Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Singh · 05 Apr 2004

Looking at the Toronto Star's report of the arrival of Sree Guru Granth Sahib, I realised that there's a fine line between respect and idol worship. Guru jee deserves our respect, but to treat the saroops like "weary travellers" is totally wrong. Guru Sahib does not need blankets or a "time to rest", or be taken on walks or bathed or given food. Some people argue that Guru Sahib even in human form didnt' need anything. But here's the thing: in human form, there are certain things you can do for a human body. A human body indeed needs food and rest and blankets to keep warm. But now that Guru jee is in the form of a Granth, the needs are no longer those of a human. We now have to make sure that the angs are turned with respect so as not to rip, and the binding is treated carefully so as not to get damaged. When we start going overboard with blankets and food etc. it doesn't remain respect, it becomes idol worship.

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Singh1 · 05 Apr 2004

Singh, dont mean to sound rude, but I think your also not realizing that Guru Granth Sahib actually is the eternal and LIVING Sikh guru. Now i realise you can say "how can a book be living etc..." what makes Guru Granth Sahib living is the fact that Gurus Joyt now resides within Guru Granth Sahib this is what makes the Saroop living. whyichoosesikhism i think effectively deals with the idol worship suggestion so have a read of that. Vaaheguroo jee kaa khalsa, vaaheguroo jee kee fateh!

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Singh · 05 Apr 2004

I agree that Guru Granth Sahib is the "living guru", but that doesn't mean Guru Sahib is human. Guru Sahib does not need to eat, sleep or go to the bathroom. Also Guru Sahib doesn't feel hot in the summer or get cold in the winter. I agree that we should matha tek, and put Guru Sahib in a takhat and that chaur sahib is all appropriate, but to treat Guru Sahib like a human being is just idol worship. I know certain sants will "rest" guru sahib after an akhand paath sahib and some idiots have gone so far as wrapping guru sahib in plastic and then bathing the saroop. Perhaps the biggest idol worship is if we bow to Guru Sahib without having ever bothered to know what they are saying to us.

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Singh · 05 Apr 2004

Here are some quotes from the newspapers about the arrival of the Saroops that just made me cringe. Toronto Star: There, they were placed on six beds and tucked beneath covers of crimson and gold brocade. They'd earned the rest. "It's a person, not a book," said T. Sher Singh, a Guelph lawyer schooled in Sikh history. "This is the teacher. It is the living word that is venerated and followed." "To be part of this history is very overwhelming," said Sujinder Kaur Auluck, 25. "We see each book as an actual living person." _________ CBC: "We don't pray to anyone in particular , so to us, the holy scriptures are our God. They are our church. They signify our temple. They espouse all of our values and ideals," she said. _____________ Globe and Mail: The 1,430-page scriptures are written in Gurmukhi and contain devotional hymns and poetry, as well as ethical rules for spiritual salvation and unity with God. There are also passages from Islam and Hinduism, the dominant religions in India.

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

M4A1 assault rifle · 05 Apr 2004

Our Guru is living, our Guru is jot saroop. Whatever seva we do is a humble offering by a servant. Guru Nanak Dev Jee used to come in human form to eat parshada offered by Baba Nand Singh. Baba Nand Singh Jee's sharda cannot be described in words. Sharda is the mother of bhagti. Going by the logic above, there is no point in doing Sukhasan dee seva. Why do they not have Guru Jee parkash all day and all night? Matha Teking to Guru Granth Sahib Jee = reading bani!!

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Singh · 05 Apr 2004

So we do sukhasan because Guru Sahib needs rest and we put Guru Sahib to sleep? Is that why we do sukhasan? The reason we do sukhasan is because at night there is no one in hazoori of Guru jee and no one is going to have a divan or read bani from Guru jee. For this reason it makes sense to do sukhasan. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying no respect should be given and Guru Sahib should be treated like a book. I'm not saying that at all. I'm saying that giving HUMAN qualities to Guru Granth Sahib ie. hunger, fatigue, etc. is not sensible. Trying to fulfil human needs for the saroop is pointless. The greatest respect we can give though, is to read Guru jee and adopt those lessons in our own life.

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

mr singh · 05 Apr 2004

what i seem to be getting from your points, is that.... sri guru granth saahib jee indeed contains the jot and is the body or 'deh' of our guru... but, this deh is different in form than it was when the jot was in a human body... therefore we should still show complete respect, but that respect should take into consideration that the 'deh' we are dealing with is different and has different needs than the human deh the jot previously occupied... ie, this deh has no need for physical food, for a bathroom, for sleep, and isn't effected by moderate cold or heat.... but this deh, unlike the human form, will be badly affected by say, water (bathing) so this isn't done to it. same jot, still just as alive as it always has been and will be, but a different body with different bodily needs... Do I understand you correctly?

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Mkhalsa · 06 Apr 2004

Lets compare the different bodies or roops of guru sahib. Human body: Guru sahib had food, water bath to clean, slept in order to gain energy Guru Granth Sahib: Guru sahib does not need food, but if a saroop gets very old, new ink or binding replacement may be in order, in order to clean one uses mal mal cloth during akhand patt to clean the dust off of each ang as common sense dictates that the bani is guru and if we got guru sahib wet we would be washing the ink off and damaging the saroop! Guru sahib does not need sleep as he is available at all times and does not move therefore does not need to regain strength through sleep. I think one needs to follow common sense of what seva we can do for guru sahib and what seva we cannot do any longer.

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

M4A1 assault rifle · 06 Apr 2004

"I think one needs to follow common sense of what seva we can do for guru sahib and what seva we cannot do any longer." I think we should leave it up to Guru Sahib to decide what seva is acceptable or not.

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Singhani · 07 Apr 2004

Why do we do Karah Parsaad Da Bhog before giving it to the Sangat if we do not believe Guru Ji accepts it, is this also a ritual? Singh, you're missing the point, as a Veer said, Sharda is not defined by logic.

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Singh · 07 Apr 2004

I dont' know. I remain convinced that "seva" such as wrapping Guru Sahib in plastic and "bathing" the saroop make NO sense. Same with air conditioners and heaters and blankets. If we're going to "let Guru Sahib decide" what seva is acceptable and not use our own budhi, then lets go all the way shall we? Let's leave a thaal filled with Langar for Guru Sahib, and lets take Guru Sahib for walks and time in the sun. All the above things are actually done by some samparda sants. I just wish everyone would put as much effort in reading the bani as doing all these physical acts. Bhog for degh is a very old tradition in the Panth. It is a very symbolic act. Putting blankets and treating a saroop like its tired after a ran sabaaee or an akhand paath sahib is a new Brahministic practice we learned from the Hindu idol worshippers. Now that I'm on a roll, why not come out with other stuff that disturbs me: Guru Sahib stressed simplicity. So why then do we put rumallas of every gaudy and flashy colour? Bright green and pink laced with golden ribbons etc. All this takes away from a spiritual atmosphere. Even Gurdwaras that put up party decorations in the hall: what is that all about??? Keep it elegant and simple. Again, I repeat: I support respecting Guru Sahib. But treating Guru Sahib like a "human" makes no sense. And doing things Guru Sahib would not approve of like flashy rumallaas also makes no sense to me. Would Guru Gobind Singh jee wear clothes made of those fabrics and colours? No? Then why put it on Guru Sahib now?

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

jagroop singh · 07 Apr 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, Instead of having heaters for Guru Sahib, who does not need them, why not spend the money on a dehumidifier which would perhaps preserve the pages...much better Seva. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Another View · 07 Apr 2004

There was once a story about Baba Harnaam Singh he left a sevadaar to do sukhasan. The sevadaar did the evening seva very fast and without alot of respect. In the morning Baba jee had the darshan of Guru Arjan dev jee and his eyes were all red. Baba jee asked what was wrong. Guru jee said that the sevadaar did the sevaa very fast so the white rumalas had a lot of wrinkles in them, therefore Guru jee could not sleep proplerly. So Guru Granth Sahib is the body of Guru jee. Guru Arjan dev jee himself took Guru Granth Sahib to a place of rest at Harimandar Sahib. The dohra we read after ardaas says"Guru granth jee manyo, pargat guraa kee deh". When Guru was in human form he did not need food or water either, he was beyond that. But the sangat did sevaa anyway because it was an expression of there love for Guru Jee.

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Singh · 07 Apr 2004

>>>>>>>> Some people argue that Guru Sahib even in human form didnt' need anything. But here's the thing: in human form, there are certain things you can do for a human body. A human body indeed needs food and rest and blankets to keep warm. But now that Guru jee is in the form of a Granth, the needs are no longer those of a human. We now have to make sure that the angs are turned with respect so as not to rip, and the binding is treated carefully so as not to get damaged. >>>>>>>>

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

??? · 07 Apr 2004

The Bhog question is a good one, because I've seen this done amongst the Devi goddess-worshipping Rajputs (using anything form a Kirpan type implement to a a Khanda) in their Halwa. This practice pre-dates Sikhi in some ways and is unique amongst the Devi Cults of India, how it came to be a custom wihtin Sikhi is explained by various people in various ways from Nihangs adopting this from the Rajputs on account of being warriors to Guru Gobind Singh giving his blessings through the touch of a weapon (shastr) rather than touch (same way he replaced charan-amrit with khanda amrit)... ...any thoughts?

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Mkhalsa · 07 Apr 2004

>>>>>So why then do we put rumallas of every gaudy and flashy colour? Bright green and pink laced with golden ribbons etc. All this takes away from a spiritual atmosphere. Even Gurdwaras that put up party decorations in the hall: what is that all about??? Keep it elegant and simple. Again, I repeat: I support respecting Guru Sahib. But treating Guru Sahib like a "human" makes no sense. And doing things Guru Sahib would not approve of like flashy rumallaas also makes no sense to me. Would Guru Gobind Singh jee wear clothes made of those fabrics and colours? No? Then why put it on Guru Sahib now?<<<<< I know!! Can you imagine Guru Gobind Singh Jee on his horse leading an army wearing a pink chola with sequins and a big pink bunga?! Why do we dress guru granth sahib jee in such stuff then?

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

M4A1 · 07 Apr 2004

Guru Granth Sahib gets their seva done by their servants. Not everyone can be a true servant. One of the conditions of being a true servant is to be dead while living. Guru Sahib would accept a chola if it was offered with sharda. There is a sakhi of when Guru Jee went to a bibis house to accept a chola that was sewn for them. Guru Granth Sahib is the king of kings. They deserve the most fanciest rumalleys there are.

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Singh · 07 Apr 2004

Am I alone in believing that Sikhism stresses simplicity?? Fancy Rumallas are not wanted or needed by Guru Sahib. Guru Sahib tells his Khalsa to avoid jewellery, be simple, wear only simple colours, yet himself would want "fancy" stuff? Our "King" is not like the false "Kings" out there. That's why we love Guru Sahib so much. If we make our "King" just like the others, then what makes us any different than the rest of the world? Guru Sahib has shown a unique way...so why try to mix it back with the world again?

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

s!nghn! · 07 Apr 2004

Often, the rumaalaas offered aren't just too fancy and flashy, but they're TACKY and just plain UGLY. The simplicity of plain white rumaalaas can't be beat. They look elegant and are a much more courtly dress for Guru Sahib rather than fancy silks and gold borders etc. And "M4A1", offering a cholaa isn't exactly comparable to the flashy rumaalaas offered today.

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

Kaur · 10 Apr 2004

Fateh Jee I was having this discussion (/argument) with someone recently who disagreed with the idea of thick rumaals and they sed that if Guru Ji got cold, then taking it one step further, you could equally say that Guru Ji may get a headache, so you could put paracetamol tablets under Guru Sahib! Now that to me is completely wrong and it may be a silly example, but it does go to show that many of us don't really know WHY we do things - it's often not out of respect, but out of ignorance. But to be honest, why are we arguing about it? If someone uses an extra rumaal and honestly believes that this is showing full respect, then to me, well, that's ok. It's when we get obsessed with this rather than obsessed with the Naam Baani that Guru Ji gives us, that we start to go wrong! Ok - end of my babbling Bhul chuk maaf

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

wow · 12 Apr 2004

whats................"M4A1",?????

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

P.Singh · 12 Apr 2004

Alot of this stuff has got to stop (like taking Guru Ji for walks). Our Gurus can travel anywhere in the universe in not even a blink of the eye, so what is the use of this?

Re: SGGS: Respect vs. Idol Worship

unknown · 14 Apr 2004

I think we need to learn how to do seva from someone Like Baba Nand Singh Jee. Once during a holy conversation, father was holding with venerable Baba Isher Singh Ji in praise and glory of Mahan Baba Nand Singh Ji Maharaj, Baba Isher Singh Ji narrated a personal experience of his own to us. There were number of other devotees also present. Baba Nand Singh Ji Maharaj was once busy in the holy service of Sri Guru Granth Sahib. It was time for the Holy Scripture to be closed for rest. Baba Isher Singh Ji who was standing there, was watching Mahan Babaji with a fixed gaze, thinking all the time of total merger of Babaji with His most adorable, lovable, worshipful Lord Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Mahan Baba Nand Singh Ji Maharaj, just at that time, in a most compassionate and divine mood looked at Baba Isher Singh Ji and in His ecstatic characteristic humility kept His forehead on the open Sri Guru Granth Sahib, with all reverence. No sooner He did this, He disappeared physically in the holy folds and lap of Sri Guru Granth Sahib. As Babaji did not reappear from the holy Sri Guru Granth Sahib for some time, venerable Baba Isher Singh Ji got worried and started praying to Babaji to kindly return from the Holy source of His merger. Baba Nand Singh Ji Maharaj reappeared from Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Esteemed Baba Isher Singh Ji then added that all this he saw with his own physical eyes with the Grace of Mahan Baba Nand Singh Ji Maharaj. He saw physical merger of the great Worshipper and the Worshipped Lord into one entity and then physical emergence of Baba Nand Singh Ji Maharaj again as a separate entity apparently for the redemption of mankind. Baba Nand Singh Ji Maharaj, had disappeared bodily into the divine bosom of Sri Guru Granth Sahib; he had physically disappeared into the splendour and glory of all pervading Parbrahm Guru Nanak, and had re-merged as the blazing Sun of Divinity from His Supreme Abode and divine source that Sri Guru Granth Sahib is.