Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Kirpan Size

Kirpan Size

Kirpan · 04 Jan 2004

Does kirpaan size matter and why???!!! As long as you dont have a kirpan placed around your neck, then i think its fine. i got my kirpan from sri hazur sahib couple years back, and its kind of small, not that small, dont know how many inches, haven't measured it

Re: Kirpan Size

charandaasi · 04 Jan 2004

The minimum requirement length of a Kirpaan is 9 inches. I dont know why though. The kirpaan in the neck is just pure manmat. If you were to defend yourself, how would you do it with a kirpaan thats like 3 centimetres long? think about it.

Re: Kirpan Size

PaKi MoNsTeR · 04 Jan 2004

I think this discussion was held b4.

Re: Kirpan Size

Surrey Singh · 04 Jan 2004

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH i posted the following a couple of monthes ago, and thought i would put it up again for a response to this question.... <>> WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH [%sig%]

Re: Kirpan Size

Kirpan · 04 Jan 2004

no i said the kirpan was manmat, read my post my kirpans not that small lolz

Re: Kirpan Size

Trying to be Gursikh · 05 Jan 2004

Talking about people wearing Kirpans around their necks, I've seen people with mini kangas, what next mini versions of kacheras and karas.

Re: Kirpan Size

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 05 Jan 2004

tha's nanaksaar rehit, all came after dhun baba isher singh ji i'm imagining next is a lock of hair representing kesh

Re: Kirpan Size

woooooooooo! · 05 Jan 2004

Vaaheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaaheguroo Ji Ki Fateh, I just wanted to say that i wear a little kirpan and kanga around my neck, but these are not a replacement for my actual Kakars. I know people say why bother this that and the other, but they mean a lot to me. By wearing them I don't feel like I'm loosing anything and don't see what I will gain from not wearing them. Peace Vaaheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaaheguroo Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Kirpan Size

- · 05 Jan 2004

but whats the point of wearing htem? THey cant be used as shastars so they turn into mere show pieces then, and that is not gurmat

Re: Kirpan Size

Sarbloh Badman · 06 Jan 2004

its obvious that all the kakkars are totally practical. like 100percent. so i dont see why u would want to have mini versions or versions round ur neck. yes u wont gain anything by removing them but what will u gain by having them? lol i can just imagine a little diddy pair of kachere, maybe it might become a fashion item with the monneh LOL, mini silk kashereh round their neck next to their ikkle gold khandas hahahaha it annoys me how all the kakkars have got smaller. keski shorter, kangha smaller, skinnier karra, titchier kirpan, tiny tight kachereh :( :( :( ....... i bet in gurujis time all of them were masssivvvvvve

Re: Kirpan Size

narsingha · 06 Jan 2004

kirpan size has been discussed already, check the archives of this very phorum.

Re: Kirpan Size

s · 24 Mar 2004

Considering that none of us, NONE of us, are wearing a kirpan as ordered by Guru ji, I think limitations on the size of the imitations we do wear are pointless. The only limitation should be, is it effective - can u use it to defend yourself. A knife doesn't need a nine-inch blade to be effective. A 6 inch, 5 inch, even 4 inch blade on a kirpan can be extremely effective if it's designed to be a real, genuine weapon - much more effective than the 9 inch, 10 inch, 12 inch hunks of metal most of us wear aka taksali kirpans. You have to realize, kirpan in the context Guru ji ordered us to wear it in, means a full-length sword. What we are wearing are more kards than kirpans. If you want to follow Guru ji's hukum to the word, the way it was intended then you MUST wear a full-length sword. Short history: British outlaw kirpans (the 3 to 4 foot ones). Sikhs protest. Sikhs protest. Sikhs protest. Finally, Britain allows Sikhs to wear kirpan but restricted in size - 6 inches i think. Most everyone starts wearing the smaller kirpans as they are better than not wearing a kakkar at all. Some time passes, and the British remove the size restriction on the kirpan. The Sikhs are so used to and comfortable with the smaller kards, they don't go back to the full-sized kirpans. So basically, there are very few Sikhs (exception being some Singhs in India) who are obeying Guru ji's hukum. Instead, we wear our imitation kirpans (no more than knives or daggers in reality) and pretend we're the most 'hardcorest' of the 'hardcorest'. We're all pretenders to one degree or another especially when it comes to kirpans. daas [%sig%]