Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bibek

Bibek

bibek singh · 12 Apr 2004

The requirements for my employment require me to occasionally be outside in the night for some hours at a time. It gets very cold. However, there is a Sardar and his family that live down the street my workplace. One day the Sardar saw me and he came outside and brought me warm milk. I could have either accepted and drank the milk, appreciating that he warmed the milk up and came outside just for me...or i could have nicely refused it because of my bibek. My question is, should i have turn this man away or should i have drank the milk? Should i not break my bibek for anyone, even after he got up to help a fellow Gursikh in need?

Re: Bibek

no · 12 Apr 2004

This man has made this garam dood with such pyaar that you musnt refuse. Not in any way! Bhai Sahib Rama Jee once said the same thing when they had a keertan program at a non-amritdhari/non-sarbhlohee's house and when it was time for langar bhai sahib sat right their and ate the langar and he was angered at those singhs who got up because it wasnt bibeki. He said that it was made with such pyaar that you musny refuse.

Re: Bibek

Singh · 12 Apr 2004

Vaaheguru jee ka khalsa vaaaheguru jee kee fateh! I personally would have declined it but in a very nice way. I would have taken the time to explain bebek and why gursikhs keep it and then try to spark a nice conversatoin about sikhi or something. Usually most people have respect for bebek and understand once you explain to them why. A lot of people have more respect for you afterwards, and also your doing parchaar of bebek since now that sardaar knows that this is a rehit of khalsa. Ive run into this situation myself a few times and so far Guru SAhib has done kirpa.

Re: Bibek

Mohan Singh · 12 Apr 2004

Im not bibeki (or Amritdhari) but I hope to be in the future, and Im not exactly sure how one could explain bibek to a non Amritdhari/mona who has just offered you food without offending them. I personally would not take offence as I understand, but for your average monnah, telling them that you dont want their food because its jhooth (lol) is going to have to be put in quite a blunt way. Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Bibek

Kulbir Singh · 13 Apr 2004

--------- My question is, should i have turn this man away or should i have drank the milk? ---------- I concur with "Singh". I too would have declined milk boiled by this benevalent Sardar jee but would have done it politely. It is not right to be blunt in such cases. This Sardar jee prepared milk with pyaar and as such he should not have been snubbed. ------- Should i not break my bibek for anyone, even after he got up to help a fellow Gursikh in need? ------------ For a gursikh, the foremost priority is Guru Sahib's rehit and obeying Guru Sahib's hukams. In Gurbani, Guru Sahib has instructed us to keep bibek i.e. associate with devotees only. Guru Sahib has not written any exceptions; therefore, we should not assume any exceptions like "food cooked with love", etc. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bibek

ns · 19 Apr 2004

Here we go again another one on bibek. I thought I just mention a popluar saki of Guru Hargobind Singh Ji. A bibi wanted darshan of Guru Ji , hence Guru Ji got on his horse with his sikhs went to see this bibi. Upon darshan the bibi offered food for Guru Ji to eat, and Guru Ji had food from the bibi. The Sikhs along with Guru Ji at the time thought maybe Guru Ji gets hungry when he is out, so next time they decided to keep some food with them. Afterf a couple of days Guru Ji went out with the Sikhs somewhere, after a couple of hours the Sikhs asked Guru Ji, if he was hungry and if so they have food with them. Guru Ji smiled and said "no, how can I eat without the sadh sangat, I will only eat with sadh sangat." .Then the Sikhs questioned why did you eat food offerred from the bibi the other day, that was not with the sadh sangat. Guru Ji replied "that was a situation where preet had overcome reet, the bibi had so much pyar, and it had overcome the normal reet." So therefore I feel Bhai Rama Singh Jee above was indeed correct and the other sikhs should've eaten langar as it was prepared with so much pyar, afterall it was this pyar for Gursikhs which prompted them to invite Gursikhs in the first place.How else are you going to bring the world into the fold of the KHALSA ? Don't get me wrong, I have respect for Sikhs who follow bibek and the ones that I know, never even go into explaining it in the way it is done on this forum. I'm sure and certain that some people will say this is another flawed sakki, just like it was mentioned the sakki about Ganga saagar is also flawed. I would like to say then how come the miracle from Ganga saagar which we see today it only holds milk, how do you explain that, would you say that Guru Ji's kala is also falwed. How far do you have to go with this debate? for ever? bhul chuk maaf Narinder

Re: Bibek

A Singh · 19 Apr 2004

Interesting points Narinder Jee. Dear forum and particularly "Kulbir Singh" and "Singh", if indeed Narinder's post is flawed and moreover as you say, "foremost priority is Guru Sahib's rehit and obeying Guru Sahib's hukams. In Gurbani, Guru Sahib has instructed us to keep bibek i.e. associate with devotees only. Guru Sahib has not written any exceptions; therefore, we should not assume any exceptions" is Bhai Rama Singh wrong in his view on this matter as per the earlier post or did this not actually occur?

Re: Bibek

singhsation · 19 Apr 2004

"Bandeya, dil na dukhaa kisse banday da, bandeya vich Rab vas da" No matter what explanation you could have given, or how politely you explained your position, you would have hurt this person by rejecting what he brought you with such pyar. My questions/thoughts regarding bibek have been made elsewhere so I'l refrain from touching upon them but I do not see anything wrong in accepting that milk. If you had rejected that milk and broke this person's heart, but kept to this interpretation of sikh protocol (bibek) do you think Guru ji would have been proud of you for having done so? In my opinion, accepting the milk would be the right choice. Before someone takes this example onto the slippery slope and says what if someone offered alcohol with pyar or some other nonsense, there is a difference between such examples and the question at hand. It may be a matter of degree only, but the difference in degree is enough, in my opinion, to make all the difference in the world. - daas If you absolutely could find no way to drink this milk, you should have accepted it, dumped it somewhere out of sight, and given the glass back later. This way, you could preserve your protocol as well as not break this person's heart. This would be a dishonest approach - but dishonesty in this fashion is a better choice than breaking the person's heart. I liken this to when someone overweight asks you if they're fat - you can be honest and crush them or slightly dishonest and preserve their self-esteem.

Re: Bibek

Mohan Singh · 19 Apr 2004

Personally I am in a situation when I take amrit I will be a household where neither parents are Amritdhari but both are Kesadhari. Unfortunately having briefly discussed the issue with them neither see it as part of Rehat no matter what evidence is given and have shown very great unhappiness at the idea their son will not eat their own food. Following Bibek may lead to quite large family problems when I take Amrit what should I do? I have heard the Panj Pyare can give exceptions in some situations such as mine? Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Bibek

Singh S · 19 Apr 2004

"A Singh" Are you trying to say that Bhai Randhir SIngh Jee was wrong for keeping strict babek while in Jail for years? He could have broken his Babek to make friends, but no! for him friendship with Guru Jee was more important than any worldly friendship.

Re: Bibek

uk singh · 19 Apr 2004

Bhai Rama Singh Ji regularly ate langar prepared by non amritdharis after the morning simran programmes in Hounslow (UK)...maybe he was not a bibeki...even Jatha Singh's have witnessed this. the question that arises in my mind however is that people place so much emphasis on Degh being made by nitnemi singhs and prepared following strict maryada, but not when it comes to everyday food?

Re: Bibek

Kulbir Singh · 19 Apr 2004

---------- Interesting points Narinder Jee. --------- It is an interesting post surely. Narinder gave example of Siri Guru Har Rai jee and how Siri Guru jee ate from that bibi who had prepared langar for Guru Sahib. There are some points in this saakhi that we should not forget: 1) First of all, it is wrong to assume that this bibi who prepared langar for Siri Guru jee was not a devoted Sikh. The reality is that she was a very devoted Sikh, who used to stay absorbed in Naam all the time. She had a wish that Siri Guru jee come to her house and eat food cooked by her. It is wrong to use this saakhi to prove that bibek is not a rehit of Guru Sahib or that Siri Guru jee did not used to observe bibek. 2) It is not a rehit of Khalsa to always eat in langar. There is nothing wrong to not eat langar from Gurdwara Sahib, if you are not hungry or if you had food at home. Siri Guru jee did not eat the regular langar when he was served on horseback and said that he prefers to partake langar in the langarhall with other sangat as opposed to eating it on horseback. I don’t understand how you are using this example to prove your invalid point that Bibek was not observed by Siri Guru jee. It is wrong to say that the only way to bring people to Sikhi is to eat from them. There is no point of doing any such sewa that violates Tatt-Gurmat principles e.g. Bibek. ------------- Dear forum and particularly "Kulbir Singh" and "Singh", if indeed Narinder's post is flawed and moreover as you say, "foremost priority is Guru Sahib's rehit and obeying Guru Sahib's hukams. In Gurbani, Guru Sahib has instructed us to keep bibek i.e. associate with devotees only. Guru Sahib has not written any exceptions; therefore, we should not assume any exceptions" is Bhai Rama Singh wrong in his view on this matter as per the earlier post or did this not actually occur? --------------------------- You ask me if Bhai Rama Singh was wrong in his views. I think this is an unfair question from you. What if I ask you, “Was Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee wrong in his views?” Few years ago, Bhai Rama Singh jee came to Toronto and blessed us by coming to our house. I will tell you this very honestly and I say this considering Siri Guru jee with me. He visited us and while there, he expressed his displeasure at having two langars at the Gurdwara Sahib. In those days, a special arrangements were made at Brampton Gurdwara Sahib for bibekis, during akj samagams. At that point, my relatives who opposed our bibek rehit and were also sitting there, tried to exploit the situation by asking Bhai Rama Singh jee more questions on Bibek and rehit. I will not go into details on what Bhai Rama Singh jee said as there is no need for that. Anyway, I asked Bhai Rama Singh jee if he what Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee had written on bibek and how strongly he observed Bibek, was a wrong practice. Bhai Rama Singh jee pondered for few moments and said in his typical Uttar-Pradeshi accent, “Bhai Sahib tau bahut mahaan thay. Unkay jaisa kaun ho sakta hai. Jo unho nay kaha hai, sabh sahee hai” (Bhai Sahib was very great. Who can be like him? What he has written and said is all correct). Bhai Rama Singh jee fully endorsed bibek, just as Bhai Jeevan Singh jee does. Their comments were taken out of context, by some ignorant people. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bibek

jorawar · 19 Apr 2004

kulbir singh, i have noticed that you use your words cleverly get around the subject. they have no relevance what so ever, but you bring up points that make no sense and stand by them to somehow show people that your right, it seems. you also use counter arguments which also make no sense in your argument. i dont mean to be rude but i have noticed this on many posts.

Re: Bibek

uk S · 19 Apr 2004

I don't see how their (Bhai Rama Singh Ji's) comments can be taken out of context as they proved their point practically by eating Langar. Your post seems to state that what they did practically themselves does not coincide with their own rehni banie.

Re: Bibek

Kulbir Singh · 19 Apr 2004

------ kulbir singh, i have noticed that you use your words cleverly get around the subject. they have no relevance what so ever, but you bring up points that make no sense and stand by them to somehow show people that your right, it seems. you also use counter arguments which also make no sense in your argument. i dont mean to be rude but i have noticed this on many posts. -------- Dhanvaad hai hazoor-e-meharvaan daa, for his kind words. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bibek

Kulbir Singh · 19 Apr 2004

Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh! -------- I don't see how their (Bhai Rama Singh Ji's) comments can be taken out of context as they proved their point practically by eating Langar. Your post seems to state that what they did practically themselves does not coincide with their own rehni banie. --------- By saying that Bhai Rama Singh jee did not keep bibek, you are trying to prove that he was against bibek. I on the other hand am saying that i agree that he may not have kept a strict bibeki rehit but he agreed with this rehit of bibek and was not opposed to it. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 19 Apr 2004

If something is a question of love and if it is prepared with love, then how far can we take it? I agree that hurting someone's feelings is a horrible thing to do. It is wrong to harshly refuse someone who is lovingly offering food. But let me give you an example from my pre-bibek days about 5 years ago. I went to a Greek friend's home to do some school work. After finishing our work, we went downstairs to the family room and as it happened, I believe it was Greek Easter (I think that was the holiday...). Their family had prepared some traditional bread and were about to do some famly ceremony called "breaking the bread" and they lovingly invited me to join this family ceremony. I looked at the bread and at that point, I did not know much about bibek and did eat food from outside. But I did not eat any meat or eggs. The question arose in my mind, does this bread have any eggs in it? I did not know how to ask. They had invited me to join clearly a family ceremony out of respect, but how could I be sure that the bread had no eggs? I gathered all my courage and finally asked, "Does the bread have any eggs?" The mother answered, "yes". And I politely explained that I didn't eat anything with eggs. My friend had a hurt and surprised look in his eyes, and his mother and father also seemed a bit taken back. They then asked why I didn't eat any eggs or meat and I explained why. They then went on to tell me they understood and how they wished more Greek children stood by their traditions as well. I've had to refuse milkshakes presented by friends, cookies, etc. All in the same way. All before bibek. So how far can we take the love factor? I know that bibek is a rehit of Guru Sahib. So to keep this rehit, if I have to politely refuse some food, I will. I will try my best to do so lovingly and show I don't reject them, just that I can't eat that food, but I will not violate my own rehit. I hope that makes sense.

Re: Bibek

uk S · 19 Apr 2004

I on the other hand am saying that i agree that he may not have kept a strict bibeki rehit but he agreed with this rehit of bibek and was not opposed to it. This is much more clear...

Re: Bibek

kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 19 Apr 2004

VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAAVAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!! I humbly disagree with Bhai Kulbir Singh, "Singh" and Bhai Balpreet Singh First - my bias: I do not keep sarblohee bibek. I do not eat out from restaurants, but that is it. Second - me in those shoes: If my relative owned a restaurant and made food for me with pyaar, I don't know what I would do. It might be tough. The decision would depend on the circumstances and the atmosphere of the restaurant - if it was purely vegetarian and it was run with dedication to that maryada - like some "sikh-owned" Pizza Shops in Surrey Third - generally: I think "bibek singh" (the original poster) - if he drank the milk seeing the love, then your gursikhi is dhan dhan. Bhai Chaupa Singh has written "pritham rehit" is khande-ke-pahul. And I respect Bhai Chaupa Singh. But I think for my father, Guru Gobind Singh, the real "pritham rehit" is PREM. And when PREM is involved, things change. Of course Bhai Balpreet Singh you may try to take it to extremes - but we are talking about milk here, and nothing else. YES, somebody could prepare us an alcoholic drink or a meat dish with prem but that is a different story. I think KUREHITS are above bibek. Therefore if somebody, with upmost shardaa and prem, prepares something for you, AND THEY DIDN'T KNOW YOU KEEP BIBEK, and the thing they prepared for you would not cause you to commit a kurehit, I think it is acceptable. If somebody KNOWS you keep bibek and still tries to make you non-bibeki food, that is not real prem because they aren't recognizing your personal commitment. But if they are doing it with "bhola bhaao" ... well that's the key to God there... innocent and honest love... for the Guru, for a Sikh, for waheguru. As long as it doesn't break a kurehit, I think it is honourable to accept that food from the person. and i'd just like to say here - if anybody posts please avoid say "but what if..." - because every situation is subjective, and bibek budhee comes from gurbani vichar and pyaar, and whoever has it can exercise it. please forgive my mistakes -daas VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAAVAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!!

Re: Bibek

Kulbir Singh · 19 Apr 2004

Dear "kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n)", Your post is based on emotions and not facts of Gurmat. You talked about "Prem" and referred to Dashmesh Pita. What kind of prem with Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee would let you eat from someone and violate hukam of Siri Guru jee. On one hand is prem of Guru Sahib and on the other hand is prem of that worldly person whose heart you don't want to break. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bibek

kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 19 Apr 2004

VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAAVAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!! Bhai Kulbir Singh jee, When Bhai Kannhaiyaa Jee gave water too wounded soldiers - he wasn't looking at Moghuls or Sikhs. He saw Guru gobind Singh in each jeev. His prem was not for the moghul or the sikh. He was in a state of brahmgyaan "sagal sang ham ko ban aaee" ... this is gurmat of Bhai Kannhaiyaa Jee, a gursikh of our father Guru Gobind Singh. If somebody innocently does not know that you keep bibek, and they make food for you that does not force you to commit a kurehit, how in the world can accepting this person's food is be equated to losing the prem of Guru Sahib?. I don't think our sacha patshah Guru Gobind Singh sahib would take his deedaar away from us if we saw his parthakh joth in a non-bibeki sajjan and accepted the bhojan made with prem bhaavNaa. Please forgive me if i am out of line - please tell me how accepting this food would lose Guru Sahib's pyaar. VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAAVAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!!

Re: Bibek

Mkhalsa · 19 Apr 2004

About Bhai Rama Singh Jee, He was a great gursikh, he could feel what people had in their hearts and minds. He actually KNEW when something was cooked with love. For those of us who don't have such powers, we rely on what we can see/know. Another example is Bhai sahib bhai jeevan singh jee. I have personally witnessed him (when he kept some bibek) refuse food from an amritdhari bibi (who was known not to wash her hands and did a lot of gossip) and accept something from a mona who made something for him with true love. Bhai sahib smiled at him as if he knew him well and ate the food as if it was made with so much naam abhyaas. Bhai sahib knew how much love these people had and what their karams were. Even bhai randhir singh jee had such powers. Why do we even talk about their perceptions of love when we cant even approach that level of awareness? stop using gursikhs and sakhis where not all evidence is presented as proof for your dhils.

Re: Bibek

ns · 20 Apr 2004

Kulbir Singh Jeo, and everyone jee, I wasn't trying in anyway to twist Guru sahiban Ji's saki as to parcahar that bibek shouldn't be observed.What I 'm trying to say is "reet" overcame "preet" for Guru Sahib. In a similar situation I cannot hesitate it overcame for Bhai Rama Singh Ji therefore he took langar.I 'm not also questioning why Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji kept bibek either.It is all about understanding Prem/love.Prem is a parameter which is very hard to measure by a third party hence we have this debate!!. Just as music is a parameter which has an effect on our minds which cannot be experienced by third party prem works in a similar fashion but that's another point. Balpreet Singh Ji's argument is cool, I have done the same thing many times to my gora friends. However if it was a gora and he made me that milk as in the original argument similarly I wouldn've taken it due to the parameters of prem which occurs within one's mind to go the extra effort and also due to the quotes from SGGS below. Going back to the original point of discussion milk was made and taken out, there was prem which led to this effort. Kulbir Singh Ji when you mention at one point about Bhai Rama Singh Ji "I on the other hand am saying that i agree that he may not have kept a strict bibeki rehit but he agreed with this rehit of bibek and was not opposed to it. " I fully agree on this point it makes it clear, but you do also say Bhai Sahib ji blessed your house when he came over, so therefore you accept he was a Gursikh of some avasthaa even though he may not have kept full strict bibek. And when you mention above : "On one hand is prem of Guru Sahib and on the other hand is prem of that worldly person whose heart you don't want to break" you mention worldy person, doesn't this worldy person have any feelings?, is he/she an alien to society?, he/she don't they have God's Johot inside them? didn;t bhai Ghanaya Ji see Guru Sahib Ji's face in all the enemy he was giving water to? As this is going to be interesting debate here are few quotes which relate to my argument that indeed it would have been OK to take that milk from sardar sahib who may not be a bibeki Sikh but had those feelings inside of prem which made him to go the extra effort and make that milk and take it to you. Ghat ghat vaseh jaaneh thoraa: God dwells in each and every Heart, but only a few know this (sggs 562). Bholae bhaae milae raghuraaeiaa: Through innocent Love, God is met (sggs 324). Maanas kee jaat sabai ekai pahchaanabo: Recognize the entire mankind as one family Saach kahon sun leho sabhai jin prem keeo tin hee prabh paaio: Listen all, I tell you the Truth: One who practices love attains God (Paatshaahee 10). only learning bhul chuk maaf. [%sig%]

Re: Bibek

Another Singh · 20 Apr 2004

Veer Kulbir Singh and Balpreet Singh Jeeo, I'd like to ask a question. I agree with Bibaik and Sarbloh Bibaik. I understand the benefits to somebody who is Naam Abiaasee and how food can affect our mental state. I don't keep Bibaik myself - I just make sure I don't eat anything that is not vegetarian. I would like to be in a situation where keeping Sarbloh bibaik would be more possible for me. I accept that a some of it is most probably just laziness on my part. But my concern is that if I keep Sarbloh Bibaik as I am now, without keeping the Internal Rehits as described in Gurbani, then I would effectively be putting on a show for others or even for myself. I mean, if I don't practice contentment, honesty, compassion, controlling of 5 thieves, Amrit Vela, Naam and Bani, then I would not feel any much better for keeping Sarbloh, nor do I think it would help me spiritually. My point is that I feel I need to develop my internal Rehit before my external Rehit. Do you feel this is a sensible way forward, given that I'm not able to keep all Rehit instantly? I feel that Sarbloh Bibaik is a higher-level external Rehit than say not cutting hair. Would you agree that some Rehits can't be kept instantly and that one should develop other (more basic/internal) aspects of Rehit before one will feel the ability to keep higher-level Rehits? Look forward to your responses.

Re: Bibek

k4ur · 20 Apr 2004

i think u need to ask urself wot bibek actually means so jan ralaaeiaa naa ralai jis a(n)thar bibaek beechaar ||2|| Those humble beings who are filled with keen understanding and meditative contemplation-even though they intermingle with others, they remain distinct. sacho sach vakhaaneeai sacho budhh bibaek || So speak the Truest of the True. Through the True One, an intuitive and discerning mind is obtained. these r onli a few examples frm the guru granth sahib jee. in both cases bibek is sed to mean distinct..with descerning mind(discriminating mind)...where dus it sey nething bout eating food which has only bin made by amritdharis? if one cnt eat food made by non-amritdharis...for example bread--shouldnt they go and plant the wheat..so on and so forth, and i no many "bibek"hoo dnt, so dus this mean they arent truly bibeki?...bibek means pure frm the inside lets not mistake it for nething else..... please forgive for ne mistakes.......fateh [%sig%]

Re: Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 20 Apr 2004

We have this same discussion so often on this board, it's getting a bit redundant and I'm thinking that in the future we should read the old discussions and if our questions aren't answered there, only then should we post about bibek. Anyways, let's try to go through these points. Kar Kirpaa veer jee asked how accepting this milk would reduce our pyaar for Guru Sahib. Especially knowing that there is akali jot in everyone. See, there is akali jot in all of creation, it doesn't mean we accept all of it. There is akali jot in the worst person and in the best person. How does it reduce love? I think that if Guru Sahib tells a Sikh to do something (ie. keep dietary bibek and sarbloh), a Sikh will die, but not compromise on that hukam. Look at Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee, he almost died in prison but would not compromise because he loved Guru Sahib too much. Would Guru Sahib not have "understood" that Bhai Sahib was in such a horrible situation and an exception could perhaps have been made? It didnt' matter. Bhai Sahib had so much love for Guru Sahib, that Guru Sahib's hukam came above all else. No bending that hukam for anything. Stuff made in prem may not necessarily be made correctly even. I mentioned a milkshake I refused earlier. See, that milkshake was made in fact by a Sikh. It was a very hot day and that bhain jee was in fact VERY pregnant who made it. She went and made this milkshake for me and when it was given to me, (again, I wasnt' bibekee), I wanted to drink it and saw the effort she put in, but I got the doubt that perhaps there is egg in the ice cream she used. Again, using all the courage I could muster, I asked if I could see the box, and yes, it had egg. I had to refuse it. I could've seen the prem and accepted but it would've violated my rehit. You can't know if the person understands about rehit, and that's another reason why we restrict who we eat from. "prem" is not a good argument, in that a lot of things done with good intentions, and requests made with respect/love just cant' be fulfilled. I've had people ask to see my kesh, hold my kirpan, etc. And they asked with genuine respect, but I can't accept these request. 2ndly re. Bibek. Dietary Bibek is only a portion of Gurmat Bibek. Gurmat Bibek includes Naam Abhyaas, Keertan, and other outter rehits like ishnaan, seva, baaNaa. But Dietar Bibek is a very BIG part of that outter rehit and is a MUST. But at the same time, Bhain jee asked if it will help spiritually. If you keep basic rehit (avoid 4 kurehits, keep 5 kakaars, read Nitnem banis, give dasvandh) then dietary bibek will help you. But if you think that just by keeping bibek you can become a spiritual Gursikh, you are mistaken. Bibek is an assitant karam that can help spiritually, but if you do no naam abhyaas and no paath, then it is of no use. But like I said, if you keep even basic rehit, then it will help. 3rdly, for K4aur Bhain jee, Dietary Bibek is covered in BaaNee. Please see the article in the Gurmat section. But Bibek is, like said, much bigger than just food. And as for getting wheat, etc. I say if you can do it, and grow wheat with naam abhyaas more power to you. But the definition of bibek is to get raw supplies and then have them cooked by an amritdhari who is reciting baaNee or meditating on naam. It all boils down to this: know the information and then make your own decisions. I know bibek is a rehit and I think it must be followed. But others can use their own minds to figure out whether it is Gurmat or not.

Re: Bibek

yes · 20 Apr 2004

I don't think you can compare eating meat,eggs to sarbloh bibek. Eating meat is a bujjer kurrehit so you would not be able to accept it.

Re: Bibek

Mkhalsa · 20 Apr 2004

Its STILL rehat!! No matter HOW small!

Re: Bibek

Mkhalsa · 20 Apr 2004

All of you arguing against bibek in this thread are basically saying its OK to violate rehat so that you dont hurt another persons feelings. Right?

Re: Bibek

Kulbir Singh · 21 Apr 2004

---------------- When Bhai Kannhaiyaa Jee gave water too wounded soldiers - he wasn't looking at Moghuls or Sikhs. He saw Guru gobind Singh in each jeev. His prem was not for the moghul or the sikh. He was in a state of brahmgyaan "sagal sang ham ko ban aaee" ... this is gurmat of Bhai Kannhaiyaa Jee, a gursikh of our father Guru Gobind Singh. -------------- Veer “Kar Kirpa jeeo”, your comparison of Bhai Ghanahiya jee giving water to Mughals, with eating from non-devotees does not make too much sense to me. How are these two things related? Giving water to non-Sikhs is Gurmat whereas taking food from non-Sikhs is manmatt. How are you mixing these two and considering them same? By giving water to non-Sikhs, Bhai Ghanahiya jee was fulfilling his duty of a Sikh. When it comes to serving, we can serve anyone in sight. We can give degh (Karaah Parshaad) to everyone who comes to Gurdwara Sahib but if we use this logic of serving degh to everyone and say that since we can give degh to everyone, so everyone should have the right to serve degh to everyone, would it make sense to you. How much sense would this make? Same way, giving water to Mughals was nothing but Gurmat but this does not mean that we should start eating from anyone, without having any regard to Guru Sahib’s rehit. Bhai Ghanahiya jee’s service to Mughals was not a violation of any Gurmat principle but taking food from a non-devotee is a gross violation of Gurmat Bibek. If we give the argument that Vaheguru’s jyot is in everyone and everything, and as such we should not discriminate against anyone, then we will also have to accept that Tobacco, liquor, meat etc too have jyot of Vaheguru and as such we should consume these detestable items. --------- If somebody innocently does not know that you keep bibek, and they make food for you that does not force you to commit a kurehit, how in the world can accepting this person's food is be equated to losing the prem of Guru Sahib?. ----------- Food of non-devotee is haraam (prohibited) to us, as per Gurbani. By not accepting hukam of Guru Sahib and by accepting food of non-devotee, we do a kurahit. Yes this kurahit is not a bajjar kurahit but it still is a kurahit big enough to warrant peshi with Punj Pyaaray or local sangat. If we break bibek, we have to go to the local sangat at Gurdwara Sahib and get ardaas done by them. Please read Multan Jail chapter of Jail Chithiyaan for more details. ----------- I don't think our sacha patshah Guru Gobind Singh sahib would take his deedaar away from us if we saw his parthakh joth in a non-bibeki sajjan and accepted the bhojan made with prem bhaavNaa. --------- And, I don’t think “our sacha patshah Guru Gobind Singh Sahib” would appreciate us breaking his rehit for trivial reasons. Why would it break someone’s heart, if we show our unwillingness in eating their food, due to Guru Sahib's rehit? If this person has any sense and has real prem for you and Guru Sahib, we could explain to this person that it is a rehit of Guru Sahib to not eat from non-amritdhaaris. If explained properly, this person may one day adopt this rehit. If this person becomes upset at hearing about bibek, then we can surely tell that this person is a selfish person whose only interest is to make you eat food, perhaps to satisfy his ego, and has no regard for Guru Sahib's rehit. If such a person gets upset, despite explaining everything to him, then let this person stay upset. Guru Sahib’s rehit is more important than anything else. These are all tests of Guru Sahib to see how tenaciously we can hold on to Guru Sahib's rehit. Khalsa jeeo, don't fail these tests. Keep rehit at all costs. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bibek

ns · 21 Apr 2004

Kulbir SIngh Jee, The points you make here are valid enough, then why don't the AKJ panch make it mandatory to have this rehat when in amrit sanchar. I will read the above as menitoned and try and understand. Thanks for taking time out and pointing reference. Thanks for taking time out to explain the above points. Narinder

Re: Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 21 Apr 2004

Bibek is a Mandatory rehit and it was certainly given during amrit sinchaars in the past. In recent years because of the people doing seva in the punj pyaaray, this rehit was presented as optional since the punj pyaaray themselves did not follow it. But in Bhai Sahib's time when he did seva in the punj pyaaray, Sarbloh bibek was set out as a mandatory rehit. Gurmat Bibek makes this clear.

Re: Bibek

A Singh · 22 Apr 2004

"Singh S " asked:- "Are you trying to say that Bhai Randhir SIngh Jee was wrong for keeping strict babek while in Jail for years? He could have broken his Babek to make friends, but no! for him friendship with Guru Jee was more important than any worldly friendship." Bhaji, please could you tell where (a) I have referred to Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh in my post and (b) where I have indicated that he was wrong. I asked a simple question and that was following Narinder's post, and comments by "Kulbir Singh" stating, "foremost priority is Guru Sahib's rehit and obeying Guru Sahib's hukams. In Gurbani, Guru Sahib has instructed us to keep bibek i.e. associate with devotees only. Guru Sahib has not written any exceptions; therefore, we should not assume any exceptions" is Bhai Rama Singh wrong in his view on this matter as per the earlier post or did this not actually occur? I ask as both Bhai Sahibs are regarded as great Gursikhs and hence it does seem strange to find them having seemingly contradictory views/examples? Hope this clarifies. For the record, I am not saying anyone is wrong, I simply wish to understand correctly, why we as Sikhs can only eat from other (Amritdhari) Sikhs -for explaining this is difficult at times when offerred food by non-amritdharis (particularly family relatives, in some instances one's own mother). I am not saying we need to bring "dhil" in our rehit or even that we should compromise Guru Sahib for "friends", but I wish to have a better understanding of (1) Bibek and (2) Sarablohi Bibek which I haven't been able to get from the articles on this site as yet, although I am working on my own bibek right now and for this reason wish to understand rather than rely on (blind) faith alone. I guess what I'm trying to say is, the reasons given to date in articles would imply that all non-Amritdharis are in the same category as Malik Bhago, even one's own mother! Ok, someone is going to say tell her to take Amrit, but if she's Amritdhari but not Sarablohi Bibeki, then the same applies! Is this true, that under these conditions she would fall in the Malik Bhago category? Essentially whenever I've tried to explain it, no matter how I try and phrase it, it sounds as "Sauchna" / "Shootak-pootak" or issues of "Pollution" which are closely linked with Brahmins and their attitudes to non-Brahmins. Yes, we know that this is not the case, but the problem then arises, when running out of nice ways to explain the bibek, one turns to saying it is Guru Sahib's Hukam and I follow it thus -only problem, this at times seems like we are blaming Guru Sahib for our lack of ability to convey the message properly, consequently, it seems to some that our Guru Sahib is invoking Brahmin type "pollution" / "shootak-pootak" issues. Please can some of the more experienced Sarabloh Bibeki Singhs and Singhness help out with a sensible way of explaining this practice, as this is some faced on a daily basis. Thank you.

Re: Bibek

kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 22 Apr 2004

I am in the same line of thinking as "A Singh" and the articles and discussions thus far have not been able to convince me in the real relevance of not eating from non-sarblohees to reaching sach khand.

Re: Bibek

Balpreet Singh · 22 Apr 2004

What conclusive proof can anyone possibly give you that sarbloh is spiritually useful? We've given examples of so many Gursikhs who have done it. We've given historical examples and quotations from rehitnamas. It is clearly a tradition in the Panth. But if someone still doesn't believe it, then what can anyone say? It's like arguing with someone who says "I dont' believe that sugar is sweet" but hasn't ever tasted it nor wants to taste it. Ok, if you belive that, that's fine. Kar Kirpa..., You said "the articles and discussions thus far have not been able to convince me in the real relevance of not eating from non-sarblohees to reaching sach khand" Let's take that sentence, and remove "not eating from non-sarblohees" (note, the correct statement would have been non-amritdhaarees)and substitute the word "Kangha". Have you been convinced about the relevance of keeping a kangha to going to sachkhand? How about a white kacherra? The relevance is that they are all hukam or the Guru who is going to take us to sachkhand. End of story.

Re: Bibek

Sohanganee · 22 Apr 2004

Veers, Bhain's: Why do we keep talking about this? Some people believe that keeping Dietary Bibek is Hukam of Guru Sahib Jee, and some people don't. Both parties have equally good supporting arguments. That's just the way it is. Some will keep it over thier lives, and some won't give it a second thought. Who's wrong and who's right? If you believe it's Hukam, then keep it. If you believe it's not Hukam, then don't. It's as simple as that. Bibekee's will do parchaar for it, and non-Bibekee's will do parchaar against it. I wonder if there was even a point to writing this post, since it won't really make a difference. ...and so the world goes on. At the end of the day it's our ideas that separate us. [%sig%]

Re: Bibek

Mkhalsa · 22 Apr 2004

Balpreet Singh, you are right there! because of everyone always fighting over bibek and sarbloh bibek I am more sure that these are rehats of guru sahib (due to evidence that keeps coming up every discussion) than kanga or even taking a bath every morning, or many other rehats which dont have NEARLY the amount of evidence that bibek has. We are so westernized in that we are looking for some constitution to sikhi that lays everything out with explanations and details with guru sahibs signature at the bottom: NOT gonna happen!!

Re: Bibek

A Singh · 23 Apr 2004

Balpreet Singh Bhaji, Your response has missed all our questions and has further confused me. Again, I am working on my own bibek and really need help with this for myself and for practically putting this into my life, which clearly involves social-aspects since I as a Grishti Singh am not a hermit living in a cave or forest and have interaction with my family, friends and colleagues, who are not all Amritdhari let alone Sarabloh Bibeki! So for the record, I am not challenging Sarablohi Bibek or even Bibek (not eating from other Amritdharis), and I am well aware of the references to this in some historical sources (mainly the Bhai Desa Singh rehitnama). However, this alone does not suffice, as this only indicates that this is as you say “a tradition” within the panth when compared with matters such as the 5 Kakkars which are found unanimously across all puratan and modern rehit literature, sarablohi bibek for me is clearly more specialised –note again, before any one gets paranoid, I am not arguing pro-or-against Sarablohi Bibek, I need help with mine and hence want better understanding: as I have stated, I am do not wish to rely on (blind) faith ‘alone’. As the cyber-sadh-sangat, I trust that you will be able to help in this regard. Your examples of the white kachera or khanga are misfounded comparisons, as they do not pose the same issue as Sarablohi Bibek. Allow me to expand, (I’m not talking about reaching Sach Khand, I’m asking for practically living Gursikhi), keeping Amrit Vela Nitnem and 5Ks rehit is a personal matter and each aspect can be explained for their purpose, practical and spiritual or otherwise. Sarablohi bibek to date is explained by two reasons, (1) to eat from only other (Sarablohi) Bibeki Amritdharis and (2) to eat and cook in Sarabloh as respect for Loh (as indicated in the celestial writings of Guru Gobind Singh), the nutritional value derived from the Iron vessel and as many have recently suggested, the mystical aid of Sarabloh to one’s simran/spiritual lifestyle (see all articles on this site and also on MKhalsa’s site). I have no issue with (2) regardless of what scientific issues sceptics make present, however must ask if this is a recommendation or is to be so strict that any food cooked in say a non-sarabloh item, albeit by an Amritdhari is to be rejected. My question relates particularly to part (1), I am aware of issues concerning saliva exchange and so on, however the matter remains if a non-Sarablohi Amritdhari cooks food and from that vessal (i.e one for serving that no-one is eating out of) serves you your portion of the food, this is then deemed ‘haraam’ according to this maryada. Likewise, if one’s own Mother is this person, this makes her food haraam –ok, let’s just say that this is fine, and we explain this using the Rehitnama and examples of Malik Bhago, we immediately come across two issues. The rehitnama is specialised and contains many other aspects which are also controversial, moreover Shivites in Punjab are typically found to favour Loh (Iron) given its connotations with the goddess-cult, so I’ve run into all sorts of trouble here, but this much aside, the main issue is, explaining the requirement for Bibek ultimately implies that we as Sarablohi Bibek Amritdharis are not able to share food with others to the extent that even if they cook in the prescribed manner they still fall into the ‘Malik Bhago’ category regardless of what type of person they actually are, hence the bottom line being that we do not wish to get ‘polluted’ by them and back to the ‘shootak-pootak’ issue. Simply saying that we are doing it because the rehit is prescribed as such is fine for me personally, but not when it comes to represent Sikhi to others, all it shows is gross lack of ‘actual’ understanding, lots of ‘blind faith’ and an attitude similar to Mohammedans rather than Sikhs. It is for this reason, I ask what I do, we are all ambassadors of the Panth by virtue of our dastaars and kakkars and I wish to do this justice. Aspects such as food are so crucial to social engagement (grisht) that food is used universally in building bridges and fostering relations (even we do it through langer for all), again I am not saying we bow down to social pressures, my questions are aired, since I wish to live Sikhi and manage these social pressures properly without giving the impression to all and sundry that Sikhs are effectively no better than self-obsessed Bhramins who only consider themselves as clean and regard all others as polluted. Please help with your thoughts and recommendations.

Re: Bibek

Mkhalsa · 23 Apr 2004

A Singh Jee, You are a bit confused. There are different levels of sarblohi bibek. Most of the sarblohi bibekis I know will eat from ANY amritdhari as long as it is made in sarbloh, some will just eat it in sarbloh. Others will not eat from amritdharis who dont keep keski as kakkar (ie if they beleive it is kakkar, they cannot eat from someone who neglects to wear a kakkar) some will only eat from other bibeksi, others from other sarblohis. Personally I eat from amritdharis in sarbloh. This is a personal choice because there are not many sarblohi bibekis around here etc etc. Perhaps this will change (for the better) once I have finished university and gotten married and all of that. See what fits you now.

Re: Bibek

ns · 24 Apr 2004

Sorry to go on with this debate , but A. Singh Ji also has very valid points. I somtimes think if Guru Ji was here in physical form , how long would we be debating on this topic. A noble prze winner once said "the essence of debate is to progress" we are so far away from this one line, and this does include me.it has to go on till we progress. My point mainly was why the panj in the AKJ don't have it mandatory, Balpreet Singh Ji answered that they used to , but due to most not practising bibek they don't have it as mandatory anymore. I think there is more to it than that, I feel they are merely following the Akal Takht example and rehat maryada which is excellent for them to do so, and I hope it continues that way , the panj are respecting sarbat khalsa and akal takht rehat maryada. I am not against bibek in any way , it's understanding the social issue etc. To be honest if leave bibek out it for a minute and for example ponde on this quote: Onhee mandai pair na rakhio kar sukarit dharam kamaaiaa. Onee duniyaa torhe bandhnaa ann paanee thorhaa khaayaa: They (the truest of the true) do not do sin, but do good deeds and live righteously in Dharma. They burn away the bonds of the world, and eat a simple diet of grain and water (sggs 467) How many of us can certainly say at the moment that they have tried this diet of grain and water, let alone sarbloh or bibek, I certainly haven't? We talk about sachkand through sarbloh or not, we are far far away, Guru Ji menitons such as : Mann rasak rasak har ras aaghaanay fir bahur na bhookh lagaavai: My mind is immersed in, and drenched with the Divine Essence. Fulfilled with the Love of the Self, I will never feel hunger again (sggs 172). Could the sarbloh practising Gursikhs on this forum , tell us how many times do they eat in a day, has sarbloh given the spirituality level where you eat far less than the normal amritdhari Sikh?? Bhul Chuk Maaf Narinder

Re: Bibek

A Singh · 26 Apr 2004

MKhalsa Bhaji, thanks again for your help, I didn't realise there were different types of Bibek. I must ask now, sorry but you are right, I am extremely confused, but grateful for your and the forums help in explaining things to me, however if there are so many types of Bibek asyou described, what qualifies as correct? Afterall, saying work with what works best for me, is a little too vague (imagine applying this to the other Punj Kakkars or Rehits), what is to say, Gursikhs will not still consider me to be non-bibeki even if I maintain Bibek insofar as I can, fo example, at present, if all else remained as it were, this is the best I could hope for:- Cook in Sarabloh insofar as possible (i.e. at home only, for no facilities as work and certainly none during lengthy travels with work, often far from any near Gurdwara or location and much of resting time spent on planes). Cook Pinia as meal-replacements where possible (however 2 week road show with work for a new product, will be hard, I often have to dine with board members and colleagues -usually request fresh salads and/or veg food, but this will break Bibek for sure) ...I can go on, but I trust you get the picture...

Re: Bibek

Mkhalsa · 26 Apr 2004

What is the correct or most strict level of food bibek? Where one only eats from tyaar bar tyaar naam abhyaasi gursikhs who are also very strict in sarbloh bibek. They would only eat from absolute scratch, ie milk on cow, grind wheat, churn butter. I think thats ultimate. But unfortunately this is not possible here, plus the fact that I myself am too weak to come to such a stage at this point in my life. Perhaps once/if I ever become a naam abhyaasi gursikh. The lowest level of food bibek I would think is avoiding meat, alcohol, tobacco. There is obviously a wide array of different levels in there from not eating out, to only eating from amritdharis, not eating processed food, eating only in sarbloh etc.. And this does kind of show that for those that say they arent following any food bibek, or even ridicule it, they themselves follow SOME LEVEL of bibek, unless they do take meat, alcohol and tobacco. I also want to point out that if you are eating out at restaurants, or even eating processed foods, you are most likely still a meat eater. I know this may come as a shock and I continue to point out foods to singhs that have meat in it. This is why I avoid processed food. So much of our foods have some kind of meat in it, from breads with lards (but with different or confusing names) to peanut butter with the same lard. When we eat out there is a LOT of contamination, not to mention huge chance of jhoot. Prego sauces, most campbells products all have hidden meat in it which the company doesnt legally have to list. If one really cares about not eating meat, they would have to follow a stricter level of bibek just to avoid meat in this world.

Re: Bibek

Kaur · 27 Apr 2004

>>>Could the sarbloh practising Gursikhs on this forum , tell us how many times do they eat in a day, has sarbloh given the spirituality level where you eat far less than the normal amritdhari Sikh?? <<<< Obviously there is an ideal that every sikh aims for in thier path to Vaheguru ji. I have heard this type of argument many times and it is so pointless. If we do not try going towards that ideal of a gursikh, then how are we to ever reach it? If we cannot even accept not eating from non-amritdharees becuase its too hard or whatever, then how are we to ever reach that stage that you mention of not having any need for tastes. Instead of using this ideal as an excuse, why not try to achieve that ideal instead.

Re: Bibek

ns · 29 Apr 2004

Kaur Ji, I understand we must try to reach that level as you correctly point out, and beleive me I am trying, but why is it a crime to ask such a question as a learning Gursikh? So therefore I ask again : Could the sarbloh practising Gursikhs on this forum , tell us how many times do they eat in a day, has sarbloh given the spirituality level where you eat far less than the normal amritdhari Sikh?? Many Thanks Narinder

Re: Bibek

Singh · 29 Apr 2004

ns, I have been keeping sarbloh bibek for about 2.5 years now and I can tell you, I usually eat once a day. I think it's best to eat twice a day though. But I weigh as much as I have always weighed and can go quite some time without eating. I have often gone 2 days without any food. This isn't on purpose of course, but just due to circumstances that can arise. I don't feel hunger pains and I don't feel particularly tired if I don't eat. So to answer your question: yes, I do eat less than most people and most of the bibekee Singhs I know have also naturally reduced the amount of food they require. Hunger is really not much of a problem anymore. I know my parents get very impatient and anxious if they miss a meal, as do most people, but I can happily say that with Guru Sahib's kirpaa, it reallyh doesn't matter to me if I miss a whole day, let alone a meal.

Re: Bibek

ns · 29 Apr 2004

Singh Jeeo , Many Thanks for sharing the above information. Mann rasak rasak har ras aaghaanay fir bahur na bhookh lagaavai: My mind is immersed in, and drenched with the Divine Essence. Fulfilled with the Love of the Self, I will never feel hunger again (sggs 172). Thanks again, Sarbloh bibek is complex for fools such as myself to understand fully, hence my involvement in this debate, I promise myself it will be the last ,as this time it was quite fruitful.