Re: Question
R. Dorothy Wayneright · 26 Dec 2003
This is very interesting question.
Personally I feel that to reach "heaven" all you need to do is follow the three tenants that Guru Nanak set forth:
1) Remember god.
2) Do not steal/work hard.
3) Share and be a decent individual.
I think most people get so wrapped up in the schematics of Sikhi (which color turban Sikhs should wear, what kind of material their food can or can not be prepared in, etc...) they lose sight of the basics tenants Guru Nanak set forth.
Re: Question
waheguru sahib jeeee · 27 Dec 2003
ya only if ur a gursikh
there was a sakhi i cant quite remember
but there was a man who did bhagti for a long time in a jungle
and he didnt go to god because he was not an amirthdhari.....
thats what i remember..
umm and also when guru gobind singh ji visited some family or something
the guy wanted charna of guru sahib, he asked for guru sahib cuz guru ji asked him what he wanted..
guru ji said i cant give u my charna becus u havent taken amrit
Re: Question
taken directly fromwww.akj.org · 27 Dec 2003
Waheguroo ji ka Khalsa Waheguroo ji ki Fateh !!
*******I have just heard this story, so am not sure about the authenticity******
Sheikh Farid ji did so much jap tap... When first 12 years he went to jungle to do bhagti and only ate fruits and did bhagti and other 12 years he did other tap but he still couldn't merge with GOD, there was akashvani that until you will accept a guru and then do bhagti, it won't be fruitful... then he made one japi tapi as a guru and did so much seva and bhagti, he did for another 12 years and he did everything for HIS guru and then finally his bhagti was successful.
How can we think that doing seva and simran without taking Amrit (accepting guru) and obeying HUKAM will be fruitful? Seva and simran did without taking Amrit will just make good karams and can be fruitful in giving worldly sukh... but won't help in anything related to mukti... Only after taking Amrit and obeying rehat and then being dedicated in seva and simran of true guru will help us get mukti...
Bhul Chuk di Khima
Waheguroo ji ka Khalsa Waheguroo ji ki Fateh !!
Re: Question
R. Dorothy Wayneright · 27 Dec 2003
__tHe-mAN said:__
>Look man, our 10 GURU was amritdhari. Once you have taken amrit, you're given a
>routine, you're given entrance into school.
This makes no sense to me. How is this related at all to the discussion at hand?
>Ask those Sikhs who died in 1984, they had true love for the Guru in delhi.
Way to use emotional appeal to make me look like the bad person. The events of 1984 have nothing to do with this discussion.
>Anyone can act as a hindu by cutting their hair, but someone who submits is truly a believer.
Who said anything about acting like a Hindu?
I said to reach heaven following the teachings of Guru Nanak should be enough. Are you implying that following the teachings of Guru Nanak makes you a Hindu? (not making a straw-man here, just want to know if I am interpreting this person correctly).
__waheguru sahib jeeee said:__
>ya only if ur a gursikh
>there was a sakhi i cant quite remember
>but there was a man who did bhagti for a long time in a jungle
>and he didnt go to god because he was not an amirthdhari.....
>thats what i remember..
Yes it has been a long time since you heard it, let me refresh you memory.
The lesson you should have walked away with from that Sakhi is that a Sikh does not need to walk away from life and society and go mediate in the jungle to reach heaven. Instead a Sikh should be a hard working member of society. You can pray and work hard at the same time. I think the example is passing out the grain and saying "vaheguroo" each time you pass it out.
Number #1 and #2 as I listed in my original post of the three basic teachings of Guru Nanak satisfies this.
__- said:__
>I believe that yes sikhi is the only way becuase this is what my guru ji has told
>me and me being his sikh I have to believe everything he says,
No! This is the exact opposite of what you should be doing!
Why don't Sikhs idol worship?
Why don't Sikhs believe in multiple gods?
Why don't Sikhs go out into jungles and pray to god all day long?
Why don't Sikh women kill themselves when their husbands die?
Why don't Sikhs believe in a caste system?
Sikhi was FOUNDED on questioning the wrong headed beliefs of the past! The Gurus questioned these beliefs and by you should do exactly the same. That is what a Sikh is, a student, a learner, it is your job to continually question and ponder the greater questions of life!
> and since guru ji is all
>Truth this is true, Sikhi is the only way to Saachkhand.
Each Guru was just another form of the same spirit correct? Meaning they all had the same message, just packaged a bit differently for the times and then in one volume at the end (Guru Granth Shaib). If I am not mistaken the Guru Granth Shaib also stresses those three things.
Following what Guru Nanak said, does not make you any less of a Sikh.
__taken directly fromwww.akj.org said:__
>Seva and simran did without taking Amrit will
>just make good karams and can be fruitful in giving worldly sukh... but won't help
>in anything related to mukti... Only after taking Amrit and obeying rehat and then
>being dedicated in seva and simran of true guru will help us get mukti...
Does that make any sense to you? Ask yourself for a minute if you were god and you had two people in front of you. They were identical in every which way except one took amirt and the other did not.
Both lived their lives the same way, both worked hard, both were humble, both never cheated anyone of anything, and both always shared and helped the community.
You think god would not send both to heaven?
How does that make ANY sense at all to you?
__Hara Kiri:__
>iTS LIKE SAYING YOU GOT A PHD IN SCIENCE WITHOUT GETTING THE CERTIFICATE
>FROM THE UNIVERSITY ITSELF. THEY MAY BE ABLE TO REACH HEAVEN OR WHATEVER, BUT NOT SACHKHAND
Some of the greatest scientist and mathematicians were never successful in the traditional school setting.
You don't need to have a doctorate to be a great scientist.
Re: Question
Jagroop Singh · 28 Dec 2003
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
Let's hope this doesn't turn into a very long-winded irrelevant thread...it seems to be getting nit-picky as we speak.
Sometimes it's worth just making one extensive, thought-out and Sehaj-inspired post then leaving it at that...otherwise 'timewasters' have a field day with those sincere Sikhs who wish to sincerely learn and have worthwhile Sangat with others...
Within my limited experience upon the path of Sikhi, one question that always used to plague my doubtful mind is the following:
+ On the one hand Sikhi teaches all faiths are equal yet on the other hand, The SatGuru teaches that without The SatGuru, no-one ever finds Vahiguru. How on earth do we resolve this conundrum?
It was whilst reading the English translation of one of Bhai Randhir Singh's writings (Anhad Shabad Dasam Duar - Open Discussion of Unstruck Ethereal Music at Tenth Door of Abode-Divine) that I found an insight which finally answered my question and firmly erased any doubt. Bhai Sahib's opinion placed these 'seemingly' oppositional teachings into an immediately clear perspective; a perspective which left any notion of contradiction disproved. I quote from page 46-47 of Bhai Randheer Singh's book:
"The Liberation-state of Gurmat is UNIQUE AND DIFFERENT IN CONCEPT from other religious faiths. Liberation is not the mere ending-up of the human body or just an escapement of the soul from it's bodily cage. Some envisage liberation as riddance from afflictions associated with the human body. They believe liberation is unattainable as so long as the soul is caged within the human body. Others identify liberation as the fulfillment of their desires to abide in a heavenly abode.
However, THIS KIND OF LIBERATION FALLS VERY SHORT COMPARED TO THE GURMAT CONCEPT OF LIBERATION. Liberation is not the banishment of imagined pain and sorrow, nor can it be described as the disassociation of the soul-being from materialism. Yogic faith conceives liberation as empty consciousness through meditational practices that bear no semblance to the Gurmat concept. Vedantic faith believes in the removal of duality to arrive at oneness with The Absolute, in order to be liberated. Buddhism believes liberation to be a state of total renunciation of desire and negative thought - Nirvaana. Jainism considers that non-violence and non-killing leads to liberation. Mere escape from transmigration is not the essence of True Liberation....
GURMAT CONSIDERS THE ABOVE LISTED FORMS OF LIBERATION AS HALFWAY AMD INCOMPLETE. The swan-bird GurMukhs who are blessed with Divine Enlightenment REJECT all these forms. They MERGE with The Divine Immaculate Light whilst living; they envision The Glorious Lord in full Divine Splendour.
GurMukhs are sustained by the nourishment of Naam-Divine, while they behold The Lord at all times. They find TRUE LIBERATION within this Love-Divine...
Their Liberation lies in the SOLE OCCUPATION of Naam-Devotion, in ACCORDANCE WITH GURMAT. This supreme state is reached through complete dedication, when one takes refuge within The Guru...what is not sought is a form of liberation devoid of God-Realisation."
If we use this methodology to analyse some 'mainstream' schools of thought, we may reach the following conclusions:
In Hinduistic/Vedantic tradiitons, Liberation = various states according to different schools i.e. freedom from transmigration, realisation of self as God etc.
In Buddhism, Liberation = escape from desires / realisation of the temporary nature of self / Ultimate Nothingness (shunnya) / Nirvaana.
In Judaism, Liberation = heavenly abode
In Christianity, Liberation = heavenly abode
In Islam, Liberation = heavenly abode
In Sikhi, Liberation = The merging of atma (soul) into ParAtma (Universal Soul) - all of which can only be achieved through complete dedication to (and APPLICATION of) The SatGuru's Teachings.
This murakh would say that the lesson he learnt was YES - all paths lead to The One; but NO - not every concept of The One/God or Liberation is the same. This is because, and here we reach the crux of the issue, not all paths are the same.
The concept of equality exemplified by Sikhi (i.e. all religions lead to The One) is not the result of a debate concerning which paths are more (or less) efficient and ultimately productive; equality is not based upon such rational discussions or 'language games'. The Sikhi concept of equality is an inward and outward acceptance of all, which results directly from the practice of Siree Guru Granth Sahib Jee's Teachings.
It is with the SatGuru's Grace (The Ultimate Beneficience), and not any other efforts, that we reach SachKhand and are absorbed within Vahiguru - this is the GurSikh's Heaven / Liberation / Mukhti / Nirvaana / Shunnya etc.
As for whether any other practices (aside from THE IMPLEMENTATION of Guru Sahib's Teachings) can take us there: Guru Sahib makes this clear in Japji Sahib. Acts of charity, philanthropy, pilgrimages, austerities, prayers, meditation etc. are all fruitless in search of The Ultimate Truth...
Devoid of Naam (The True Practice, Love and Submission), they are useless or bring only very little merit. Naam is The Philosopher's Stone that turns all these relatively worthless practices into Gold...just as only a positive numeral (e.g. 1) can make many zeros (e.g. 000,000) into something positive (e.g. 1,000,000), so only Naam brings us forward in the Purest Spiritual Sense.
Without Amrit we are unable to establish the GurSikh relationship...we have not offered our mind, soul and body to the Guru - we have not accepted formally the codes which should govern the Gursikh's conduct; sadly until that Blessed Day we are Nir-Gur: without The Guru (as i currently am).
Hence, The Fountain of Naam Guru Nanak Sahib, who received Naam directly from Nirankaar and brought it to Earth, has been referred to as The Greatest, who in this Dark Age protects one's Honour' i.e. brings Supreme Honour (Enlightenment) to the GurMukhs.
Could i also take this opportunity to humbly respond to some other points raised earlier in this thread:
--- ...what happens to babies who are killed other people who are never exposed to sikhi?... ---
--- Ask those Sikhs who died in 1984, they had true love for the Guru in delhi... ---
---...then why did God make me sikh? he did for a reason but my reason is not to reach sachkhand...I dont think im special in anyway if sikhi is the only way to reach Sachkhand I think Guru ji has wasted a Sikh life giving it to me...---
Here we are attempting to directly and indirectly decipher Vahiguru's Will - what can we say about that? Who apart from The One can we ask? imho these points do not move this debate forward. Unless we personally have PERFECT KNOWLEDGE of Karams of individual souls and UNDERSTAND (!!!) Vahiguru's Perfect Hukam etc., how can we answer or in fact even CONSIDER these points; what do WE of these things? i imagine that The GurSikh takes nothing from such conversations...?
Somone else wrote:
--- I said to reach heaven following the teachings of Guru Nanak should be enough. Are you implying that following the teachings of Guru Nanak makes you a Hindu? (not making a straw-man here, just want to know if I am interpreting this person correctly) ---
Guru Sahib's teachings have been summed-up with these three major components of Spiritual Life and rightly so - they elucidate and make plain Sikhi; however, let's not use them to negate everything else Guru Sahib teaches or promotes e.g. Rehat : What the Gursikh practices in order to please Vahiguru, as an expression of their undying Love and respect, should not be downplayed e.g. someone may laugh at me/you for wearing our Kacchera while bathing; they may see it as a ritual act which serves no purpose - that is up to them and their opinion...
Personally, we may feel that by keeping our Panj Kakkar on our person at all times expresses how we feel about Guru Sahib's Gifts...perhaps they are so dear to us that we cannot be without them even for a moment; regardless of what others think.
Also there seems to be some confusion...in response to a statement about the importance of Amrit the same person wrote:
--- Does that make any sense to you? Ask yourself for a minute if you were god and you had two people in front of you. They were identical in every which way except one took amirt and the other did not. Both lived their lives the same way, both worked hard, both were humble, both never cheated anyone of anything, and both always shared and helped the community. You think god would not send both to heaven?How does that make ANY sense at all to you? ---
This response is simply out of context...ofcourse JUST by taking Amrit, we do not become Enlightened (aside from issues regarding previous Karams)...it is by the HEARTFELT, APPROPRIATE and CONSTANT APPLICATION of Gurmat that one reaches Vahiguru.
Can i say in closing that i firmly believe that Bhai Randhir Singh's response makes clear the following and hence sheds light upon this debate and imho concludes the whole debate:
i) Different paths aim to achieve different things.
ii) The Gurmukh, upon The Gurmat Path, aims to ACHIEVE the VERY THING the path leads to: Vahiguru.
iii) Any Spiritual Objective devoid of God-Vahiguru Realisation is not The True Enlightenment.
Bhul chuk maaf karna.
ps. this murakh will not be adding any further because to do so would only encourage his ego.
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
Re: Question
Kulbir Singh · 29 Dec 2003
Thank you so much Veer Jagroop Singh jeeo for posting an extract from Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee's book - Anhad Shabad Dasam Duaar.
What a great book this is! No one has written on this subject (Dasam Duaar and Anhad Shabad) other than Bhai Sahib. Guru Sahib took this sewa from Bhai Sahib only (Other than Bhai Gurdas jee, of course).
I think we should have no doubt left, after reading the post of Bhai Jagroop Singh jee. All paths other than Sikhi are incomplete. They don't go all the way to Vaheguru.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh