Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Laser eye treatment?

Laser eye treatment?

my name · 13 May 2006

Is laser eye treatment ok with gurmat? id like to hear the views of gurmukhs like bhai sahib kulbir singh ji and bhai sahib bhupinder singh daas ji.

Re: Laser eye treatment?

Sikh of the True Guru · 16 May 2006

I think it is as good as any surgery to correct something wrong in the body. As long as it does not alter the normal body to suit our own tastes or for ego.

Re: Laser eye treatment?

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 16 May 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VAheguruJeeKeeFateh As a overall answer it is against Gurmat, but I don't know the pain you're going through, so whatever you do is upto you at the end. Although my view on this is that the physical form given to us is one that cannot be changed, only if Vaheguru Jee changes it for us. We have to learn to accept Hukam, and move on; forget about the lack of sight. This is similar to a story in Guru Jee's time, as a old person in Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee's time was blind, and wished to have Guru JEe's darshan for so long, but then one day Guru Jee met him and cured this blindness and after the old man had his darshan he asked if Guru JEe could stay with him, but because Guru Jee couldn't the old man asked to be blind again, as he didn't wish to see anyone else in the world, but to remember Guru Jee's darshan; the only person he laid his eyes on. Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee left with a tear in his eye and a hug from the old man. You may argue that Guru Jee at the time was there to cure such people, but remember that he didn't cure everyone but just the chosen that had most love for him. You may also argue that no one had technology at the time that could do such things, but there is also such technolgy that can change the physical form such as plastic surgery. So, if one goes for a laser treatment it then means nothing is wrong with plastic surgery. It is all about accepting Hukam and japping Naam, which can help one move on. Think about one darshan and only one, Vaheguru Jee's darshan. This life is only a dream, and will last for a short time and will then end. The reality is in the next world, not this. Do everything you can to help the next world, not this world. Finally, it's upto you, but I also had a problem, but I accepted it and moved on by japping naam and realising divine Hukam. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VAheguruJeeKeeFateh

Re: Laser eye treatment?

r · 16 May 2006

well its like an operation, but it shoudlnt go agasint gumat, beacuse no hair is cut.

Re: Laser eye treatment?

singh · 16 May 2006

It's anti gurmat. God's nmature. Accept Gods will!

Re: Laser eye treatment?

Ranjit Singh · 16 May 2006

As far as I know, there is nothing anti gurmat about laser eye surgery. It's a medical procedure, not simply a cosmetic one, so it isn't the same as plastic surgery. We wear glasses, which is also a corrective procedure. Our Guru's didn't prohibit us from getting medical treatment. In fact, Guru Har Rai Saahib Jee had one of the largest dispensaries in India. Of course, if someone has enough faith and rely only on Naam, that's great. But someone who chooses to get a medical procedure, like laser eye surgery, is not acting against gurmat.

Re: Laser eye treatment?

my name · 16 May 2006

thanks loads for replying, i dont think i will do it.

Re: Laser eye treatment?

some12 · 16 May 2006

hahahahaha laser eye surgery anti gurmat? jeez do u guys not wear glasses? accepts gods will and walk around blind. i dare u 2 goto a blind gur-sikh who has the choice of gaining his vision back and saying, ur a tankha cause u want 2 see again. like jeez

Re: Laser eye treatment?

jsut a thought · 16 May 2006

if god wills it then isn't doing the laser eys surgery ok, becuase god is directing you to do it by putting the thought in your head and then if you act on it or not that is gods will not yours., other wise if god didn't want it then you would not have thought of getting laser eye surgery. Dosen't god give everyone a destiney maybe getting laser eye surgey is one step on the path to your destiny that god has put out for you. Just a thought to think. VAheguru Ji works in mysterious ways us mere mortals can't claim to know what gods will is.

Re: Laser eye treatment?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 May 2006

treat blindness as a blessing....you will be forced to memorise gurbani...lols.. and that cant be all bad... and you cant see all that bad tv shows...or read nindiya of sants...and if you go deaf..wow all the better..you wont be able to hear nindiya ( of sants especially)

Re: Laser eye treatment?

a · 17 May 2006

well wat are u trying to achieve by not wearing glasses? basically you want to look good which is the same as putting makeup on. image changing is anti gurmat

Re: Laser eye treatment?

singhani · 17 May 2006

i think its ok... im gonna hav it done when im a bit older... definately need it! cant even see the screen up in rehnsbhaaees cos im that blind! dont think theres anythin wrong with it as ur not commitin a kurehit or anythin... i dunno maybe you should ask an older gursikh in ur area or ur panj pyaaraay.

Re: Laser eye treatment?

Jasmin · 17 May 2006

Maybe I'm just missing something here but I really don't see any controversy. Its done for vision, not looks, kes is not removed. How is wrong to want to fuction and see better? Sure you could wear glasses. Personal I like contacts because, you get peripheral vision, and more comfortable then always having to wear glasses all the time. btw how do glasses work with dastar maybe a little awkward? In any case, sure you can ask about it.

Re: Laser eye treatment?

sg · 17 May 2006

im gettin it done soon and some ppl said wear glasses, i do right now i need to get it done for police, as they dont accept glasses/contact lenses.

Re: Laser eye treatment?

uuu · 18 May 2006

what if a singh had to go into jung he couldn't carry his glasses out there would it be ok to get laser eye surgery in such a case

Re: Laser eye treatment?

PTE SINGH · 18 May 2006

I think if you're gonna ask such silly questions then you deserve the kind of silly answers you got, and it shows you do not have the necessary cerebral capacity to make a decision like this. I’ve had the laser surgery done, had braces as a child and a number of fillings, in fact I used some ear drops yesterday. I may as well cut my Kesh, stop japing Naam and quit Gatka seeing as I’m going to hell now anyway…?? [%sig%]

Re: Laser eye treatment?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 May 2006

i have been wearing glasses since age 20....( anti gurmatt ??)...and now have been advised to go for laser surgery to remove cataract in one eye....(anti-Gurmatt)..no. Wearing glasses to correct vision is NOT anti gurmatt and having cataract removal is NOT anti Gurmatt either.. a lot of jeewan waleh singhs can be seen wearing glasses...are they all anti guramtt ??i think not.

Re: Laser eye treatment?

tableji · 22 May 2006

hahaha, in that case, dont ever go to a doctor, or the hospital when u are ill. dont take medicine to cure ur illness as it is altering the way god made u also dont eat, because that also alters ur physical parameters. dont train, because that also changes ur body, dont study because u were made to be stupid. Fateh ji

Re: Laser eye treatment?

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 22 May 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeekEeFAteh Children, whatever you want to do is upto you. Whos stoping you; is it a sin? No, stop crying about it and do what you like KIDS. Use your own head; if you think its going to make your life easier good on you. But remember your life can become harder as well. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeekEeFAteh