Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

KPS Gill CONDEMNED by Human Rights Watch

KPS Gill CONDEMNED by Human Rights Watch

LS · 01 May 2006

http://www.hrw.org/english/docs/2006/04/27/india13279.htm India: Draconian Response to Naxalite Violence States Must Respect Rights to Counter Rebels (New York, April 27, 2006) – The adoption of a draconian law by the Chattisgarh state government to address the Naxalite armed movement and its appointment of a known human rights abuser as security advisor are likely to lead to serious abuses, Human Rights Watch said today. Chattisgarh has a duty to keep its citizens safe, but it should not resort to draconian laws or abusive officials. The state and central governments must use lawful methods to counter Naxalite violence. Brad Adams, Asia director at Human Rights Watch. India: Grime under the red carpet Commentary, March 26, 2006 The group said the government should repeal the new Special Public Protection Act, or amend it to conform to international human rights law, and remove the special advisor, K.P.S. Gill, who led the Punjab police at a time of widespread rights violations. “Chattisgarh has a duty to keep its citizens safe, but it should not resort to draconian laws or abusive officials,” said Brad Adams, Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “The state and central governments must use lawful methods to counter Naxalite violence.” The Chattisgarh state government’s actions come even as the human rights and humanitarian situation is deteriorating in the 13 Indian states affected by increasing Naxalite attacks. Fifty villagers were abducted by Naxalites in Chattisgarh on April 25. The Indian government is planning to deploy 11 battalions of the paramilitary Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) in states affected by Naxalite action, increasing fears of spiraling armed confrontations that would place ordinary civilians at grave risk. The CRPF has been implicated in serious abuses in other parts of the country, including Jammu and Kashmir state. Recent criminal acts by the Naxalites, such as the April 25 abductions, politically motivated killings, and the use of landmines and bombings, have placed the central and state governments under enormous pressure to maintain public safety and security. The leftist Naxalites say they are fighting on behalf of lower-caste Indians. They have imposed illegal taxes; demanded food and shelter from villagers; abducted and killed “class enemies,” government officials, police officers and others whom they consider to be opponents; and hampered the delivery of aid to the isolated countryside, adversely affecting the lives of the people they claim to represent. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh recently described the Naxal movement as the “single biggest internal challenge ever faced by our country.” The Special Public Protection Act, which came into force in March, is a vague and overly broad law that allows detention of up to three years for “unlawful activities.” The term is so loosely defined in the law that it threatens fundamental freedoms set out by the Indian constitution and international human rights law, and could severely restrict the peaceful activities of individuals and civil society organizations. The respected Public Union for Civil Liberties in India has filed suit, alleging that the ordinance is “amenable to gross abuse and misuse, arbitrariness and partiality” and “can result in harsh and drastic punishment to innocent persons without hearing or remedy and … can be abused for the suppression of the fundamental rights of the citizens.” The law also criminalizes any support given to Naxalites, with no defense of duress. Thus, persons whom the Naxalites force to provide assistance are subject to detention under the ordinance. “People can now be put in jail for three years for peaceful protests, or for giving food to the Naxalites at the point of a gun,” said Adams. “This is a mistake. Scrupulous respect for rights is the best answer to the Naxalites.” Human Rights Watch expressed particular concern about the appointment of Gill, who led Punjab’s police force in the 1990s, when it was implicated in widespread human rights violations during counter-insurgency operations. During Gill’s tenure, the Punjab police were responsible for numerous extrajudicial executions, “disappearances” and cremations intended to destroy evidence of those executed. The Central Bureau of Investigation found that at least 2,097 such cremations occurred in just one district. Human rights activist Jaswant Singh Khalra, who first exposed the cremations, was murdered by members of the Punjab police in 1995. During a trial for Khalra’s murder, in which six policemen were convicted in 2005, evidence was presented linking Gill to Khalra’s death. Gill has often criticized human rights defenders, saying in an article last year that only a small number of human rights organizations “are actually and innocently concerned about anybody’s rights,” and that the rest, together with “terrorists,” had established a modus operandi “for the manipulation of the media and the systematic abuse of the processes of law to constantly denigrate the police and to protect criminals and terrorists.” “Appointing K.P.S. Gill is a sure way to undermine public confidence in the security services,” said Adams. “Given his record, the government will not be able to claim ignorance if and when Gill uses abusive methods.” Recommendations Human Rights Watch called upon all parties, including the central government, the state governments, the various Naxalite groups and government-backed vigilante groups, to respect human rights protections under Indian and international law. In particular, Human Rights Watch urged that: Indian security forces must end the practice of extrajudicial executions of alleged Naxalites and their supporters, and allow the National Human Rights Commission and independent civil society organizations to investigate such allegations. All state and national security legislation that does not provide for international standards of due process or fair trials or allows for prolonged and arbitrary detention should be repealed or amended to conform to international standards. The government must cease the sponsorship of and take steps to dismantle armed vigilante groups that commit human rights abuses. The government should ensure that internally displaced persons are protected according to the United Nations Guiding Principles on Internal Displacement. The Naxalites must immediately cease committing abuses of human rights, including killings and abductions, and allow the National Human Rights Commission and independent civil society organizations to investigate such incidents. The Naxalites must immediately end all recruitment of persons under the age of 18 and demobilize all individuals under 18 from all forces under their control.

Re: KPS Gill CONDEMNED by Human Rights Watch

LS · 01 May 2006

The following letter is a joint letter by ENSAAF, Human Rights Watch, REDRESS, and the Center for Human Rights and Global Justice. The complete letter, with appendix, as well as the PDF, is available at: http://www.ensaaf.org/CBIletter.html May 1, 2006 Mr. Vijay Shanker Director Central Bureau of Investigation Block No. 4, 6th Floor, CGO Complex Lodi Road New Delhi 110003 Re: K.P.S. Gill Dear Mr. Shanker, In early December 2005, Mrs. Paramjit Kaur Khalra wrote to you requesting that you initiate an independent investigation and bring charges against former Director General of Police (DGP) K.P.S. Gill for his alleged role in the murder of her husband, Jaswant Singh Khalra in October 1995. Over ten years ago, members of the Punjab police operating under Mr. Gill abducted, tortured, and murdered human rights defender Jaswant Singh Khalra because of his courageous work in exposing the "disappearances," custodial deaths, and secret cremations of thousands of Sikhs in Punjab. On November 18, 2005, Additional Sessions Judge Bhupinder Singh convicted and sentenced six Punjab police officers for their roles in the murder. Though long overdue, these convictions were an important milestone in Mrs. Khalra's search for justice. Mrs. Khalra has campaigned tirelessly for justice despite severe police harassment. Her request for your intervention is based on testimony that emerged during the trial of the six police officers. On September 11, 1995, five days after Punjab police abducted Mr. Khalra, the Supreme Court issued formal notice and service to DGP Gill of a habeas corpus petition filed on behalf of Mr. Khalra. The testimony of Special Police Officer (SPO) Kuldip Singh established at trial that Mr. Gill ignored the pending habeas corpus petition and personally interrogated Mr. Khalra in October 1995, while Mr. Khalra was illegally detained at the residence of Senior Superintendent of Police (SSP) Ajit S. Sandhu. Evidence from the trial also indicates that Mr. Gill authorized the abduction and murder of Mr. Khalra. SPO Kuldip Singh testified that, according to his superior, during the interrogation Mr. Gill gave Mr. Khalra a choice between life and death. In order to live, Mr. Khalra simply had to follow Mr. Gill's advice and stop his human rights work. The police murdered Mr. Khalra in late October 1995. On November 15, 1995, the Supreme Court issued another order on the habeas corpus petition, ordering the CBI to inquire into Mr. Khalra's "disappearance" because the police investigation had not yielded any results. The Supreme Court further directed Mr. Gill to "render all assistance and help to the CBI." At a minimum, Mr. Gill failed to take necessary and reasonable measures to prevent Mr. Khalra's murder. Mr. Gill also ignored court orders. Despite receiving formal service in September 1995 about an active habeas corpus petition before the Supreme Court, Mr. Gill failed to disclose Mr. Khalra's whereabouts while he was alive. At the time that Mr. Gill interrogated Mr. Khalra, Mr. Khalra allegedly could barely move from the torture he had experienced at the hands of Mr. Gill's subordinate officers. At that time, Mr. Gill was legally required to order Mr. Khalra's release, thereby ending his illegal detention and further torture, and preventing his murder. In its November 1995 order, the Supreme Court explicitly identified Mr. Gill's subordinate officers as alleged to be involved in Mr. Khalra's "disappearance," and directed a copy of its order to DGP Gill. The court ordered Mr. Gill to provide assistance in locating Mr. Khalra. Mr. Gill thus had well-publicized information in his possession that put him on notice about his subordinates' illegal activities. Yet Mr. Gill ignored the Supreme Court's order. He further failed to punish any officers after the murder of Mr. Khalra, despite his personal knowledge of the officers who illegally detained, tortured and murdered Mr. Khalra. Given the weight of the evidence available in the public domain about Mr. Gill's role in this case, the CBI must undertake an impartial and thorough inquiry as soon as possible and then refer the case for appropriate prosecution. Both Indian and international law provide a clear framework to prosecute the kinds of acts and omissions described in this case (please see the Appendix for a short discussion of relevant international law). We are therefore disappointed that the Central Bureau of Investigation has yet to respond to Mrs. Khalra's letter of December 2005. We urge you to address this matter on an urgent basis, not just because justice has already been inordinately delayed, but also because Mr. Gill is continuing to act as a governmental advisor on counter-insurgency operations. His recent appointment as Security Advisor to the Chattisgarh government provides every reason to fear the advice he will offer to the state police in their efforts to counter the Naxalites. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Brad Adams Executive Director, Asia Division Human Rights Watch Jaskaran Kaur Executive Director ENSAAF Carla Ferstman Director REDRESS Smita Narula Faculty Director Center for Human Rights and Global Justice CC: Paramjit Kaur Khalra

Re: KPS Gill CONDEMNED by Human Rights Watch

justice · 01 May 2006

why kps gill still alive can't we kidnap a loved one of his son father mother daughter but not hurt them just take them in and make him surrender and hand himself over to us take him over to pakistan torture him for month and month then finish him off.

Re: KPS Gill CONDEMNED by Human Rights Watch

Singh · 02 May 2006

forget that, let the jamddotts do that

Re: KPS Gill CONDEMNED by Human Rights Watch

LK · 03 May 2006

uthor: justice Date: 05-01-06 15:50 why kps gill still alive can't we kidnap a loved one of his son father mother daughter but not hurt them just take them in and make him surrender and hand himself over to us take him over to pakistan torture him for month and month then finish him off. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- [Sarcasm]Good idea. Very Sikh-like to involve his son, ho lives in Australian and has totally disowned him for his action. Go and abduct his Brother and do exactly what he did to Khalra. That woudl be a very Sikh action. I'm sure Guru Ji woudl be very happy with you doing that.[/sarcasm] Sarcasm-o-meter: MAX On another note, I'm very happy to read that a respected organisation like Human Rights Watch has engaged itself in the Gill Issue. That is a very solid mail signed by ver solid people =D