Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Uch-da-Peer

Uch-da-Peer

. · 21 Apr 2006

Guru Roop Saadh Sangat ji, Is the story of uch-da-peer in maashee vaarda, where Guru Gobind SInghji were present and Guru Sahib allowed a certain meal to be eaten after bhog with Sri Sahib true? The meal, as someone told me was 'meat'. I am sorry, I find it hard to say this, and it is hard for me to believe this story. When the topic of Guru Ka langar came, I was told that because there is much power in the kirpan Guru Sahib allowed bhog of meat with sri sahib?? Is this true,and if so, how accurate is this story? Can any Gursikh please provide with some knowledge, as if this story is fake, I need to correct those who believe it to be true. thank you.

Re: Uch-da-Peer

... · 22 Apr 2006

The same sources that give this story, also say once the kirpan was put through the dish, it turned to karah parshad. If you want to use a story, you have to use the whole thing and that's a pretty important part of it.

Re: Uch-da-Peer

Makhan · 23 Apr 2006

If guru ji disguised as Muslim peer in the presence of mugal army to hide his identity how could Sikh use kirpan for bhog. All Sikh gurus were against miracles turning meat into karah parshad is a miracle and is against Guru jig’s preaching. Guru Teg Bahadur Ji did not show miracle to save his life why would Guru Gobind Singh Ji do this and defy his father? These question need to be answered.

Re: Uch-da-Peer

.. · 23 Apr 2006

I didn't say anything about whether to believe it or not, just that if you use one part of the story, you have to use the whole thing. When Guru Nanak squeezed Bhai Lalo's parshaada and milk came out, was that also against Gurmat? How about stopping the rock at Punja Sahib? How about when Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib saved the sinking ship by giving his shoulder? Are all these stories wrong too? Miracles on demand are wrong and not given by Guru Sahib. But Guru Sahib is himself a miracle and many miracles happened in the course of their dealings with the Sangat, but were not done on the orders of a so-called King.

Re: Uch-da-Peer

a singh · 23 Apr 2006

makhan..i think u need to understand how miracles work in sikhi...and guru sahib is not bound by anything...as guru sahib may do as he please.

Re: Uch-da-Peer

Makhan · 23 Apr 2006

Author: .. Author: a Singh No I don't because I believe in gurubani and not in these sakhis. The story of Makhan shah Lubana is not a true story. According to "Mahan Kosh" he lived in village "Tanda" district “Jehlum” Pakistan and Bhai Kahan Singh Nabha has not mentioned this shipping story. Dr. Taran Singh & Dr. Fauja Singh have also not mentioned this story in their writing about Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji. Regarding blood and milk pouring from Malik Bhago & Bhai Lallo's food is also not true. What is the difference between our great Gurus and Hindu’s or Muslim’s prophets if our Gurus have to perform miracles to convey their message to ordinary people? Sikh Gurus had supernatural intelligence and had the ability to convince people and did not need un-natural means (miracles). That was the Hindu, Muslim or Christian way to convince people. People invented these stories to show that our Gurus are in no way below the prophets of other religions. As about a cobra spreading his head over young Nanak's face to protect him from the sun is taken from followers of Buddhism. King cobra protected Buddha’s face from the sun by spreading his hood over his face, when Buddha woke up he touched cobra's head with his hand and that is why king cobra has lines over his hood. Please do not attach these cheap miracles stories to devalue our great Gurus. Our Gurus lived practical lives with supernatural intelligence. The list is endless, but there is no point because some people do not understand the difference between super-natural intelligence and miracles. Miracles do not make a Guru a great Guru.

Re: Uch-da-Peer

... · 23 Apr 2006

makhan, If you don't believe in the Bhai Makhan Shah story, then how was Guru Tegh Bahadur recognised by Makhan Shah at Baba Bakala from amongst the 22 other claimants? What about Punja Sahib? Fake as well? How about Guru Gobind Singh at Gurdwara Bhatha Sahib cooling the kiln? There are so many stories involving miraculous happenings, are you sure they are all false?

Re: Uch-da-Peer

a singh · 24 Apr 2006

here ones for ya...what about 1699? Are you saying guru ji was "fake" and needed to "show his powers" by be-heading the punj and placing there heads on different bodies?

Re: Uch-da-Peer

. · 24 Apr 2006

Thank you for all the responses.

Re: Uch-da-Peer

makhan · 25 Apr 2006

All these statements are just to make u believe what u believe. As far as sakhi of panja sahib the story goes that Balli kandhari rolled a rock from top of the mountain to kill guru ji and guru ji stopped the rock with his hand, it means this rock is still hanging in the air un added. I have not been to panja sahib but if this rock is attached to the mountain then this sakhi is also false. You can test Gurubani according to science and you will not find any thing which will go against science. But sakhis no way. that is why today's youth is turning away from religion. sikhism is a religion of future not of the past.

Re: Uch-da-Peer

makhan · 25 Apr 2006

All these statements are just to make u believe what u believe. As far as sakhi of panja sahib the story goes that Balli kandhari rolled a rock from top of the mountain to kill guru ji and guru ji stopped the rock with his hand, it means this rock is still hanging in the air un added. I have not been to panja sahib but if this rock is attached to the mountain then this sakhi is also false. You can test Gurubani according to science and you will not find any thing which will go against science. But sakhis no way. that is why today's youth is turning away from religion. sikhism is a religion of future not of the past.

Re: Uch-da-Peer

satnam · 25 Apr 2006

How about Guru Nanak Dev jee rotated Mecca and this is written by Bhai Gurdas jee in his Bani which is a pakki Bani.

Re: Uch-da-Peer

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Apr 2006

it is written in the bible that when the walls of jericho were ready to fall....the SUN stood fixed - in order to extend the day for battle.. now we all know that the sun is not in the sky..the earth revolves around it to make day and night...and any time earth stops revolving...no more gravity..and no more earth..but then how would the writers of the bible know that...they believed the earth was flat and centre of the universe.and had no knowledge of gravity etc etc..and all that..but that doesnt mean thye have changed the bible...the same exact words about jerciho are still there... SIKHI is not like that at all..we have nothing that is absurd..and cannot be rationally explained..and nothing to be sorry about...Gurbani goes hand in glove with science...in fact its science that must look at gurbani for facts.. When Mecca rotated..was it just the city - like on a microwave turntable..or the surroundings also..if the earth below mecca also rotated...it is easy to prove it..the layers of earth strata under mecca will not sync with the surroundings..on the other hand if everything rotated and went full circle...just as once in a life time show for that time only ??Look for answers in Hardwwar...here Guru Ji wanted to show the hindus the futility of throwing water to the heavens..so Guru Ji DID NOT MAKE their water impossible to throw up...Guru Ji also began to throw water..BUT in the OPPOSITE direction....to attract attention...and then ANSWER the people as to why ??? in Mecca the objective was to show that God doesnt live in one direction only...

Re: Uch-da-Peer

Harmeet Singh · 22 May 2006

vjkk, vjkf Makhan Jee, you really need to read Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Jee's book called Rangley Sajan. The whole point of the book is to prove that miracles and special/hidden powers don't have to connect with science as he stated in his introduction. Please read that book, I'm sure you'll change your entire view after reading it. :) vjkk, vjkf