of Gursikhi and his life was just reflection of that. We need to go through his books to know his Gursikhi-jeevan instead of just cross-question. There is nothing wrong in giving references of Chardi-Kala Gursikhs. It is quite hard to find them now and we can have their sangat by reading their books.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

p · 19 Dec 2003

Who says Bhai Sahib Created the Jatha.......................R u sure?

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Sarbloh Soulja · 19 Dec 2003

WWJKKWJKFATEH Yes, Bhai Sahib did create the jatha, thats why before it was called Bhai Randhir Singh da Jatha?

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Singh 0 · 19 Dec 2003

I think the Sant Attar Singh was an example. The fact is that no other individual is respected and quoted more by our Jatha then Bhai Randhir Singh, any one who disagrees is not telling the truth. His opinions are very important but so are other people who are never mentioned, and even more important the opinions of the collective Khalsa Panth. Individual Gursikhs are Gursikhs and their opinions are important but not the Basis of Sikhi which comes direct from the Guru.

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Hello Ji · 20 Dec 2003

AGREE WITH SINGH 0

Re: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

p · 21 Dec 2003

it was called something else before.......it was never ever called bhai randhir singh da jatha.....