Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

is AKJ Arya Samaj of Sikhs

is AKJ Arya Samaj of Sikhs

E · 11 May 2006

Many scholars refer to (as opposed to Jatha/missionaries etc) Sants, Taksaalis, Nirmalas etc as Sanatani Sikhs for following old ritulistic maryadas. Do you think that in contrast AKJ Singhs are Arya Samajis of Sikhs ? Any thoughts.

Re: is AKJ Arya Samaj of Sikhs

Singh · 12 May 2006

Many people who criticize Jatha are not sure what it is. Some people call them Brahmins, Hindus, some say they are a cult, others may say they are British influenced, others say they are Arya Samajis. However you see AKJ, the fact is, it is one of the largest (if not the largest) Amritdhari organisations/Jatha's on an international level dedicated to the spiritual side of Sikhism - Naam Simran, Keertan, etc.

Re: is AKJ Arya Samaj of Sikhs

sarbloh · 13 May 2006

This is so bad.I am not from akj.But I find akj so good,especially this site with people like kulbir singh ji,daas soora ji.

Re: is AKJ Arya Samaj of Sikhs

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 May 2006

Whatever... they have the most Tatt gurmatt...of any Jatha..and the LEAST Brahminism...

Re: is AKJ Arya Samaj of Sikhs

LK · 14 May 2006

I though Kulbir Singh ji and co were all Sikhs first and then AKJist..but i could be wrong.

Re: is AKJ Arya Samaj of Sikhs

Sardar · 14 May 2006

isn't AKJ a strict version of SGPC?

Re: is AKJ Arya Samaj of Sikhs

Disagree · 15 May 2006

If you read Bhai Randhir Singh's books you will see that the views propagated are very different to the comparatively British-influenced SGPC. Kala Afgana-type scholars have even referred to Bhai Randhir Singh's books as "Brahminical Granths".

Re: is AKJ Arya Samaj of Sikhs

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 May 2006

yes KA is anti Bhai Sahib Ji..and so is Santaan de kautak writer Sbhraa...people are entitled to their views... its ok by me Everybody is a SIKH FIRST..then Jatha....if anyone puts Jatha first..he is WRONG...

Re: is AKJ Arya Samaj of Sikhs

I Singh · 15 May 2006

Vijaydeep Singh Jee, Gurmat is not closer to the semitic faiths. Sikhism is an eastern based faith like Buddhism, Hinduism, Jainism. Just because we look like the semites does not mean our theology is close to theirs. Anyway, in my opinion AKJ is an offshoot from the Singh Sabha leher, but they also follow puraatan rehets like promoting colour blue, Bana, Sarbloh Babek etc that you find in puraatan Nihang groups.

Re: is AKJ Arya Samaj of Sikhs

Balwant Rao · 17 May 2006

the ony racist is you Vijaydeep Hinduism covers all manners of beleif from the Vedantic concepts to Arya Samaj you great pride in being banded with Islam and Christianity and talking of 'their God' and 'our God' is a true representation of monotheistic fascism which in reality reflects duality i.e Good and Evil, them and us. beleivers and non beleviers you need to read more than 19th century British authors and talking about 'Hindoos' and 'Siques' and 'Muhamadons'