Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

singh · 23 Apr 2006

I know that in a lot of places, the Punj Pyare come into the darbar after the amrit sinchaar with the people who took amrit or got peshed following. Everyone stands up to greet them. I think that this practice isn't right. Punj Pyare are only punj pyaare upto the final ardas of the amrit sinchar and after that seva is finished, they return to being normal Singhs and members of the sangat. In Bhai Jodh Singh's book, "Soan Chiree ChaRee Gain" he writes that when he took amrit in Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh's time, after the amrit sinchar, the Punj Pyare returned to normal dress and came and sat in the Ran Sabaiee. He says they did not go out as a group. Another reason I think this practice is not right is that those people who got peshed are then exposed. If the punj pyaaray wish to expose someoene as having been peshed, that is fine, but what if someone gets peshed to ask a question? When he walks out, people begin to wonder what mistake was made. This factor actually discourages some people from getting peshed at all and makes the peshi process even more painful and difficult. I think this practice doesn't make much sense and I request the Sangats that still do it to please re-consider. I don't see any benefit to it.

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

mmm · 24 Apr 2006

What I find slightly strange is that it doesn't happen at EVERY rensbhai...

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

observer · 24 Apr 2006

alot of people get very inspired by it.

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

o · 24 Apr 2006

cos ther isnt a amrit sanchaar at every rainsbai

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

... · 24 Apr 2006

I think the issue of people getting inspired doesn't justify the practice. Lots of people would get inspired by seeing the amrit sinchar itself, but it's not made public. Speaking in general as well, the pepole that do seva in Punj Pyare or as Pehraydar, etc. aren't all at the same spiritual level. It's very conceivable that a sense of haumai might come in if the entire sangat knows they have done this seva.

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

Hardeep Singh · 24 Apr 2006

"... " How you do u know there not at the same spirtual level? Maybe during the selection of the punj, they had 6 very spirtal gursikhs, but then the 1 of them obviously has to do pehradaar de seva. I think it was awesome the punj walking into the darbar and doing keertan!! Saying that, a keertani can get kaumai from doing keertan, infront of the sangat.

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

... · 24 Apr 2006

Hardeep Singh, I'm not talking about any specific amrit sinchar, I'm talking in general. Generally speaking, there are very big chances that all the people that have a seva in an amrit sinchar are not of the same spiritual level. It's a given frankly. The difference between a kirtani and someone that does seva in the Punj Pyare is HUGE. Anyone can really do seva of kirtan based on whether they have that skill. Doing seva in the Punj Pyare is something that is given to someone who has a chardi kala jeevan and is solid in rehit. That having been said, even people at the highest levels have fallen due to haumai. The chances of getting haumai in this situation are a lot more than someone getting it from doing kirtan.

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

Singhh · 24 Apr 2006

Translated from Soan ChiRee ChRee GaiN by Bhai Sahib Jodh Singh (Delhi) Amrit Da Bata In order to prepare the bata of Amrit the Panj Piare did ardas. The Iron vessel, Khanda, Water and sugar pellets were already present. A blanket was layed in front of Guru Sahib, on top of a large rock the iron vessel was steadily placed. In the attendance of Guru Granth Sahib sat one Singh and the jathedar arrived in the panj. They (the panj) all sat in Bir asaN (warrior position) and became the Sanmukhs of the Guru. Together the Panj poured the water into the vessel and then put in the sugar pellets. Turn by tuen the Panj bania, Jap, Jaap, Sodha Swaiye, Chaupai and full Anand Sahib were read. Whilst doing paaT the Singh held the Khanda in his right hand, whilst the bata was held with the left with complete concentration. The other Singhs held the bata with both hands and everyone focussed their conciousness into the nectar being prepared. Once the five prayers were over the Jathedar did ardas. In order to give the candidates Amrit the jathedar asked the Singh in attendance of Guru Sahib to seek permission. After this the Panj piare again sat in Bir AsaN (warrior position) ready to bless the abhilakis with Amrit. There were approximately 8-10 people getting initiated into the Khalsa brotherhood, my turn came after the 2nd or 3rd person. Kautak (miracle) This was an unforgettable experience which occured after complete Sodh Sudhayee. My inner state was uncontrallable, I was half concious and was completely mesmerized; my body was just shaking. It is extremely difficult to describe in detail. As Sanmukh I went to humbly bow my head before Guru Granth Sahib Ji, as I was about to do so Guru Gobind Singh Ji in all his glory gave me his Partakh darshan (in real body) on Guru Granth Sahib Ji's throne. It was as if there was a mirror and behind it Guru Gobind Singh Ji sat in Bir AsaN. It seemed as if it was happening for a long time, but it was only a second or so. After bowing my head I drank the Amrit, then Amrit was splashed in the Kesh (hair), then in the eyes. The Jathedar then proceeded to teach the method of reciting the Gurmantar, at that time my hands just clasped together in prayer and I suddenly received Guru Gobind Singh Ji's darshan once again on the throne of Guru Granth Sahib, my eyes shut and I placed my head in the holy feet of the Guru. The Jathedar Ji then tapped me on my back as if to say 'be aware!'. (Saavdhan!) He also had to physically wake one Singh up from this state of Vismadh. Everyone started doing Abhyas and the Amrit ceremony ended quiet quickly. The Rehnsbhai The time was 1-2am. In the hall upstairs a Rehnsbhai Keertan was in progress. I can clearly remember that the Panj Piare came into the Darbar Sahib along with us without the formal dress for the Panj, but on the other hand I do not know whether they came in with us or came in after. What I do know is that after Degh (parshad) was distributed after the Amrit Sanchar they went into a separate room in order to get changed. This I know for sure. Just like normal members of the Sangat they bowed their heads in front of Guru Granth Sahib Ji and took a seat in Sat Sang. I was coloured in the divine colours at that time, but when I did come to full conciousness I found myself sitting right behind Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji. Only the Guru knows how that happened! On Bhai Sahibs dastar was the Chakar (iron quoit) and whenever he swayed back and forth I felt a pull towards him as he was a divinely imbued soul. My mouth just filled with unbearable taste. Bhai Sahib was singing the following Shabad on the Baja: “Poota Mata Kee Asees”. Keertan was taking place with an ecstatic atmosphere which is hard to forget. Naam Abhyas Bhai Sahibs eyes were closed, but they were rolled up towards the sky. The sound of his voice was as though a child is screaming. After 2am, abhyas started in the hall for 2 or so hours. I do not know who turned the main lights off and put on a dim one. The beautiful Jaap of ‘Vaheguru’ was being meditated upon. At that moment it seemed as though no one was present there and I myself was not present there, all that was being heard was the Vaheguru Gurmantar. My spiritual state rose to such a height that I was not conscious of my body or anything else that was happening around me. Only the beautiful name was heard all around, it can be compared to the ticking of a watch, no one was at a higher or lower pitch than anyone else, everyone was reciting with exactly the same tone and rhythm. When my eyes were closed, at times I would experience ecstatic light through my inner eyes. Sometimes I would get a divine glimpse of ‘Ik Oankar’ and it looked as though it was an electric Halogen light shaped like the symbol, whereas sometimes I would get vision of the word ‘Vaheguru’. Then, after about 2 and a half hours the Keertan kicked off again. After some minutes, we started to hear the Vaheguru dhunni resounding everywhere, even though the keertan continued. When I came down from this avastha I noticed that I was still in the same hall as before and the sangat was joined with the keertan enjoying the ecstacy of his name. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh and Baoo Mal Singh were sitting infront of me. Some keertani bibia were doing keertan. Some sangat were sitting behind me, some infront of me, all in total bliss. Bhai Sahibs chakar (iron quoit) was continuing to mesmerize me and had a magnetic glow. “Vaho Vaho Gursikh dhan hai”. To tell you the truth, I did not understand what kautak was taking place, nor did I know what this ras was, otherwise I would have grabbed the holy feet of that Sant (bhai sahib) and never let go. When I did get some knowledge the true king (Guru ji) made me into good friends with Bhai Sahib, he bought this Ant into his holy shade. In the morning, after Bhai Sahib had sung many shabads, the ceremony came to an end. Seperation After this we went home and ate langar, we then went straight back to the Gurdwara Sahib. (In them times langar was made for sangat that had come from outside). Sangat was getting ready to go. Bapoo ji (bhai sahib) and another Singh were trying to get accommodation for the sangat to stay. I kept on gazing into their lovelorn eyes and enjoying ras and they also kept looking at me. The Singhs who were coloured in divine colours were hugging each other and leaving. Initially Bapoo ji was very sad, all the Singhs had tears in their eyes. Everyone was yearning for the same thing as I was – that the Keertan never stopped along with the Naam and Bani. But everything happens in the will of Vaheguru. “Sanjog vijog doe kaar chalave lekhe avai bhaag”

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

confused · 24 Apr 2006

"Another reason I think this practice is not right is that those people who got peshed are then exposed. If the punj pyaaray wish to expose someoene as having been peshed, that is fine, but what if someone gets peshed to ask a question? When he walks out, people begin to wonder what mistake was made. This factor actually discourages some people from getting peshed at all and makes the peshi process even more painful and difficult." "singh" if they were exposed then yes it would discourage others to take pesh but the sangat didnt no who took pesh unless they saw sum1 that they new had taken amrit before in which case it cant be helped they are going to be exposed anyway when they leave the amrit sanchar because lots of ppl were waitin outside and stuff!! sorry if im wrong but if your a peshi and you dont wana be exposed why commit that paap in the first place wich made u a peshi i no it cant be held sumtimes but if you done sumit knowingly which was bad then if you're exposed isnt dat ur fault?? forgive daas if i have said anything wrong please correct me and sorry if i affended anyone this is just my opinion!!!! finally i think the panj pyaare walking down the darbar sahib was absolutely awesome breath taking we are all lucky that guruji gave us kirpa and we who were there experienced that!! and when panj pyaare (bhai Tavsev singh) was beautiful!!!! vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji kee fateh

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

o · 24 Apr 2006

"..." pretty much evry1 knows hu does seva in panj pyareh anyways

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

lapt · 24 Apr 2006

"Author: ... " <<< the sangat get to know who teh panj are anyway , and what can the paredaar do "hide his face" anytime somone walks by ?? The homay comes when you start questioning the actions of the panj singh , you should learn that hiding behind computer screens and talking about homay of the panj ain't gunna help your jeevan , if you have an issue about the panj then talk directly to them

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

... · 24 Apr 2006

lapt, you said, "The homay comes when you start questioning the actions of the panj singh" So to question something on the basis of Gurmat is haumai? The practice of walking in does not seem like Gurmat to me. After the final ardaas of the amrit sinchaar, punj pyare revert to being just normal members of the Sangat. As the article above says, in Bhai Sahib's time, this didn't happen. Another thing, I think it's very wrong to see any Singh in the sangat as a member of "the Panj". They are members of Punj Pyare only when they are in the amrit sinchaar mandal and before the final ardas. After that, they are respected Singhs and nothing more. No Singh ever can be considered a permanent member or a fixed member of the Punj Pyare. Punj Pyare should be chosen fresh at each amrit sinchaar by the gathering of the Khalsa Sangat, not fixed roles.

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

singh · 24 Apr 2006

the panj pyare come out of amrit sanchars into the divan in india and uk, canada etc smagams (as well as non akj) and have been doing so for many years. yes in the bhai sahib article the panj didnt but it doesnt say it is "not gurmat". bhai sahib bhai jeevan singh ji himself has requested for keertan programs to be extended so the panj can come out. this is simply a non issue that is being made into one, anyone who has seen/experienced the panj come out themselves will know it cannot possibly be a "manmat" action.

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

... · 24 Apr 2006

The practice of Punj Pyare coming out has been slowly been stopped. It happens in Panchain smagams, but I dont' think in India it happens in the mainstream smagam. It doesn't happen in other places either. The fact remains, Punj Pyare stop being Punj Pyare once the final ardas is done for the amrit sinchar.

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

confused · 24 Apr 2006

im really confused by this matter, (or non-matter) now. Can some of the SiyaNe Singhs please commment on this? Thankyou

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

Tamed cat · 24 Apr 2006

What about Nagar Kirtans...are the 5 Singhs not Guru's Roop? should they be allowed to lead..there is no amrit sanchaar.

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

singh · 24 Apr 2006

there is another issue here. the panj piyarai are the sargun saroop of guru jee. however, the shabad saroop is still higher. the guru granth sahib is greater than even the panj, we all understand this. otherwise, god forbid, the panj would sit at the same level as guru granth sahib jee, but this is, of course, a disgraceful possiblity. when guru jee's darbar is going on, guru jee should be the focus of attention. to stand up and aknowledge anyone else is like turning your back on your guru. only if another saroop of guru granth sahib jee enters the darbar, then yes, we should stand up and give it our full respect. however, if the panj come in, forgetting the issue of whether an ardaas has been done for the end of the amrit sanchaar or not, the sangat should NOT stand up and aknowledge the panj in such a way. it is highly disrespectful to guru jee. we all should firmly believe that the panj are the full and real sargun saroop of guru jee. however, we should also remember that granth sahib jees, even before been given gurgaddi in 1708 were treated higher than the guru sahib's themselves. guru arjun walked behind the original guru granth sahib and sat lower than it in darbar. likewise, we have all heard how guru jee slept lower than the granth sahib. the same was true of later gurus. they understood that the guru shabad was greater than even them! i am completely certain that if we were could see darbar sahib 400 years ago, after aad granth sahib jee's parskash had been done there, and guru arjun walked in, the sangat would not stand up for guru arjun sahib. it just doesn't make sense. guruFateh singh

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

lapt · 24 Apr 2006

this is pindoo thinking yaars , the panj walk in and bow to guru granth sahib duh!!! it's not rocket science why does the youth try and make everything so complicated ????

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

singh · 25 Apr 2006

i have seen videos of india mainstream akj smagams where the panj have come out. people such as bhai surat singh pooranji have been involved in such sevas. i have also heard of this happening at non-akj amrit sanchars. if it is acceptable for panj pyare to lead the nagar keertan i dont see why the panj cannot come into the divan hall. the calibre of the gurmukhs that have been involved when this has happened in various uk and india samagams, as well as jathebandia outside of akj makes it quite clear that it is not a "manmat" or "wrong" practise.

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

ummm · 25 Apr 2006

its in interesting one actually, if this is meant to be a regular occurence, check back through you old smagam vids since 1995 and see how many times they've actually come in, and if you really know what your talking about ask them why they never came in so and so year ?? if this is meant to happen at every smagam ! it should be without fail, to pick and choose is manmat, why ??? because if it is marayada ?? then no one is allowed to choose when they come in or not, regardless of who has been involved in the amrit sanchar. Found the whole message on the screen quite amusing as well, first time i've seen that, perhaps we should put up a message saying "everyone stay in the darbar as ilhaii gurbani is being recited", instead of everyone stay in as punj singh are coming in.

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

Dhian Dhar · 25 Apr 2006

Singhs, please remember that Guru Gobind Singh ji Himself kneeled infront of the 5 Pyarai. When the 5 Singhs come into the Darbar, nobody bows down to them, nobody has their back to Guru Ji, the 5 Singh themselves bow down to Guru Ji. Standing up for the 5 Singhs is a sign of respect. The 5 Singhs do not suddenly stop being 5 Pyarai at the end of the Ardas - nothing really changes. The Ardas signifies that the end of the Amrit Sanchar, not the end of the 5 Singhs! Where possible, the 5 Singhs try to bring the new Amritdharis into the Saadh Sangat - which is highly commendable. The 5 Singhs are effectively saying, "Come and join the True Sangat." The intention is not to say to the Sangat, "Look at me!" When the Sangat stands up for the 5 Singhs, they are not standingup for the individual Singhs who make up the 5 Pyarai - they are standing up for the most beloved Panj Pyarai who Guru Sahib cherished so lovingly. Should we not cherish that which Guru Sahib himself cherished so dearly? We kneel infront of the Panj for Amrit Daat, just as Guru Ji did. It is through the Panj Singhs that Guru Ji's Kirpa is done. How is it objectionable then for us to stand in presence of the Panj?

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

gurooooooooooooo!!!!!! · 25 Apr 2006

it was so good when the panj come in the darbar i have never falt so good in my life and plz stop making a big thing out of it just get a life we dont no when the last breth is going to finish so lets all just jaap naam guroooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

l; · 25 Apr 2006

singh i dont get u guru nanak dev ji to guru granth sahib ji is same. no difference same jot how can one be higher then other

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

... · 25 Apr 2006

"Standing up for the 5 Singhs is a sign of respect. The 5 Singhs do not suddenly stop being 5 Pyarai at the end of the Ardas - nothing really changes. The Ardas signifies that the end of the Amrit Sanchar, not the end of the 5 Singhs!" When do the Punj Pyare become Punj Pyare? Or do you think they are always punj pyare? Singhs only become punj pyare after a thorough sudhaiee. Otherwise, do you think that that the sangat should stand up when 5 Singhs walk in together normally? And when do you think Punj Pyare return to being normal Singhs? Or do you think they stay Punj Pyare forever? If not at the final ardas of the amrit sinchaar, then when? That final ardaas changes everything. These Singhs then become no higher or lower than any other Singh.

Re: Punj Pyare Coming into Darbar

Admin · 25 Apr 2006

thread closed.