Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

GUNS VS. SWORDS

GUNS VS. SWORDS

Me · 20 Apr 2006

I was wondering...Singhs/Singhnis had rifles, guns, cannons etc. back like over 300 years ago, and we always hear about how they fought with swords etc, as well as rifles. My question: why did the Singhs/Singhnis, or even the enemy, not focus all their atttention towards the use of firearms, because of its advantage with range. Also, i heard alot Katha about wars going on, how Singhs/Singhnis fought so bravely against so many soldiers at once, but...the question is: were the enemies using guns on them too? Because we all know that in a war today, on a battle field, if one person had a sword and the other had a gun, there is a clear advantage with the gun. So, can someone please explain why the swords etc. were being used even though firearms were available. (could it be that guns were still in the develpoment stage, and were not that effective or quick to load?) (please forgive me for any mistakes i have made)

Re: GUNS VS. SWORDS

musket · 20 Apr 2006

back then the guns would probably take longer to load then they go nowadays so i think that a sword is better

Re: GUNS VS. SWORDS

PTE SINGH · 21 Apr 2006

The musket of the 17th and 18th century was not a very accurate weapon and nor did it have much range. Not until the middle and late 1800's with the improvement of the rifle was it a decisive weapon. Up until then it was widely used as a motivating factor for troops and a demoralising factor for the enemy as they were seen as modern and required less hand to hand combat. Untill the mass production of the industrial revolution cannon and rifles were expensive and difficult to produce. Even during the Napoleonic wars when rifles started to replace muskets the ratio of bullets fired to actual hits ranged in the thousands and the bow and arrow was still far more acurate. It was also difficult to fire any more than 2-3 shots in a minute which would be impossible once the enemy was upon them and bayonets were used. All in all it was not the best weapon at the time. The snobery that was still a large part of warfare in that era also saw the sword as a gentlemans choice and the only fair way to fight. The move from the sword and bow to the bayonet and rifle was the move from warriors to soldiers. [%sig%]

Re: GUNS VS. SWORDS

sanjo · 21 Apr 2006

yh the guns wouldnt be very practical, u only have to watch documenteries or films of early wars in britain etc n you can see that the soldiers rush to reload their rifles with gun powder and bullets. if someone is charging towards you it isnt very effective, its really a one shot defice. if u compare this to bow and arrows, the bow n arrow was much more effective and guru ji did use bows n arrows effectively. however, i think primative rifles n cannons are mentioned in guru gobind singhs writing shastar naam mala in sri dasam granth. swords are for close combat, and nothing can really beat a sword or small kirpan in close combat (if you knw how to use it properly). the phillipines has a notorious knife culture, nearly everyone carries a knife and alot know how to use them properly, they actually prefer knives to guns, i have seen demos of people with knives completely out witting and gaining control over people with guns, its amazing what you can do if you only know how to use a weopon properly. obviously in todays warfare guns are practical and essential which is why alot of nihangs carry licensed rifles, however the importance of the knife has not been overlooked, as alot of marines must carry knives and be taught how to use them effectively. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: GUNS VS. SWORDS

BirRass Singh · 21 Apr 2006

Muskets would have been used at long distance, shoot at the enemy and then disperse them. As they regathered then they were shot at again from another angle. Loading times were overcome by groups of Singhs who would shoot, reload and as they were reloading another group would step up to fire, as they reloaded another group would fire etc.