Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Kes Vs. Keski

Kes Vs. Keski

Gurlaal Singh · 21 Apr 2006

WJKK WJKF i am an Amritdhari Singh, when i took amrit my guru (panj pyare) told me that the fundamentals lie upon the 5 kakaar; Kara, Kirpan, kanga, kashera and Kes. Recently i had a discussion with a Singh who actually told me that Kes is not a kakaar and that instead it is a Keski? Please can someone help me with this; what is the siginificance and meaning of keski? Is it ok if i cut my hair aslong as i wear a keski? as keski is the kakaar (according to this 1 singh) and not kes? Or is this Singh just a one-off i met with this view? Gurfateh GS

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

anon · 21 Apr 2006

this singh is probably a member of the akj, it is absolutly not ok if u cut ur hair singh ji, as far as my knowledge goes the akhand kirtani jatha, look at the kakkars as something guru ji gave you to wear. therefore according to historical accounts it is claimed guru ji gave his khalsa the keski as the 5th kakkar. from a logical point of view, men and women are equal, and if men are required to wear keski then women should be no different, we must respect our kesh at all times. i think this is why guru ji may have given us the keski as kakkar. this does not mean kesh is not important. kesh is more important than anything, its just that it is believed that the keski was given to the panj pyareh as kesh is something that everyone has from birth. the kakkars are given to u by guru ji. but do not think kesh is not needed, i just dont think that singh explained it properly to you. but thats my knowledge of akj maryada, i am pretty sure there is a detailed account of this on the literature part of this site. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

... · 21 Apr 2006

Gurlaal Singh, those that believe keski is the kakaar still can't cut their hair because cutting hair is a bujjer kurehit. That in fact is one of the reasons kes can't be a kakaar, because they are higher than kakaars. If a kakaar falls off, or you purposely take it off, it doesn't mean you have committed a bujjer kurehit and need to take amrit again. If you cut your kes on purpose, you need to take amrit again. So why would this kakaar be higher than the rest? >>>>>>>>>>>> Keski as Kakkar Bh. Manmohan Singh Jee LA Keski, Kesgi, chhoti dastaar (or mini turban) is the first important striking symbol which makes the members of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha conspicuous - especially the women. And, naturally, it is the first object of criticism. One very distinguished scholar, S. Kapur Singh states: "Bhai Randhir Singh and his admirers claim and assert that five K's obligatory for an Amritdhari Sikh, a Singh, include a Keski, i.e., a short turban for men and women, as a must and one of the other K's, Kangha (comb) is not one of the five Do's." According to him "...It is wholly arbitrary and schismatic...and thus an act of sabotage against the solidarity and monolithicism of the Khalsa."20 Another critic asserts the rahit of Keski to be an "absolutely mundane" teaching of the Jatha having "no precedents" and thus being the "teaching of an individual." Before taking up the question of whether 'Keski' is a symbol or not, it may be pointed out that in their eagerness to criticize Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh, even the well versed Sikh scholars, like S. Kapur Singh, have not cared to verifify the facts before offering their criticism. Keski is not at all considered to replace Kangha as a symbol as asserted by him. It does, however, replace Keshas as a symbol because Keshas is the first fundamental requirement for a Sikh. Shaving or trimming of hair is the first of the four Cardinal Sins -Kurahits (Big Don'ts) - the commitment of any one of which makes one an apostate and results in one's automatic excommunication from the fold of the Khalsa Brotherhood. Moreover Keshas form part of the human body and are not obtained and worn like other Kakaars. Sikh history is full of instances where the devout Sikhs were hacked joint by joint, boiled and even sawed alive, had their scalps cut' their limbs broken on the wheel, and faced bravely many other unbearable and severest of tortures, and yet remained firm in their faith to their last hair and breath. Right from Sahib Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji, the Sikhs have been commanded to abstain from shaving or trimming of hair. According to Bhai Sahib Mani Singh's Gyan Ratnavali and other Janam Sakhies, Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji, while initiating Bhai Mardana into the newly founded Sikh faith, laid down the following three-fold Code of Conduct for him: "Firstly, you are not to cut your hair. Secondly, you are to get up early in the morning and do practice of the Sat Naam; and, Thirdly, you are to serve hospitably the visiting devotees of God."21 In another instance Sahib Sri Guru Hari Rai Ji, while blessing Bhai Nandlal, grandfather of Bhai Hakikat Rai with the Holy Naam, is reported to have codified as follows: "Firstly, you are not to cut your hair; Secondly, you are not to consume tobacco; and Thirdly, you are not to wear a cap." It is thus crystal clear that the injunction regarding abstaining from cutting Keshas was initiated by Sahib Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji himself and continued to be adhered to by all his successor Gurus. Hence the importance of keeping Keshas intact is the basic and fundamental requirement for becoming a Sikh. In fact, the Keshas are considered so sacred that for their cleanliness, care, and protection, two additional Kakaars, i.e. Kangha and Keski, have been prescribed in the Sikh Code of Conduct. It is well known that the outward appearance of the Sikhs is absolutely unique and different from those of other faiths. This applies to all Sikhs irrespective of sex. The wearing of the Sikh symbols has been obligatory for both the sexes. In addition, Sikh women are also conspicuous because of the absence of any piercing ornaments for nose and ears, such as those customarily worn by women of other religions. After their initiation into the Khalsa fold by partaking Khande-ki-Pahul (Amrit), the Sikh women have always tied their Keshas in the form of topknot and covered the same with Dastaar (i.e. Keski) just as men do; the only difference being that they wear chunnies or dupattas over their small turbans. Right up to the reign of Maharaja Ranjit Singh, Sikh women had been steadfast in following the edicts of the Satguru in respect to their spiritual inner life as well as dress, including Keski. That is what J. D. Cunningham himself saw and wrote in the middle of the Nineteenth Century when he wrote his book, History of the Slkhs. Even after the Punjab came under the British rule, this symbol of Keski was conspicuously seen in case of Sikh women as well as men right up to the Gurdwara movement and the establishment of the Shromani Gurudwara Parbandhak Committee in 1926. Until then, no one - man as well as woman was allowed to be baptized (by taking Amrit) at Sri Akal Takht Sahib without Keski. It was only afterwards that laxity was introduced in this respect and the wearing of Keski was made optional. With the introduction of this laxity, the other anti-Sikh practice of wearing piercing ornaments in the nose and ears also became prevalent in Sikh women. This is a brief summarized account of the historical background in this regard. In the following pages, an effort has been made to elaborate a bit on the above points by presenting certain facts: i. Rahit Naama of Bhai Chaupa Singh Ji contains the following couplet regarding 'rahits': Kachh, Kada, Kirpan, Kangha, Keski. Eh Panj Kakaari Rahit Dhaarey Sikh Soyee. To be a Sikh, one must observe five rahits of wearing five Sikh symbols beginning with 'K': Kachh, Kada, Kirpan, Kangha, and Keski. (Those Sikhs not believing in keski have wrongfully broken the word Keski in this couplet into two words, Kes and Ki, indicating it to mean "the rahit of keshas.") ii. The renowned scholar of the Panth, Bhai Sahib Kahan Singh Ji of Nabha, compiled the Encyclopedia of Sikh Literature and Terminology (Gur Shabad Ratnagar MAHAN KOSH) in 1926. The term 'Keski' has been explained therein on page 254, Col. 3 of its Second Edition published by the Punjab Government in 1960, as: Keski: Noun - small turban worn to protect hair. iii. Well known 19th Century English Historian, J. D. Cunningham (1812-1851) who was an eye witness to the First Anglo-Sikh War, in his History of the Sikhs - 1848 refers to Sikh women of that time as follows: "The Sikh women are distinguished from Hindus of their sex by some variety of dress, chiefly by a higher topknot of hair."22 Higher topknot of hair on Sikh women's heads automatically implies their coverage by some sort of turban, as Cunningham has connected it with "some variety of dress." iv. According to the Sikh history, Sahib Sri Guru Angad Dev Ji, impressed and pleased by the untiring and devoted labor of love and selfless service of Baba (later Guru) Amardas Ji' bestowed upon him Siropas in the form of Dastaars a number of times. Even now this tradition of bestowing Dastaar as a Siropa continues at Sri Akal Takht Sahib and other Takhts and Gurdwaras. v. Sahib Sri Guru Arjan Dev Ji's hymn on page 1084 clearly states: Naapaak Paak Kar Hadoor Hadeesa Sabat Surat Dastaar Sira. Make unpure (mind) pure. It is the true adherence to the Muslim Law (Hadees). (One can obtain this objective) by keeping one's body unviolated and by always wearing a turban on head. The above instruction to keep the body in its original complete form and to wear turban is meant for all, irrespective of sex. vi. The tradition of "double dastaar" prevalent amongst Khalsa men was also the result of the practice of keeping Keski under the big turban so that they may never remain bareheaded. Keeping this very tradition in view, the British rulers of India prescribed wearing of double dastaar, i.e., one small (also referred to as an under turban) and the other outer big one, as part of the official uniform for Sikh members of the armed forces. They were, and perhaps are even now, officially provided with two turbans, one big and one small, as part of their uniforms. vii. At the end of the nineteenth century and the beginning of the present one, as a result of the Sikh renaissance movement, a number of Khalsa schools for girls were established in Punjab. Small dastaar (Keski) was prescribed as an obligatory head dress for students as well as teachers in such schools at Jaspalon, Ferozepur and Sidhwan in Punjab. viii. . In a number of Rahitnaamas, the importance of keeping hair always covered with Dastaar has been emphasized very clearly. A few quotations are given below: "Each candidate for Baptism be made to wear kachhehra, tie hair in a topknot and cover the same with dastaar; wear Sri Sahib (i.e. Kirpan) in Gaatra (shoulder belt). Then he/she should stand with folded hands." (Rahitnama Bhai Daya Singh Ji) "...Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa should keep his hair unshorn, have flowing beard and have simple dastaar which saves him from impiety. Then the Sikhs asked what would happen to those Amrltdharis who start cutting their hair or do not keep their hair covered. The Guru replied that they would be stupid and will lose their sensibility It is a blemish to remain bareheaded...Always keep two turbans. When the bigger turban is removed, the smaller be kept. The smaller turban should not be removed." (Bijai Mukat Dharam Shastra - Sakhi-8) "(A Sikh) who eats food with turban removed from the head (i.e., bareheaded) is destined for 'Kumbhi' hell." (Rahit Rama Bhai Prahlad Singh Ji) "One who combs hair twice a day, ties turban fold by fold and cleans teeth everyday will not come to grief." (Tankhah Naama Bhai Nandlal Ji) "Whosoever roams about bareheaded, takes food bareheaded and distributes the 'prasad' bareheaded is considered punishable." (Uttar-prashan Bhai Nandlal Ji) "Women should tie their hair in topknot and should not keep them loose." (Rahitnama Bhai Daya Singh Ji) "Keshas be washed. Turban or dastaar should not be placed on floor but should always be kept with due respect. Food should not be eaten bareheaded." (Bijai Mukt Dharam Shastra, Sakhi 70) It is thus, absolutely clear from the above quotations that remaining bareheaded at any time (except when washing, drying, and combing) and keeping hair loose and unknotted are basically against the Sikh Code of Conduct, which is applicable to all, men and women alike. For obvious reasons, therefore, the use of small dastaar or keski is indispensable. There is no other way to keep the head covered all the time. Sikhs - men as well as women - who wear only big turbans and dupattas, mostly remain bareheaded, at least in the privacy of their own homes, while taking food, etc., and thus are, perhaps unconsciously, infringing the Sikh Code of Conduct in this respect. A FEW HISTORICAL AND OTHER FACTS IN THIS RESPECT: 1.Well-known Sikh historian Bhai Sahib Bhai Santokh Singh has given a somewhat detailed description concerning Mai Bhag Kaur (commonly known as Mai Bhago) of Forty Muktas fame in his well known historical work GUR PARTAP SURYA. He mentions that Mai Bhag Kaur had reached the highest stage of enlightenment and had almost lost her body consciousness...so much so that when her clothes became worn to shreds, she did not care to replace them. Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji called her in His Holy presence and instructed her to always stick to the Gursikh dress as prescribed in the Code of Conduct. In particular, she was ordered to wear Kachhehra and chhoti dastaar. In fact, according to some chroniclers, the dastaar was tied on her head by the Satguru himself. If this dastaar was not a Rahit, where was the need to include this item in the instructions given to a lady who had reached almost the Brahmgyan stage? It apparently shows that the Satguru gave as much importance to Dastaar as to other Rahits like Kachhehra. 2. In the Museum of Maharaja Ranjit Singh's fort at Lahore and Victoria Museum at Calcutta, the pictures of Sikh women of old time can be seen even now, depicting them with small dastaars or keskis. 3. Bhai Sahib Vir Singh, in his well known poetical work, RANA SURAT SINGH, depicts Rani Raj Kaur as a Saint Soldier or Rajyogi of the highest order. Her very impressive picture given in the book depicts her with a well-tied Keski, on which is also affixed a khanda-chakkar, the emblem of Sikhism. 4. The Sikh women belonging to the Jatha of Bhai Sahib (Sant) Teja Singh Ji of Mastuana, have been seen doing Kirtan in congregations wearing dastaars. He was instrumental in establishing Akal Academy - a Higher Secondary School at Baru in Himachal Pradesh wherin all students - boys as well as girls - are required to wear turbans as a prescribed school uniform. 5. The Central Majha Diwan and Panch Khalsa Diwan, Bhasaur - the two organizations which played a remarkable role in the Sikh renaissance movement in the first decade of the twentieth century laid special stress on the wearing of Keski by women. 6. The author had the privilege of meeting the late Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji Khalsa of the Bhindranwala Jatha along with his whole family, including his wife, two sons and their wives. They were all wearing Keskis just as the members of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha do. 7. It is a historical fact that there was a time when a price was put on the head of a male Sikh. Greedy and unprincipled people, both Hindus and Muslims, availed of this opportunity to make money. When they could no longer find male Sikhs in the villages and towns, they started beheading Khalsa women and presenting their heads as the heads of young unbearded teenager Sikh lads. As such, many Sikh women, out of fear of persecution, stopped wearing Keski and converted topknot of hair into fashionable styles like women of other faiths. This practice, which originated in a helpless state of affairs, became a fashion in due course of time. By the way, it was perhaps under these very abnormal circumstances that Sikh women also started wearing ear and nose ornaments to avoid the disclosure of their Sikh identity. 8. S. Shamsher Singh Ashok who has been an active member of the Singh Sabha movement and an erstwhile Research Scholar of the S.G.P.C., while discussing the prevalence of the use of 'keski', states: "...and, consequently in the Amrit-Parchaar at the Akal Takht Sahib, this was a precondition even for ladies before they could be baptized there. Any woman who was not prepared to wear Keski was not baptized. This practice continued even after the end of the Gurdwara movement. Relaxation was made only when Giani Gurmukh Singh Musafir became the Jathedar of the Akal Takht."23 9. A recent discovery from old literature puts a final seal on the Keski having been prescribed as a Rahit by the Tenth Guru himself. While going through the old Vahis of the Bhatts, lying with their successors in Karnal District in Haryana State, Prof. Piara Singh Padam of Punjabi University Patiala came across a paragraph explaining the first baptism of the double-edged sword bestowed by Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji on the First Five Beloved Ones on the Baisakhi of 1699 A.D. and the Code of Conduct imparted to them on that auspicious occasion. Based upon the language and style, this manuscript has been assessed to have been written in about the end of the eighteenth century. As this finding is of special significance in this respect, the English translation of the whole paragraph is reproduced below: "Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji Tenth Guru, son of Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji, in the year Seventeen Hundred Fifty Two, on Tuesday - the Vaisakhi day - gave Khande-Ki-Pahul to Five Sikhs and surnamed them as Singhs. First Daya Ram Sopti, Khatri resident of Lahore stood up. Then Mohkam Chand Calico Printer of Dawarka; Sahib Chand Barber of Zafrabad city; Dharam Chand Jawanda Jat of Hastnapur; Himmat Chand Water Carrier of Jagannath stood up one after the other. All were dressed in blue and he himself also dressed the same way. Huqqah, Halaal, Hajaamat, Haraam, Tikka, Janeyu, Dhoti, were prohibited. Socialization with the descendants of Prithi chand (Meenay), followers of Dhirmal and Ram Rai, clean shaven people and Masands was prohibited. All were given Kangha, Karad, KESGI, Kada and Kachhehra. All were made Keshadhari. Everyone's place of birth was told to be Patna, of residence as Anandpur. Rest, Guru's deeds are known only to the Satguru. Say Guru! Guru! Guru! Guru will help everywhere."24 This discovery is a landmark in this respect: Kesgi or Keski has not only been clearly mentioned as one of the five K's, but also the specific and seperate mention of making all Sikhs Keshadharies, makes it clear beyond any shadow of a doubt that Keshas are not included in the Five Symbols (i.e., Five K's): in other words, keeping them intact is a separate and specific injunction for all Sikhs. (By the way, regarding eating meat, both Halaal and Haraam- the Muslim description of any meat other than Halaal - were also forbidden. It means that eating meat was totally prohibited.) It is thus abundantly dear that Keski has been in vogue right from the birth of the Khalsa Nation and is not the innovation of Bhal Sahib Randhir Singh or anybody else. A FEW POINTS OF RATIONALE WHY KESKI AND NOT KESHAS IS ONE OF THE FIVE SIKH SYMBOLS. Now let us consider why Keski and not Keshas is one of the Sikh symbols. By considering Keski as a symbol, the importance of Keshas IS NOT UNDERMINED IN ANY WAY. In fact, the Keshas are the basic and fundamental edifice of Sikhism without which no one can become a Sikh. The following points are put forth for a rational and unbiased consideration in this respect: 1.Keshas are the natural blessing of the Creator. They grow from within the body and develop gradually with age as other parts of the body. As against it, all other symbols or kakaars are external and are put on the body from outside. Even a very devout Sikh may, at times, be forced to remain without any one of the four symbols under circumstances beyond his control. This cannot happen with Keshas, which do not fall in line with the other four symbols and are in a class by themselves. 2. Kangha, which is one of the symbols, is kept for the upkeep of the Keshas (which is also generally considered a symbol). No other symbol is meant for the protection of any other symbol, these being for the protection of the body or some part of it. Evidently, therefore, Keshas cannot be considered as an outer symbol but a part of the body for the protection of which Kangha and Keski are required to be kept as symbols. The RAHITS, including the wearing of the external Five Symbols (Keski, Kachhehra, Kangha, Kada and Kirpan) fall in the category of DO's, while Kurahits (Cardinal Sins or Taboos), including cutting of the hair, are placed in the category of DON'TS. The vested interests try to intermingle them. In this way, they unconsciously belittle the value of Keshas. They should realize that the value of all outer symbols is alike. 4. Then there is an evident anomaly in the commonly accepted Code of Conduct with regard to Keshas. These are included in the category of four cardinal sins which are so basically important that commitment of any one of these by a Sikh makes him an apostate. These are, then, also included in the category of Rahits, the infringement of which makes a Sikh merely a Tankhaeeya or punishable. Evidently there is definite incongruity in it which defies logical or rational explanation. The only logical explanation, therefore, is that the Keshas are not included in Rahits but are one of the four major Kurahits (Taboos or Cardinal Sins): A Sikh must not cut hair. 5. The wearing of Keski enables Sikh women to show their distinctiveness of being Sikh or Khalsa like men. The importance of this Khalsa distinctiveness has been clearly emphasized by the Tenth Guru for the Khalsa as a community, both men and women, and not for men only. 6. At the time of the baptismal ceremony, the same Amrit (Khande-Ki-Pahul) is administered to all without any distinction, including that of sex. The title of Khalsa is bestowed on all of them. The same way of life and Code of Conduct is enjoined upon all of them. All of them are forbidden to roam about, take food, etc. bareheaded. How, then, have women become exempt from any of these injunctions? Keski is the only answer to this contradiction. In view of all the aforesaid, it is clear that Keski or small turban has been traditionally worn by Sikhs, or Khalsa men and women, right from the birth of the Khalsa Nation. This Rahit has been enunciated and strongly emphasized by the Satguru himself. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh, the Akhand Kirtani Jatha, and a few other individuals and organizations are preserving this dignified Khalsa Rahit with Guru's grace. Having become aware of these facts, the Sikh intellegentia has also started showing a remarkable response in this regard. If the Khalsa is to live in accordance with the Rules of true Gurmat , both Khalsa men and women have to accept it. Keski is the crown bestowed by the Satguru for the head of the Khalsa, whether man or woman, who stands bestowed with the special form of the Satguru himself. By refraining from the use of Keski, a Sikh becomes a follower of his own ego instead of the Will of the Satguru. Wearing of Keski by Sikh women is decried mainly because modern day Sikhs want their women to fall in line with other women with respect to the so called modern way of life, including the modern fashions of dress. Sikhs - both men and women - will continue to be guilty of showing disrespect to the sacred hair by keeping them uncovered. In fact, it is the Keski's nonacceptance (and not its acceptance) that is very unconsciously eviscerating the Rahit Namas of their "tremendous and literally unlimited potency that operates on the collective subconscious level" of the Sikhs in general. One fails to understand how the use of Keski "...destroys the purity of the Khalsa Rahit and sabotages the unity of the Khalsa", as alleged by some. In fact, the shoe is on the other foot. If Keski is accepted by all Khalsa men and women, it will help in maintaining the purity and ensuring the unity of the Khalsa, as even women of the Khalsa faith, like the Khalsa men, will be distinguishable.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

R singh · 21 Apr 2006

this is why the argument of kes is a kakar is flawed when they say oh that means you can cut your hair if keski is kakar. BUT YOU CANT! because not cutting hair is already listed in the bujjar kurehit!

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

SINGH?! · 22 Apr 2006

so does this mean that all other amritdharis who believe kesh is a kakaar are wrong in what they believe isnt it tru that most of the panth believe kesh is kakaar and not keski.......therefore is this majority wrong in their beliefs?????

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

Gurlaal Singh · 22 Apr 2006

Thanks for your many replies.... i am beginning to get the impression that the AKJ jatha is like a sect in sikhism? am i correct? Are they branching off and will they soon be put in the same boat as naamdharis, radha soamis and nirankaris? ...who knows? Why do AKJ jatha read less bani? eg. raag maala and short reharaas sahib ji? How can you not read the full Chupai sahib? its like ending mool manter at "jap"......is it ok if we do this? I understand the kes thing know and will not cut my hair but i belev kes is still the kakaar as my panj pyare told me this. GS

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 22 Apr 2006

VaheguruJEeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Yes Bhai sahib 'SINGH?!' Jeeo, thats exactly what it means. The kakaar Keski is the true kakkar and one that had been forgotten or erased by goraa. Kesh is apart of the body. Guru Jee created the kakaars not to be apart of the body, but kakaars that can later form part of the body once one japs an immense amount of Naam. Keeping Kesh is common sense, not a kakaar, because it's apart of the body already. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJEeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

... · 22 Apr 2006

Gurlaal Singh, AKJ is not a sect, it is a Jatha. I think you've got a lot of learning to do and be careful when making totally ignorant comments. The famous Bhai Fauja Singh who stood against the Nirankaris was from the AKJ. And you want to put the Jatha in the same boat as them?? According to Akal Takhat Sahib, ragmala is optional and if you ever happen to listen to the Rehras Sahib from Darbar Sahib (it's on live broadcast at www.sgpc.net so no big effort required) you'll be very surprised to hear tha the Rehraas Sahib read is the same as the one you are calling "less". And mool mantar ends at Gurparsaad. Jap is the name of the bani. Finally you think your punj pyaare "gave you" kes as the kakaar. Did they really? I've heard of amrit sinchaars being conducted where the abhilakhis are given kirpans, karas, kacherras and kanghas and keskis as well. But I've never heard of Punj Pyaaray giving anyone kes. God gives you those and that's why they are above all the other kakaars and are the mohar of Sikhi. I think you need to do some more research.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

SINGH?! · 22 Apr 2006

"Bhupinder Singh Daas" u said that the majority who believe in kesh are therefore wrong.... so does this mean that in the eyes of the AKJ....... jathe like Damdami Taksal (which was formed by Guru Gobind Singh Ji) and other amrit sanchars organised by other jathe/sant/mahapursh are FALSE???? confused!!

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

... · 22 Apr 2006

Singh, I don't want to start this debate, but Jatha Bhindran is a Jatha started by Gyani Sunder Singh. There is no unbroken lineage to Baba Deep Singh, although people may try to create it now. I wouldn't say those amrit sinchars are necessarily "false" but what is wrong is wrong. I think all amrit sinchaars should make keski a mandatory rehit whether they want to call it a kakaar or not.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 22 Apr 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Bhai Sahib '... ' Jeeo, well said and spot on piareo Jeeo. What you said was wicked! Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

SINGH?! · 22 Apr 2006

"...." u said...the amrit sanchars are not necessarily false but whats wrong is wrong......whats that supposed to mean??? if you think part of the amrit sanchar is not correct would you class it as false....i.e. if panj pyare said it was ok to drink alcohol.....would it still be "not necessarily false, but what wrong is wrong" or would it be false???!?? straight up answers wanted..... if a singh classed kesh as a kakaar and not keski would the AKJ accept him as a fellow brother of the khalsa or would his amrit be "false" ????!? this "not necessarily false, but whats wrong is wrong" needs to be clarified

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

... · 22 Apr 2006

I personally feel Taksalis are amritdhari. If you feel that being mistaken on kes/keski being the kakaar is equivalent to saying alcohol is OK, then you must also feel those that believe in Keski aren't amritdharis. I personally don't have issues like this.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

SINGH?! · 22 Apr 2006

i personally believe that kesh is kakaar and not keski but also feel that when taking amrit the singh/singhni is not at fault if the panj pyare (guru ji) say keski is kakaar....at the end of they day they are only following hukam of guru ji at the time therefore i still see them as brothers and sisters of the khalsa panth but what i want to clarify is does the AKJ as a jatha feel the same way or does the jatha feel that those who do not accept keski have not taken amrit properly???? i am asking this as i have a friend who was told by members of the AKJ that his amrit (taken from an amrit sanchar organised from a non AKJ which believed kesh as kakaar) was "Void" and he needed to take it again from AKJ i just want to clarify whether this is the thinking of the AKJ as a whole or just some individuals honesty please......not anything deviating from the truth just to protect the jatha!

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

boloh waheguroo! · 22 Apr 2006

hey i wanted to kno... u kno back in the days, isnt it true that just those women hu were in the battlefield wore a dastar, while the guruas wives and all the other women in the khalsa panth just wore a chooni.. and doesnt it say in the rehat that u should cover ur head when praying and preparing food... soooooooooooooooooooooooo wudnt that mean its not a kakkar, the kakkar wud be to grow it and not cut it???? as the covering head is not compulsory at all times, however ppl just choose to perhaps cover it 24/7 by dastar or chooni,, maybe in the sense of meaning they r lower than guru ji... so its not a kakkar! n isnt akj a big follow of bhai randeer singh ji.. so like akj is all MANMADE... he jus makes sum comments and u all go and follow it?!?!?! wot i dnt get is,,. u akj run around judging people about things like women not wearin dastar,.. wen u do ur akj kirtan in ur own form, when gurua actualli said ur suposd 2 do it in raag!!! p.s as for the person hu made this thread.. Gurlaal Singh .,, lisn up son, if u cum on this board and ask is keski a kakkar, ur just askin for an akj opinion, ask around, use a broader source of opinion, do ur research and see woteva u feel is right and believe,, dont just take a jathas word for it and thats that! fateh!

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

Gurlaal Singh · 22 Apr 2006

Yes please help here.... i have heard many instances like this before where singhs and singhnis have been told that there amrit is pangh (void) as they were told that kes is a kakaar, and in turn they have been 'brainwashed' into taking amrit again from AKJ jatha....is this not wrong and immoral? GS

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

... · 22 Apr 2006

boloh vaheguru, how do you know what Sikh women wore? What are you basing your opinions on? As for the Jatha being manmade: there is no so-called "Jatha" rehit that doesn't have it's basis in some puratan material. Keski is a kakaar according to the oldest source of Sikh history, the Bhatt Vehis. NO WHERE is kes called a kakaar in any rehitnama or anywhere else. Gurlaal Singh, just yesterday you said, "Recently i had a discussion with a Singh who actually told me that Kes is not a kakaar and that instead it is a Keski?" and today, you are saying, "i have heard many instances like this before where singhs and singhnis have been told that there amrit is pangh (void) as they were told that kes is a kakaar, and in turn they have been 'brainwashed' into taking amrit again from AKJ jatha....is this not wrong and immoral?" It must have been a very eventful 24 hours if you have now heard "many instances" about the AKJ and keski rehit whereas just yesterday you wanted to know if it was just this ONE person who believed in keski as a kakaar. I think what might be "wrong and immoral" is lying to the sangat.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 22 Apr 2006

VahegurujeeKaaKhalsa VahegurujeeKeeFateh Bhai Sahib 'SINGH?!' Jeeo, Guru Gobind Singh Jee is higher then having a kakaar as Kesh, since kesh is something that should be kept; it’s apart of the body. The ones that think they can keep their hair after taking amrit are completely mistaken, as one is born with this and so it should be kept from the time of birth to now. Who told us that hair is allowed to be cut? Whoever does think kesh is a kakaar is somewhat confused about how nature, law, and Sikhi work when it comes to the law of truth. The hair only began to be cut in Kalyug not in any other age before this one, as from the very beginning of time; in satyug, the primary truth was lived and so no one had cut hair, ate meat, involved in drugs/alcohol or adultery, so now in kalyug if one commits any of these it is considered a great crime to the law of truth. If to cut hair is a bujjar kurehit and a kakaar at the same time then shouldn’t something such as meat be considered as a kakaar as well, if we’re also an animal, which would mean that any other animal cannot be ate for this reason, then as a kakaar and a bujjar kurehit it is exactly the same as kesh being a kakaar. Try and understand that these are common sense not kakaars. However, Keski is a kakaar, just as the other kakaars are not apart of the body so isn’t this. Keski symbolizes equality, dignity, respect and royalty, whereas Kesh doesn’t symbolize anything like that even though the other kakaars have a deeper meaning too. For example, the kakaar Kirpan symbolizes strength, courage, wisdom and power. A Keski is what completes a Khalsa along with the other kakaars. You shall yourself witness this fact and complete truth in the near future of Khalsa Raj. Every Khalsa shall only be formed due to keeping all the rehits including SARBLOH BEBEK to the true kakaars, which are Keski, Kirpan, Kanga, Keshara and Kara. A kakaar to be kesh was formed by a Manmukh, NOT GURU GOBIND SINGH JEE! Never was it him! Just as the hardcore rehits were forgotten to weaken the sikhs so were one of the kakaars, which was keski as it was erased and instead transformed from keski to kes. This left the sikhs from Khalsa to manmukhs – it left them faithless. So tell me if this kakaar you say is the true one where is Khalsa raj? Why did Raja Ranjit singh lose the battle with the british? What happened to the strength of Khalsa in Guru Jee’s time to British Raj? The goraa were the ones who did this to the kakaar keski. You obviously aren't all of a sudden going to change and believe what I've said, as this has been believed to be a kakaar for such a long time now. But always keep in mind: where are the Khalsa like Baba Deep Singh Jee gone? If every sikh in the world did believe this keski to be the true kakaar, as will in the future, as well as keeping the forgotten rehits such as sarbloh bebek, which were all kept by Guru Jee himself and others in the past then the Sikh nation would be strong enough to uphold the honor of having their own raj, Khalsa Raj. But we still don't have this yet, wonder why? You don’t have to believe this if you want to or not, but you will see this truth in the near future yourself and so will the world. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeefateh

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

SINGH?! · 23 Apr 2006

my question still hasnt been answered....... i personally believe that kesh is kakaar and not keski but also feel that when taking amrit the singh/singhni is not at fault if the panj pyare (guru ji) say keski is kakaar....at the end of they day they are only following hukam of guru ji at the time therefore i still see them as brothers and sisters of the khalsa panth does the AKJ as a jatha feel tha same way or does the jatha feel that those who do not accept keski have not taken amrit properly???? i am asking this as i have a friend who was told by members of the AKJ that his amrit (taken from an amrit sanchar organised from a non AKJ which believed kesh as kakaar) was "Void" and he needed to take it again from AKJ i just want to clarify whether this is the thinking of the AKJ as a whole or just some individuals honesty please......not anything deviating from the truth just to protect the jatha!

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

.. · 23 Apr 2006

The Akhand Kirtan Jatha doesn't have a policy paper on the issue. Each person can come to their own vichaar. I think that if all of the rest of Gurmat Maryada for amrit sinchaar was followed, it is not invalid.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

Gurlaal Singh · 23 Apr 2006

WJKK WJKF Firstly '...' i dont appreciate being called a liar especially from some one who calls themself '...' and when an issue arises like this for me i have a lot of discourse with singhs and friends and to let you know yes it was a very eventful 24 hours as i did sit and have this discussion with AKJ's and others and these points and instances were put forward; the fact being that you still failed to answer that post which means you only come on this forum to shoot down other peoples posts and comments and not be very helpful when really the pount of coming here is to share and help each other through???? Fateh. GS

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

... · 23 Apr 2006

GS, You may not appreciate being called a liar, but your story is a bit fishy. First you say you heard it from a Singh and are not sure if he is alone. Then 24 hours later you've heard of MANY instances of people being told to get peshed in the Akhand Kirtani Jatha. And not only that, but you've also in those 24 hours been able to track down members of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha (note, not just one member, but multiple members as per your story) and have discussions with them on this issue. The story is a bit hard to swallow, to say the least. At any rate, which part of your post do you feel hasn't been answered? The part where you want to know if you can cut your hair or the part where you ask if telling others to chhak amrit from the Jatha is immoral? If it's the latter then I'll say that if someone wants to receive naam driR then there is nothing wrong in encouraging them to get peshed in an amrit sinchaar held by the Akhand Kirtani Jatha. I don't believe in going around telling people their amrit sinchaar were invalid though and yes, that seems unnecessary to me.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 24 Apr 2006

Gurlaal Singh jee, If the punj pyare who gave you khande-ke-pahul told you to keep kes as your fifth and most important (shiromani) kakkaar, please keep it as your fifth kakkaar. If the punj pyare who gave you khande-ke-pahul were not members of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha, it does not matter. As long as they were rehitdhari naam-abhyaasi Gurmukhs, they were the suroop of Guru Gobind Singh Ji and your amrit is completely valid. The only thing that can stain your relationship with the Guru now is your own actions and thoughts. On the topic of keski, regardless of your belief on the fifth kakkaar, you should also keep keski with you at all times, but keep hukam of your punj pyare who gave you khande-ke-pahul. You should also remember that cutting of your kes is a kurehit, so no, you should never cut, trim, bleach, dye, or purposefully damage your kes. If you have any doubts about the Akhand Kirtani Jatha, please do not do slander of the Gursikhs in the jatha on this forum (or any forum). Please speak face-to-face with Gursikhs in the jatha and clarify any doubts. Please move on from this thread and do not indulge in pointless arguments.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

???? · 24 Apr 2006

to be honest i heard alot about this aswell, where so called AKJ members telling other amritdharis that their amrit is void and needs to be taken again from AKJ, personaly feel this is disgrace!

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

SINGH?! · 24 Apr 2006

I've just read some threads on other forums which talk about 52 hukams from Guru Gobind Singh Ji one of the hukams state.... Punj Kakaar di Rehat drirh kar rukhni - Follow the discipline of the 5 K's strictly and another states..... Dastaar bina nahi rehnaa - Wear a turban at all times why would guruji say that we should adhere strictly to the 5ks and then separatley say wear turban at all times if this was the case why wouldnt guruji for e.g also state separatley that we should...."wear kirpan at all times" personally i feel this indicates keski isnt a kakaar i dont know the validity of these 52 hukams but feel that it indicates keski is not a kakaar

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

... · 24 Apr 2006

I think you've touched on an important point. I have never heard of the source of these hukams and no puratan source mentions them. But lets say I accept that they are authentic. It still means that every amritdhari must keep a keski. I don't mind if you don't call keski a kakaar, just as long as you keep it as one, it's fine by me.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

singh · 24 Apr 2006

a keski is not the same as a dastar it is a "short dastar" worn underneath the larger turban. so your point is not valid.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

boloh vaheguru · 24 Apr 2006

MY Q STIL AINT ANSWERED back in the dayz, what did the women wear? dastar or chooni? yeh the battlefield women wore dastar, bt wot about the laydeez in the houses..?.... fateh!

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

... · 24 Apr 2006

They wore dastaars.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

Singh · 24 Apr 2006

"boloh vaheguru" As per historical accounts such as that of JD Cunningham and Lt Burns, as well as paintings, women tied their Jurra tall on their head in a knot, and tied a small Keski with Kangha ontop. They then wore a large white chunni/shawl ontop of this. When they went to war I am guessing they most likely wore the same Damalas as men did. Prior to the formation of the Khalsa in 1699, Sikhs did not follow the Rehat of the Panj Kakkars as it had not at this point been introduced.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

satnam · 24 Apr 2006

Is Patka under the turban is a keski or not.

Re: Kes Vs. Keski

... · 24 Apr 2006

A patka is not a keski. A keski is a "chhotee dastaar" that wraps around the head at least about 3 times or so. A patka is not at all a keski.